FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Bring it SPutnik. |
Maniac!
09.29.11 | harharhar |
pmmets07
09.29.11 | i agree that 2 is overrated but i love all of the others. |
Yotimi
09.29.11 | agree with 4. |
kris.
09.29.11 | 1 and 3 are spot on |
AngelofDeath
09.29.11 | Where's the new Steven Wilson joint? |
Romulus
09.29.11 | yeah 2 is like viciously overrated
the rest are also but i feel like a fair amount of people are aware of that
|
manicmonkey
09.29.11 | I treat the last 4 tracks of EDaSN separately from the rest of the album. When i'm in the mood, i actually kinda like the acoustic stuff. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Haven't listened to it, Angel, so I can't add it. |
Colliiiin
09.29.11 | agreed with 4 and 5 [2] |
ZilbelPing
09.29.11 | I love 1 and I enjoy 5 but the rest I haven't heard or care about. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | I have to congratulate Manicmonkey. If you've seen his ratings, you'd know that listening to anything that needs talent is an accomplishment in itself. |
wabbit
09.29.11 | agreed so hard. esp 3 cause I don't care about the others |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Wow
Surprised I haven't been crucified for this yet. |
WeepingBanana
09.29.11 | i pretty much agree with this. although i still really love 3
but yeah 4 blows |
kris.
09.29.11 | 5 is pretty overrated (mostly by me) but 2 will always be my favorite thrice album |
porch
09.29.11 | shape of punk to come gets a lot of instant 5's from 14 year old's that think THE TITLE ACTUALLY CAME TRUE. anyway sup |
taxidermist
09.29.11 | 1. I dig a lot of that album (personally) and the vocals are not a problem.
2. I've never listened to a Thrice album, just tracks, so I have no opinion on that.
3. I also dug a handful of tracks from that, but I do think it's overrated. Where the "legendary" status came from, I do not know, but it isn't legendary imo.
4. I guess it's a bit overrated, but there are some great tracks on there.
5. Def overrated. I like it. It's good, but def overrated. |
taxidermist
09.29.11 | Also, Pit
✟ |
Eulogize
09.29.11 | Needz moar Opeth. |
Trebor.
09.29.11 | 1 and 2 are very true |
manicmonkey
09.29.11 | Why thank you kind sir! |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "BEST LIST EVER. I love haters, and you are one awesome hater man! *dreamy*"
I love it. The minute you disagree with someone their either a "hater" or a "troll." How ironic is it when I say grow up, SPutnik. |
Inveigh
09.29.11 | 1 sucks, I like the rest but yeah they're probably overrated |
sportsboy
09.29.11 | truer words have never been spoken about 1
3 is still fucking awesome |
Trebor.
09.29.11 | You forgot Arcade Fire |
UnnamedOcean
09.29.11 | The Alchemy Index is way more experimental than Vheissu anyways. I don't know why people call it their "Kid A." |
anarchistfish
09.29.11 | 1, 3 and 4 are overrated but I still enjoy them |
acorncheese
09.29.11 | so completely and totally wrong about 3 and 4. so wrong. |
acorncheese
09.29.11 | but yeah you're right about 1 |
porch
09.29.11 | best thing about fake history is the album cover |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "so completely and totally wrong about 3 and 4. so wrong."
First person to post that. What does that tell you? |
wabbit
09.29.11 | I imagine if you never heard a punk album from before '95 3 would be the greatest thing conceived by man...and that title would make you feel so smart |
Joshgasm
09.29.11 | I can definitely see where you're coming from on 1, 3 & 5. Although, I wouldn't say I necessarily
agree. |
anarchistfish
09.29.11 | 1 and 4 are 3.5s
3 is a 3 |
iFghtffyrdmns
09.29.11 | woah bro.
woah |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | WHOA |
TheFonz123
09.29.11 | list needs tool list needs tool list needs tool, and i agree with thrice;band sucks ass |
UnnamedOcean
09.29.11 | "list needs tool"
Fuck yes this does. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Tool is hardly overrated on Sputnik. |
Wolfhorde
09.29.11 | 2 always reminds me of Illumanti. Horrible movie. |
UrAssIsMyHat
09.29.11 | The Wonder Years |
cvlts
09.29.11 | 4 is still better than 90% of the other 'post-hardcore' in todays scene |
UrAssIsMyHat
09.29.11 | So true |
Joshgasm
09.29.11 | true dat |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | THat's why I don't listen to 99.9% of post-hardcore that comes out nowadays |
cvlts
09.29.11 | well aren't you just a bitter jaded old man |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | What can I say? I know what I like |
cvlts
09.29.11 | anyways. startin to appreciate the acoustics of 5 but the actual hardcore music is whatevs. learned i dont mind awhile back and play it on the reg |
pizzamachine
09.29.11 | where's the radiohead |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | The hardcore on 5 is bearable, but I find the acoustic songs to be nothing more than an attempt at standing out from a genre, rather than something heartfelt. I'm also getting tired of them using the same lyrical content for every single fucking song they write. |
johnnyblaze
09.29.11 | i agree with all five even though i havent heard 4. ilu frank. |
omnipanzer
09.29.11 | While I don't know enough about the discog to agree with the description of 5 I completely agree with the "new" rating.
