Reign_In_Blood_89
11.15.07 | You are not allowed to make anymore lists due to the fact that you believe that the MCR guitarist is better than Dimebag, Kirk Hammett, Santana, and Jimmy Page...You sir are a retard. Thank you for your time. |
heavy metal kid
11.15.07 | With the amount of shit they take these days, is hard to say that Metallica is overrated. |
Intransit
11.15.07 | YOU ARE NOT ALLOWED TO MAKE LISTS BECAUSE YOU HATE WHAT I LOVE SIR NOW GTFO OF SPUTNIKZ |
tinathefatlard
11.15.07 | hmm, you know i WOULD take your opinions into consideration, but you DID say that Nickleback are NOT overrated, i'm sorry.... |
JumpTheF**kUp
11.15.07 | ^ you moron, he said that they are not overrated in terms of the hate that they get, ie. yes, they are that terrible |
tinathefatlard
11.15.07 | ok, how about you ShutTheFuckUp |
Willie
11.15.07 | These lists always bring the Sputnik community so much closer ;) Oh, and I agree that no one is over rating Metallica these days. |
ASberg
11.15.07 | haha omg i laughed so hard when i saw the comments for this list. You my friend got some heavy hate from Reign right here :D
And yeah, the band i think are the most overrated on this list is coheed and cambria. Metallica get alot of shit right now and zeppelin deserves all the praise they get. |
Phil
11.15.07 | I like the Arcade Fire. |
VicariousIntent
11.15.07 | Those top three are some of my favorite bands... : |
Kiran
11.15.07 | Arcade Fire and Decemberists rule. |
jrowa001
11.15.07 | 5 are far from overrated |
McP3000
11.15.07 | I entirely disagree with this list
except for 3 |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | Hm, I noticed, ASberg. :-P
And I was referring to old Metallica, not new stuff.
You guys are so friendly; this community always makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside. Honestly, grow up. |
TheStarclassicTreatment
11.15.07 | first 2 yes, but 3 is outstanding |
BallsToTheWall
11.15.07 | Metallica is great, rest suck, anybody want to call me out today you rats. Yeah,thats right. |
ASberg
11.15.07 | nah man, old metallica made some of the best metal records of all time. thats a fact :D |
Reign_In_Blood_89
11.15.07 | I agree |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | Metallica is the number one reason why I hated the entire genre of metal for awhile, disregarding as the most persistently boring genre of music ever. Luckily, Opeth came along and saved me from that sad opinion and opened up a whole new world of music that was actually good. Metallica represents the ultimate low to me in a genre I've come to love. |
Dethtrasher
11.15.07 | Where's Opeth? |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | I'm one of those annoying Opeth fanboys.. you'll find them on my "Definitely not overrated at all" list. :) |
Reign_In_Blood_89
11.15.07 | Opeth is overrated. |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | You're just mad that they make Metallica look like Kidz Bop. |
Reign_In_Blood_89
11.15.07 | no your just mad because you can't make a joke to save your sad pathetic life. |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | *scrolls back up*I wasn't aware I joked anywhere... *shrugs*
I don't necessarily think The Decemberists and Arcade Fire are bad bands, I just don't think they deserve the 4.5's and 5's they always seem to get on this site. |
Reign_In_Blood_89
11.15.07 | But you think that fall out boy, coldplay, and deathcab for cutie do. You sir deserve the death penalty. |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | *is having fun* Wow, that's pretty harsh.
*ponders* Hm... am I the only one who thinks that Freebird is the most boring piece of wankery every to hit airwaves? Just throwing it out there... |
Sakkie
11.15.07 | Haha Led Zeppelin wtf? Hahahaha
You are a moron |
botb
11.15.07 | 1 and 2 aren't over-rated. coheed's great but their great too. and i can't take you seriously since you said carlos santana's playing is mindless wanking, or whatever you said along those lines. |
EverythingEvil2113
11.15.07 | Everyone's got their own opinion so I'm not going to call you names or anything, but 1-4 are some of my favorite bands. |
LearntoSwim
11.15.07 | zeppelin is amazing and arcade fire is really talented too but i agree that the rest is shite. |
Electric City
11.15.07 | Oh my, Arcade Fire owns your soul. Apologize. |
CeeBone
11.15.07 | 1. No. They were that good.
