Bfhurricane
02.16.09 | I say again, this was made by the guys at IGN. I think it's a pretty damn good list though. |
Burn2Burn
02.16.09 | IGN is pretty decent with their metal tbh |
KTV
02.16.09 | i think adam jones deserves a spot. |
Lunarfall
02.16.09 | 9 is way to low, should be top 5 at least |
Anthracks
02.16.09 | boring |
joshuatree
02.16.09 | 5 and 10 should not be on here at all |
ninjuice
02.16.09 | any prog list without Mars Volta or Coheed is fail |
Zoo
02.16.09 | Not having Michael Romeo here is absolutely ridiculous. |
Phantom
02.16.09 | Needs more Coheed and TMV |
SeaAnemone
02.16.09 | 2 and 5 are great, but Omar Rodriguez neeeeds to be on this list. |
TricksterGRex
02.16.09 | Adam Jones is a fag, but anyway it's good to see ELP getting some love. |
KTV
02.16.09 | if by a fag you mean awesome then yes |
SwallowARazor
02.16.09 | Needs Paul from Between the Buried and Me. |
Psyclone
02.16.09 | petrucci woot |
Apostle7
02.16.09 | Coheed...seriously? And is BTBAM prog? |
Jim
02.16.09 | focus awesome |
Mendigo
02.16.09 | fuckin awesome list, probably 4, 5 & 10 are not on the same level as the rest here, but they're awesome as well.
and good to see some list with Focus on it. only thing that's obviosuly wrong is that Gilmour should be higher (#3 probably).
and the recs here are just hilarious (BTBaM? TMV? Coheed? c'mon!) ;)
honestly, atm I can't think of anyone who's missing. |
TheGreatD17
02.16.09 | I don't know about Yes having two guitarists in the top 6 and Greg Lake is more of a bassist than a guitarist, so I would probably replace him and Banks with Brian May and Buckethead, but overall this list is pretty good. |
hellohelicopter
02.16.09 | i'd say this list is pretty accurate. IGN have got it right for once. |
TheStarclassicTreatment
02.16.09 | I would tend to put Petrucci top of this list because his versatility but if you're focusing on how well they play prog then yeah I see your point |
Chewie
02.16.09 | Steve Howe is a fucking demi-god |
pyogeniccortex
02.16.09 | i think you should have mentioned Bill Kelliher, but i noticed the small amount of prog metal |
Bfhurricane
02.17.09 | I was really happy to see Petrucci there. I'd say IGN was on the money.
And to the comments directed at me: learn to read. |
Underachiever
02.21.09 | I hope this isn't in order, because Alex Lifeson, David Gilmour, and Robert Fripp Should be the top 3 |
MUNGOLOID
07.10.09 | a list without omar rodriguez-lopez = fail. |