1-4 I've never listened to but I've never had any Sputnikers I respect specifically rec any of them either so I'm inclined to believe you Pit. |
xfearbefore
09.29.11 | Meh, 3 is underrated if anything. I don't think any of these are overrated on Sputnik. Well, maybe the Thrice album actually.
Here's a better list:
Sufjan Stevens - The Age of Adz
Radiohead - OK Computer
Radiohead - In Rainbows
Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Dredg - El Cielo
Converge - Jane Doe
|
kris.
09.29.11 | 4.6
underrated
yep
are you retarded |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "Meh, 3 is underrated if anything. I don't think any of these are overrated on Sputnik."
An album has a 4.6 rating and it's underrated? Are you fucking retarded, or are you just fucking with me?
"Sufjan Stevens - The Age of Adz
Radiohead - OK Computer
Radiohead - In Rainbows
Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
Dredg - El Cielo
Converge - Jane Doe"
There's a difference between not understanding the appeal of music and something being overrated/underrated. |
Athom
09.29.11 | thoughts on songs to fan the flames of discontent? |
cvlts
09.29.11 | i met someone from sweden who said he likes hardcore and hes never heard of 3.
almost lost my shit |
Metamorphosis
09.29.11 | I mean, I have 2 at a 4.5 and I think 4 and 5 are both 4's for me. Then again, my ratings are usually really lenient, so take that how you will. |
kris.
09.29.11 | but 3 isn't hardcore |
cvlts
09.29.11 | o rly now? |
kris.
09.29.11 | yarly |
Athom
09.29.11 | shut up, meg. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | I hate to say it, but Shirley 3 isn't hardcore.
And yes, I called you Shirley. |
Athom
09.29.11 | again, what are your thoughts on Songs to Fan the Flames of Discontent?
|
kris.
09.29.11 | how dare you compare me to MEG of all people |
omnipanzer
09.29.11 | Griffin or White? |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Sorry redsky, I didn't see your question earlier. I think it's more punk/hardcore than Shape of Punk, but it's still nothing special. |
Athom
09.29.11 | :(
|
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Sorry mane. |
xenocide.
09.29.11 | Say what you wish, but everybody will still like their music. As for me, I'm a big fan of 1, I'm the one who makes that rating so high, and honestly I'm not gonna change my mind only because you said it's "overrated". |
greg84
09.29.11 | I agree that Thrice is massively overrated. Their last album included. |
Wolfhorde
09.29.11 | "Say what you wish, but everybody will still like their music [..] I'm not gonna change my mind only because you said it's "overrated""
NO WAY! ..duh. |
kris.
09.29.11 | hey guys 9 minutes left until my battlefield 3 beta is done downloading
i'm excited |
Athom
09.29.11 | I'm a massive Refused fan but I'll still admit that their whole shtick was ripped off from Nation of Ulysses and Born Against. |
porch
09.29.11 | international noise conspiracy took it even further |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Redsky, I never thought of that, but that statement is right on. I'm not saying I don't like Refused, I just believe them to be overblown because hardcore was on what we thought was it's last breath when Shape of Punk came out.
"Say what you wish, but everybody will still like their music. As for me, I'm a big fan of 1, I'm the one who makes that rating so high, and honestly I'm not gonna change my mind only because you said it's "overrated"."
Ummm..... I wasn't expecting you to. I don't think this Sputnik thing is for you.
|
UnnamedOcean
09.29.11 | "hey guys 9 minutes left until my battlefield 3 beta is done downloading"
Oh shit, I can't wait for that! I'm playing it as soon as I get back from class. |
xenocide.
09.29.11 | "Ummm..... I wasn't expecting you to. I don't think this Sputnik thing is for you."
May I ask why do you think so? |
Apollo
09.29.11 | That's it Pit how dare you oh it's on now gloves are off |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | When you take something like this list personally, it means you maybe need to re-evaluate your thought process. |
jefflebowski
09.29.11 | isn't Third Eye Blind's debut like a 4.2 or something? Ridiculous
|
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Yeah, but that's a very good, close to classic 90's pop-rock release. |
MO
09.29.11 | 4.5 actually, great album |
Xplisit
09.29.11 | hating on Refused is mad gay.
|
xenocide.