2. Now, maybe a bit. But they still helped make metal more mainstream.
3. Agree entirely. I hate everything about this band.
4. No. Fuck you.
5. See 4. Also, Colin Meloy > You.
Arcade Fire and Decemberists are definitely deserving of any high ratings they receive. |
AmericnZero02
11.15.07 | 2 gets a lot of shit these days, so I wouldn't call them overrated anymore. 3 seems like an acquired taste. Either you get used to Claudio's voice and love CoCa or you cant stand him and hate the band. |
ASberg
11.15.07 | this shit is turning ugly, and im in. Sounds like your proud when you say you think metallica are the low point of the genre. Do you even realise how many bands owe their fucking success to metallica? By going into more mainstream territory they helped heavier music into the spotlight. now give them some credit for it. |
Mikesn
11.15.07 | comments make Mike sad
anyways i'm going to judge your list too!
1. yes
2. YES.
3. eh, could go either way
4. nah
5. nah |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.15.07 | ASberg: I DO give them credit for it. Metal most certainly wouldn't be where it is today without Metallica. I enjoy a few songs of theirs, and think "One" is downright genius, at least the first half. I just happen to hate about 90% of their music and think their pre-black album stuff is horrendously overhyped. Metal bands have since topped it. |
fershizzle
11.15.07 | "You guys are so friendly; this community always makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside. Honestly, grow up."
you need to grow up. i thought we decided like a year ago that overrated lists are pointless?
having said that, 2 and 3 suck balls. |
LifeInABox
11.15.07 | Yes, Yes, No, Yes, dk |
Geedrummer
11.15.07 | 1. YES
2. BIG YES
3.you were on a roll but NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO for coheed. of of my all time favs |
Metalikane
11.15.07 | How is it possible for Led Zepplin to be overrated? Its been like 25 or 30 years since they've put out a record that got any acclaim. Its not like you see Zep scene kids walking around the mall saying how their band is better than your band. *See Coheed and Cambria" |
Serpento
11.15.07 | ...
Oh no, I just wanna be included. I agree until 4, but can see why they'd be called overrated. |
DaveBum69
11.16.07 | 4 and 5 I know nothing about, but the first 3 your a retard, you rag on metallica, and coheed and zepplin (who I don't listen to much but I respect cause I have a brain) for favorite bands you have like daphne loves derby, coldplay the goo goo dolls, relient k, switchfoot, but you rag on some of the most renowed bands in the world, no one will care about any of the bands I just named in 30 years, like zepplin |
NOTINTHEFACE
11.16.07 | The argument about who will be rememberd in 30 years is completely irrelevant. Some of the best bands around today aren't even remembered right NOW. And if I had to guess, you know what will most likely remembered as the most important album of the early 2000's by most? American Idiot. I'm not saying it's even a good album, but I'm just trying to show you how society tends to "remember" the best music. |
rudolphhess88
11.16.07 | i agree that after ajfa metallica are shit but their first4 albums revolutionized a genre started by sabbath. Metallica and Led Zep are legends. Overrated? You sir deserve 10 lashes for each great album those two bands put out. by my calculations you are going to be very sore |
Bfhurricane
11.16.07 | If you listened to Physical Graffiti by Led Zeppelin and Ride the Lightning by Metallica you would understand the hype my friend |
Mikesn
11.16.07 | Metallica didn't revolutionize anything |
rudolphhess88
11.16.07 | they didn't? How about a little thing called THRASH metal |
Mikesn
11.16.07 | Overkill and Motorhead were first |
DaveBum69
11.16.07 | replying to the comment above overkill are about the same age as metallica, if not a bit younger, Im not sure casue i don't listen to them |
YouAreMySilence
04.16.08 | i knid of understand way you're saying zeppelin & metallica are overrated, i am not a big fan either or even a fan for that matter. its all about what they did for their time though. |