musicalmedicine: Album Battle - Opeth

musicalmedicine 01.05.14	I literally mean it, you decide. I'm not voting on this thread, it's just too hard for me, 4 albums on this list are 5's for me and the other might just become one some day.
Funeralopolis 01.05.14	still life
JamieTwort 01.05.14	My Arms, Your Hearse and it's not even remotely close for me.
JamieTwort 01.05.14	at least not between these 5.
Judio! 01.05.14	Still Life
DeathGrinder 01.05.14	Still Life.
Betacra 01.05.14	Still Life, just.
CalculatingInfinity 01.05.14	BWP.
Artuma 01.05.14	still. fucking. life.
Keyblade 01.05.14	Where the hell's Morningrise? Out of these tho, BWP
musicalmedicine 01.05.14	DAMN, Still Life is destroying everything! MAYH 1, Still Life 5, BWP 2, Damnation and Ghost Reveries 0. Morningrise is an amazing record, but I couldn't feature every Opeth album. 5 is enough, so I featured the 5 highest rated Opeth records on the site, although Morningrise is as good as Reveries for me. I guess.
NordicMindset 01.05.14	BWP
conesmoke 01.05.14	throw morningrise in between bwp & damnation and i'd be feeling this.
Keyblade 01.05.14	Replace the last 2 with Morningrise and Orchid and it would be a nice battle
musicalmedicine 01.05.14	Okay, counting votes for Morningrise as well, truly a deservant album. It's 2 for BWP anyway (greenlinkinmuse voted BWP) and 1 for Morningrise. Cone, is your vote for Morningrise too?
DominionMM1 01.05.14	still life
musicalmedicine 01.05.14	Still Life is 6 now, damn, it truly is destroying stuff around here.
SpiritCrusher2 01.05.14	BWP
CK 01.05.14	Still Life
charbyno 01.05.14	BWP
ExcentrifugalForz 01.05.14	morningrise is the only one i have so it gets my vote
sputnik1 01.05.14	Still Life
Solaire 01.05.14	Morningrise
Surtur 01.05.14	Still Life, then MAYH for me
evilford 01.05.14	Mayh
thumbcrusher 01.05.14	MAYH
BigPleb 01.05.14	MAYH
Solaire 01.05.14	On Sputnik you will hear MAYH or Still Life for the most part.
PortraitsOfDecay 01.05.14	still life
demigod! 01.05.14	Morningrise
Underflow 01.05.14	Still Life
MoosechriS 01.05.14	............. can't decide
demigod! 01.05.14	morningrise dude, its so blackened and eerie
MoosechriS 01.05.14	i have morningrise on vinyl, gonna play that shit now!
musicalmedicine 01.05.14	Morningrise - 4 MAYH - 4 Still Life - 11 BWP - 4 Damnation - 0 (pretty surprising) Ghost Reveries - 1
demigod! 01.05.14	Jelly dude! and damnation would be my second choice
undertakerpt 01.05.14	Don't see what everyone sees in still life, apart from the awesome intro. Damnation!
JamieTwort 01.05.14	Damnation is the most boring album ever! (I'm exaggerating but still it's pretty boring.)
JokineAugustus 01.05.14	Still life then Ghost reveries
PunchforPunch 01.05.14	Still Lyfe
undertakerpt 01.05.14	I've only heard the middle 3 on this list, and I'd say still life is the worst of them
undertakerpt 01.05.14	I changed my mind, bwp over damnation, but storm corrosion is prob the best thing akerfeldt put his name on
DANcore 01.05.14	Still life
ValarMorghulis 01.05.14	Blackwater Park
musicalmedicine 01.05.14	Morningrise 4, MAYH 4, Still Life 14, BWP 6, Reveries 1. Fuck, SL is wrecking every other Opeth record down.
MO 01.06.14	Mayh consider this the tie breaker album wins all
Necrotica 01.06.14	Watershed
SpiritCrusher2 01.06.14	Still Life deserves this, album is just constant perfection. although I've already voted for BWP, which has always been my personal fav :] they're both 5s imo
JaySpiral 01.06.14	Ghost Reveries Don't understand why everyone loves Still Life so much. It's probably like my fourth or fifth favorite Opeth album.