09.29.11 | @ FrankRedHot: You called these albums "overrated". What did you exactly mean? I thought you're trying
to prove that other users are wrong when rating them high. |
Wolfhorde
09.29.11 | Ouch. That hurts. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "You called these albums "overrated". What did you exactly mean? I thought you're trying to prove that other users are wrong when rating them high."
I am, but that doesn't mean you should change your opinion of them. If I inspire someone to stop listening to these because they realize I'm right, that's great. If not, more power to ya. |
jefflebowski
09.29.11 | C'mon, it's a decent post-grunge release which has some great songs, but I can't figure out the classic status. It's too....derivative |
UrAssIsMyHat
09.29.11 | You should make a nice list of albums that are underrated next :) |
FilthyBorgir
09.29.11 | where's Converge? why aren't they on the list? |
Scoot
09.29.11 | i like all of these albums
am i butthurt? no
he's not saying that they are terrible albums, he's just pointing out that (in his opinion) they are praised too much. |
MO
09.29.11 | "You called these albums "overrated". What did you exactly mean? I thought you're trying to prove that other users are wrong when rating them high."
In his opinion these albums are overrated and he described his reasoning behind it...is it that hard? You can't "prove" other users wrong by stating why you THINK an album is overrated. It's all perception. |
xenocide.
09.29.11 | @ FrankRedHot: In my first comment I only stated that your list isn't gonna change users' opinion of
these albums. Like mine. Maybe it stated something totally obvious. Anyway, I enjoy sputniking and I'm
not gonna quit. We're cool? |
UrAssIsMyHat
09.29.11 | 4.6 is pretty crazy
That's like the 99th percentile |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "@ FrankRedHot: In my first comment I only stated that your list isn't gonna change users' opinion of these albums. Like mine. Maybe it stated something totally obvious. Anyway, I enjoy sputniking and I'm not gonna quit. We're cool?"
Lol |
Wolfhorde
09.29.11 | "@ FrankRedHot: In my first comment I only stated that your list isn't gonna change users' opinion of these albums. Like mine. Maybe it stated something totally obvious. Anyway, I enjoy sputniking and I'm not gonna quit. We're cool?"
Can you explain to me why people always feel the need to justify? |
xenocide.
09.29.11 | Honestly, I think all these albums/bands are appreciated by sputnik for a good reason. Even If my ratings for some of them are slightly lower than average. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | It's like getting involuntarily caught with your pants down in a room of females |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | "Honestly, I think all these albums/bands are appreciated by sputnik for a good reason. Even If my ratings for some of them are slightly lower than average"
Good for you. Now move on and stop polluting this thread. |
Aids
09.29.11 | DARLING |
xenocide.
09.29.11 | "Most Overrated" lists are overrated. |
Relinquished
09.29.11 | how do you rate lists though |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | ""Most Overrated" lists are overrated."
Grasping for straws, huh? |
AmericnZero02
09.29.11 | Oooohhhh, I like this list. I haven't heard 1 and 5 but you pretty much hit the nail on the head on 2 and 3. In regards to 3, just because an album is influential it isn't necessarily a great album, much less a classic. I personally dig 4 but I can see one not liking the vocals on it. And the last two tracks don't do much for me. |
Aids
09.29.11 | dude pit you have different opinions than me FUCK YOU
I have been thinking of lowering my rating for Vheissu though, not sure I consider it a classic anymore but it definitely was for me for a while. |
DominionMM1
09.29.11 | I like you more every day, Pit. |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | Don't know why. Mappy hates me, so all of you should probably hate me, too. |
Joshgasm
09.29.11 | 4 isn't overrated... |
tkxxx7
09.29.11 | Vheissu will never be a classic for me and 5 is definitely overrated but it's pretty well-known that I love 1 and 4 |
FromDaHood
09.29.11 | Predictable list except for 3 |
FrankRedHot
09.29.11 | I made this list with you in mind. |
theashesfromautumn01
09.29.11 | Brand New and Opeth are pretty overrated on this site too |
BallsToTheWall
09.29.11 | vHEISSU IS GREATER THAN YOU KNOW |
FeralMemories
09.30.11 | 3 is right where it should be at 4.6 |
ShadowRemains
09.30.11 | no |
Ire
09.30.11 | list is missing agalloch |
IAmHollywood
09.30.11 | @theashesfromautumn01
nah man Brand New deserves the score it has |
Knave
09.30.11 | you hit the nail on the head with 2 and 3 |
toxin.
