ArsMoriendi
06.23.14 | "meh. nothing groundbreaking here. i actually even like amnesiac better."
Amnesiac is the best Radiohead album.
Yeah you summed up 5 pretty well. Cool list, needs Pinkerton. |
BMDrummer
06.23.14 | Oh no |
Ryus
06.23.14 | COOL LIST |
PistolPete
06.23.14 | I have to agree with 2, even though it's very good. The rest I can't speak for. |
StallionMang
06.23.14 | Disagree hard on 4 and 5 but I can see where you're coming from
PT is overrated af tho |
Torontonian
06.23.14 | ^ i think ampetechure is a huge step up from frances. but ya each to his own opinion. P.S i have a real soft spot for PT, they basically got me into prog. |
jtswope
06.23.14 | DT is so overrated agreed but 3 is one of their best. |
jtswope
06.23.14 | I love Amputecture but Frances the Mute is a classic imo. |
RoundOnEndHiInMiddle
06.23.14 | "Cool list, needs Pinkerton"
seriously? lol
|
TheSpaceMan
06.23.14 | agree with 4, its still a good album though |
climactic
06.23.14 | "meh. nothing groundbreaking here"
agreed, so many albums in the mainstream sound just like kid a |
Friday13th
06.23.14 | Agree with 4, but 5 already gets a lot of flak, 3 is amazing so just no, 2 also, and 1 is pretty good. Saying Peter Gabriel Solo doesn't have other good stuff is a fail check Melt. |
Torontonian
06.23.14 | @Friday13th i've heard melt, its decent but damn he did so much better in genesis. still overrated even though decent if you ask me |
JJOMan
06.23.14 | "Cool list, needs Pinkerton."
No |
Cygnatti
06.23.14 | "agreed, so many albums in the mainstream sound just like kid a"
after kid a was released |
BlackLlama
06.23.14 | I think 3 is a classic. Actually the only album I like from them. |
PitchforkArms
06.23.14 | not going to disagree here man |
Torontonian
06.23.14 | ^The life and Times of Tim! love that show. |
NordicMindset
06.23.14 | I like all of these but 1 |
CK
06.23.14 | 2 is the only one I can honestly say is overrated |
MO
06.23.14 | agreed with all but 1 |
YakNips
06.23.14 | Ars agrees with you failed list |
BMDrummer
06.23.14 | lol Yak |
Skoop
06.23.14 | I agree with 3 a little. |
BMDrummer
06.23.14 | DT made some shweet stuff, but they are overrated |
Diamondize
06.23.14 | agreed on 4 |
beefshoes
06.23.14 | Wtf is up with #1?? |
TwigTW
06.23.14 | "agreed, so many albums in the mainstream sound just like kid a"
after kid a was released [2] |
MikeC26
06.23.14 | kid a was influential but it influenced a bunch of shit |
Necrotica
06.23.14 | Amnesiac is my least fave Radiohead |
NordicMindset
06.23.14 | Does anyone rate 1 highly? |
ChoccyPhilly
06.23.14 | How could you hate I&W? and if you don't like IA, I think you could at least agree it's solid. I'd say there's only 1 bad track on that album but Deadwing is better |
Mongi123
06.23.14 | How the hell is 4 "nothing groundbreaking?" |
Verm
06.23.14 | haaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahaahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhaahahahahahhahahaahahahahahahahhahahahaahhahahahahahahahaahahahhahahahhaa, this list made my day |
NordicMindset
06.23.14 | How is 3 the one you hate the most out of all these? |
Gyromania
06.23.14 | 4 and 5 are both of those bands' best albums wtf. totally agreed about 2 though, barring trains and a couple other brilliant songs, that album is a fucking snoozefest |
Mongi123
06.23.14 | I mean idc if you don't like it to each his own, but to call it "nothing groundbreaking" is a little far fetched. |
NordicMindset
06.23.14 | I'll show you groundbreaking... |
ChoccyPhilly
06.23.14 | Bear in mind, back when Kid A was released, britpop was still a massive thing and the majority of radiohead listeners were expecting more of the same alt-rock to feed their minds. However, instead their met but the opening notes of Everything In Its Right place and imagining how popular they are, imagine the shock.