SpiritCrusher2 01.06.14	I consider Still Life to be the biggest grower of all of their albums, so maybe you should just give it more time idk
Tyrael 01.06.14	Morningrise
Betacra 01.06.14	If I had to rank my Opeth albums they'd probably be: Still Life My Arms, Your Hearse Blackwater Park Ghost Reveries I don't listen to the rest half as much any more but to be honest I'd probably end up sticking Orchid there in fifth spot, because it's a seriously under appreciated album. Don't add these as votes I already voted, but we all know Still Life has won anyway!
musicalmedicine 01.06.14	FiveLeaves, wassup? For me BWP, Still Life and MAYH are 5's. Morningrise 5, MAYH 5, Still Life 14, BWP 6, Reveries 2. Still Life is way on the lead. I still can't vote tbh, so tight between 1, 2 and 3. Damnation grew a little off me (I mean, Death Whispered A Lullaby and Ending Credits did, rest is still perfect. Oh, Windowpane/In My Time Of Need)
SIMBOLIC 01.06.14	still life yeah!!!
CK 01.06.14	Fuck yeah m/
tempest-- 01.06.14	bwp
tommygun 01.06.14	mayh
Ending 01.06.14	Still Life no doubt. It's their most coherent by far.
MyNameIsPencil 01.08.14	Suicide Season
ButteryBiscuitBass 01.08.14	mayh
SIMBOLIC 01.08.14	Still life
NightProwler 01.08.14	BWP = MAYH, can't decide.
musicalmedicine 01.09.14	Morningrise 5, MAYH 7, Still Life 17, BWP 8, Ghost Reveries 2.
MeatSalad 01.09.14	Mayh
Avagantamos 01.10.14	deliverance, but out of these my pick is bwp
JamieTwort 01.10.14	lol
musicalmedicine 01.10.14	Morningrise 5, MAYH 8, Still Life 18 (I'm voting for it, truly the best Opeth record), BWP 9 (although this has the most badass album cover), Ghost Reveries 2.
JamieTwort 01.10.14	MAYH is truly the best Opeth record.
MeatSalad 01.10.14	Still life is truly the most overrated opeth record.
Necrotica 01.10.14	^ Indeed
Necrotica 01.10.14	Along with Damnation and Deliverance imo, but at least Deliverance actually does have a more mixed reception
MeatSalad 01.10.14	Yeah deliverance should have a lower average
musicalmedicine 01.10.14	^ I second this, Deliverance is painfully boring at times, but Master's Apprendices and By The Pain I See In Others slay the shit out of most metal bands today. Wreath and t/t are so freaking boring though. A Fair Judgement is quite great but it really drags in the end.
JamieTwort 01.10.14	A Fair Judgement is the only song I really like on Deliverance. By The Pain is one of the worst and certainly doesn't slay the shit out of most modern metal.
Avagantamos 01.11.14	title track of deliverance is top 5 opeth imo
musicalmedicine 01.11.14	I love By The Pain, one of the first Opeth songs I've ever heard and I still play it some times. Of course, it's not top 20, not even top 25 Opeth, but I like it. Title track is a bit meh for me, I don't know, it just drags so much for me tbh.
ShitsofRain 01.11.14	3>
Myrkur 01.11.14	Can't really decide between Still Life and Blackwater Park, both are classics
L4titudes 01.28.14	I will never understand how people dislike Deliverance.. I think that album is just as good as Ghost Reveries.. anyways my vote goes to MAYH if that counts for anything. I also agree that Still Life is over rated.
Inveigh 01.28.14	I might argue that Deliverance is better than Ghost Reveries. Everything after Blackwater Park is of much less importance than the first 5 records though.
JamieTwort 01.28.14	Deliverance is easily their worst imo. Ghost Reveries is actually really good and miles better than Deliverance.