09.30.11 | Lists like these are so predictable. I like 2 although I don't think it's a classic |
The Sludge
09.30.11 | You forgot Gunther's "Pleasureman". It has a rating of 4.4 (a perfect 5 at one point) and if you want proof, just search on youtube for any song of his. |
Josh D.
09.30.11 | Replace 1 with their latest. |
FrankRedHot
09.30.11 | Give it two more weeks to see how much staying power it has |
BallsToTheWall
09.30.11 | Sputnik's Most Overrated:
1. FrankRedHot
|
xenocide.
09.30.11 | ^^^ |
H61
04.12.13 | cr00sh |
kitsch
04.12.13 | songs to fan the flames of discontent >>>>>>>>> the shape of punk to come
i heard new noise first as a single, got that with the b-side song "blind date"
downloaded songs and holy fuck it was so fucking crushing and heavy. still the heaviest punk album. in my top 2 favorite punk albums (non postpunk) along with iron lung - sexless//no sex |
wabbit
04.12.13 | New noise sounds like a korn or limp biscuit song |
kitsch
04.12.13 | songs to fan the flames of discontent >>>>>>>>> the shape of punk to come
i heard new noise first as a single, got that with the b-side song "blind date"
downloaded songs and holy fuck it was so fucking crushing and heavy. still the heaviest punk album. in my top 2 favorite punk albums (non postpunk) along with iron lung - sexless//no sex |
Gwyn.
04.12.13 | I THINK I SAW YOU IN MY DREAMS
DARLING |
kitsch
04.12.13 | fuck you miles
sorry for the double post |
treeqt.
04.12.13 | I THINK I SAW YOU IN MY SLEEP
GWYN |
treeqt.
04.12.13 | there are so many awfully overrated albums on sputnik and you took the least overrated ones gj 2/10 for the effort though |
MalleusMaleficarum
04.12.13 | accurate list but refused kinda rules tho |
thumbcrusher
04.12.13 | hi 2011 |
Disrupt
04.12.13 | 2011 here, hello! |
kitsch
04.12.13 | AIDS you better stfu you dont have the cred to be calling somethign "not hardcore"
if you guys would go to any shows everyone there has heard refused and while not everyone is going to boner over it no one will say theyre not punk or hxc or phxc or whatevs |
Drummerboy123
04.12.13 | Nah 2 is phenomenal. |
MikeC26
04.12.13 | 3 sucks man agreed |
ReturnToRock
04.12.13 | List needs Converge - any album. |
kitsch
04.12.13 | ^^^hell yes |
omnipanzer
04.12.13 | Good bump H61. |
ReturnToRock
04.12.13 | List also needs Nirvana - In Utero. |
ZilbelPing
04.12.13 | "there are so many awfully overrated albums on sputnik and you took the least overrated ones gj 2/10 for the effort though"
this list if from 2011 noob
These were really overrated at that period in time
"List also needs Nirvana - In Utero."
not overrated here. |
ReturnToRock
04.12.13 | ^Yes it is overrated. People who like Nirvana keep 4ing and 5ing it when shit is the weakest Nirvana by far and not worthy of more than a 3 on a good day. |
ZilbelPing
04.12.13 | No one talks about it, and no one recs it |
Gwyn.
04.12.13 | "^Yes it is overrated. People who like Nirvana keep 4ing and 5ing it when shit is the weakest Nirvana by far and not worthy of more than a 3 on a good day."
lmfao |
kris.
04.12.13 | fuck you miles[2]
fuck you miles[3]
fuck you miles[4]
fuck you miles[5]
fuck you miles[6]
fuck you miles[7]
fuck you miles[8]
fuck you miles[9]
fuck you miles[10]
fuck you miles[11]
fuck you miles[12]
fuck you miles[13]
fuck you miles[14]
fuck you miles[15] |
ReturnToRock
04.12.13 | Overrated within the fanbase then? |
ZilbelPing
04.12.13 | You dense motherfucker |
Inferis
04.12.13 | number 1 fucking sucks. La Dispute is horrendous in studio and live. |
ReturnToRock
04.12.13 | Overrated within the fanbase the group has on Sputnik?
I can keep going for another 35 minutes then it's soccer time. |
ZilbelPing
04.12.13 | |
kris.
04.12.13 | "La Dispute is horrendous in studio and live."
while i certainly agree about their first album being horrendous, they were fucking crazy good live when i saw them and that was before wildlife was out so all they played was shit from their first album |
treeqt.
04.12.13 | somewhere at the bottom is their second.
vancouver is the first. and vancouver fucking blows. |
Spec
04.12.13 | Fake History is incredibly awesome and better than Glassjaw. Get out of my face. |