mryrtmrnfoxxxy
06.23.14 | 3 too many figure 8 songs, and you're missing like 5 songs from xo |
SeaAnemone
06.23.14 | "Ostriches and Chirping" |
tommygun
06.23.14 | easy way out is the best song ever omg |
scorpiusx
06.23.14 | SeaAnemone, I specifically stated that no instrumentals were to be included. ^ |
SeaAnemone
06.23.14 | ya I saw that after the fact oh well
either way Coast to Coast is an above-avg Elliott song |
klap
06.24.14 | wow coast to coast rules
as do all the figure 8 tracks here. pretty mary k?!?! stupidity tries? more like this list tries to be stupid |
scorpiusx
06.24.14 | WOW. So you're saying that even the lesser Elliott tracks are still great songs? It's not like I alluded to that in the opening statement or anything.
Point is, when you're sorting through diamonds, some are going to be less shiny than the others. If you feel like my choices are stupid then okay, but what I'm more interested in hearing is what you think should be there instead. ^ |
StallionMang
06.24.14 | Easy Way Out on here wowww bruh do you even have feelings
List needs more Basement On A Hill |
scorpiusx
06.24.14 | It pained me to put it on here, yes. Song has a killer melody. :/ But something had to go. |
deathschool
06.24.14 | Dude. Bad list. Needs Satellite, Bled White, and like nothing else. |
deathschool
06.24.14 | Oh. Maybe Punch and Judy. That's about it. |
scorpiusx
06.24.14 | But Satellite is beautiful. D: And Bled White does such a great job of utilizing the production style of XO. And Punch and Judy is underrated because it's surrounded by masterpieces.
Honestly though this is a suicidal effort. I'm waiting for a caravan of people to skin us alive for both of our picks and say that, like, "No Name No. 4" and "Don't Go Down" should be on here instead. XD |
klap
06.24.14 | sorry i just had to throw that pun in there
|
ShadowRemains
06.24.14 | wtf cupid's trick is fantastic
also the acoustic version of pretty mary k on new moon is amazing |
scorpiusx
06.24.14 | Oh I agree; the version on New Moon is exceptional. Well the Figure 8 version is good too, but I think the New Moon version is way superior. But they are really two completely different songs; lyrically and structurally and everything. |
ShadowRemains
06.24.14 | also easy way out is one of the best songs on figure 8 |
deathschool
06.24.14 | Bled white is like the only time I've ever thought of Elliot as slightly gimmicky. Satellite isn't bad but no matter how hard I try it
just doesn't do anything for me. Punch and Judy's problem is probably just that either or's other tracks are 1000 times better. |
ShadowRemains
06.24.14 | punch and judy's other problem is that it always seems mediocre because it is followed by angeles
i always find myself waiting for it to be over when i listen to either/or |
bach
06.24.14 | everything on roman candle is the best |
TheNexus100
06.24.14 | good to go is great |
joshuahuntkc
06.24.14 | I disagree very strongly with 8,5 and 1. However I do agree with 6. |
scorpiusx
06.24.14 | Going into sputnik and posting your least favorite Elliott songs is like going to the Vatican and discussing the least practical Bible verses. ^_^ |
klap
06.24.14 | yes i'd watch out for lightning if i was you |
tommygun
06.24.14 | amity is prob least fave from his studio albs |
klap
06.24.14 | tommy you're so right |
deathschool
06.24.14 | Amity and Bled White hold XO back a tiny bit for me. |
ShadowRemains
06.24.14 | yeah amity is one song of his that i really dislike |
YoYoMancuso
06.24.14 | Every Figure 8 song on here rules
Amity and Satellite are the only things that qualify |
joshuahuntkc
06.24.14 | bled white is awesome idk what anyone is talking about with that one. Amity is one of my least faves though. |
deathschool
06.24.14 | I'm the only one that said anything about Bled White, so you can address me directly. I don't mind. My problem with that song is that the surf rock vibe feels really forced. I know Elliott was strongly influenced by it, but I think it works better when it's subtle. Just one of those songs I don't like as much as other people. There's nothing really actually wrong with it. I mean, Elliott couldn't write a bad song, so this whole thread is going to be nit-picky. |
Rowan5215
06.24.14 | Amity is just bad |
deathschool
06.24.14 | I think Amity suffers from awkward album placement. I actually like the song though. |
lilium23
08.03.14 | Little One and Good To Go are some of Elliott's best. Especially Little One. It may be his most honest song ever. |