That album led so many people to explore into more challenging eletronic music and that's why I'd call it "groundbreaking" |
Friday13th
06.23.14 | Just because it doesn't sound like older Radiohead doesn't necessarily make it groundbreaking. Yorke says he was inspired by some experimental electronic music like Bjork and the like. Not saying it's totally unoriginal or anything because yeah it does sound unique enough, but I agree that some people think it's the most groundbreaking thing of all time just because Radiohead is the most experimental band they've heard. Check Can, peoples! XD Anyways, Choccy has a good point, and no doubt it was very influential since it was coming from a band famous for a different sound all together. |
Zig
06.23.14 | Don't agree with 5, Prog Rock needs noises.
1, 3 and 4 are so overrated. |
Torontonian
06.23.14 | just so you guys know i like all of these except 1 and 3. the others are good, simply overrated. overrated does not equate to bad. |
idkpokeit
06.23.14 | ............................ |
Torontonian
06.23.14 | ^ i say they're overrated because they unfairly overshadow other good material that also needs attention. They receive more recognition than they deserve i think. |
dante1991
06.24.14 | 3 is an outright prog metal classic. Although there were some before it (Queensryche, Fates etc), it really brought the genre to the forefront. DT have never matched the sheer energy of I&W on any of their others tbh |
Tunaboy45
06.24.14 | "let's list popular abums I don't like and call
them overrated" |
Dunpeal
06.24.14 | yeah sputdik will never change
< 3 |
Alondite
06.24.14 | "Kid A" overrated? "Amnesiac" better than "Kid A"? Huh?
"Amnesiac" is just a worse version of "Kid A," and the latter is their best album. "OK Computer" is great, but I feel like everything after "Climbing Up the Walls" (and some before it) is rather average. |
Rowan5215
06.24.14 | Dude Gabriel's self titleds are the fuckin best ever |
scottpilgrim10
06.24.14 | "Cool list, needs Pinkerton"
Noooo [3] |
Tunaboy45
06.24.14 | ^ absolutely not, that album is fantastic. |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | "Let's list popular albums i don't like and call them overrated"
@tunaboy45 i actually like all of these albums except 1 and 3. i'm actually a huge PT and mars volta fan. i actually really liked FtM on my first listen but it hasn't aged well with me, same with IA. and Kid A is alright too. its actually my fave RadioH album behind amnesiac but its not the groundbreaking album its hailed to be. and i just flat out don't like 3. |
facupm
06.25.14 | ok computer is more overrated than kid a |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | ^ya probably. |
NordicMindset
06.25.14 | no |
ChoccyPhilly
06.25.14 | Ok Computer is consistent, but it's nothing mindblowing or "groundbreaking" like Kid A in my mind |
DrGonzo1937
06.25.14 | 4 and 5? GTFO |
Verm
06.25.14 | 2- 5????????????? Plz stop derpin and start djentin |
Killerhit
06.25.14 | 3 is wtf
everything else kind of agree |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | @ChoccyPhilly and it's basically hailed as the best rock album of the nineties. And its really not that. |
adr
06.25.14 | Dream Theater are fucking overrated agreed |
Wadlez
06.25.14 | Plenty of people dislike DT so..... |
TalonsOfFire
06.25.14 | FOAD for 2-4 |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | @TalonsOfFire i see you disagree with my list. |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | @adr @Wadlez DT isn't bad but i've just never understood the obsession a lot of people have with them. I&W is the only one i think is grossly grossly overrated though. Scenes from a memory is decent. |
Torontonian
06.25.14 | still overrated though agreed. |
TalonsOfFire
06.25.14 | Not to wish you ill will or nuthin'. But damn, that right there, that's blasphemy if I ever seen it |
kevin234
06.28.14 | Frances the Mute is fantastic. You're filler |
DrGonzo1937
06.28.14 | filler |
Royl123
06.28.14 | This list sucks |
