rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | 2,3,8 could easily be the easiest 5's ever. |
clercqie
08.22.11 | Upon first listen?
Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago
and Bloc Party - Intimacy
Those are it |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | Sgt. Pepper
Abbey Road
|
rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | "Upon first listen?"
Yep |
benkim
08.22.11 | La Dispute - Somewhere at The Bottom of The River |
JamieTwort
08.22.11 | 2, 4, 13, Made in Japan, Physical Grafitti and Animals were all easy 5's for me. |
Deviant.
08.22.11 | Lifeforms - The Future Sound Of London
Tri-Repetae - Autechre
Endtroducing... - DJ Shadow
After The Eulogy - Boysetsfire |
Winesburgohio
08.22.11 | Bitches Brew and Enter the Wu-Tang(36 chambers) were 5s after a couple of listens, but I think Choirs of the Eye is the only 5 i have that i would've considered classic-worthy upon first listen.
Oh wait and 'Close to the Edge' by Yes |
MO
08.22.11 | Abbey Road [2] |
telebyrd
08.22.11 | Talking Heads - Stop Making Sense |
wittwright
08.22.11 | Defeater-lost ground, no doubt
|
ilikeforests
08.22.11 | the wild hunt |
Xplisit
08.22.11 | Black Sails in the Sunset |
pmmets07
08.22.11 | streetlight manifesto - everything goes numb
catch 22 - keasbey nights
dangers - messy, isn't it? |
accompliceofmydeath
08.22.11 | Poison the Well- The Opposite of December
Quicksand- Slip
Deadguy- Fixation on a Coworker
Black Flag- Damaged |
Thane
08.22.11 | Wish You Were Here |
WeepingBanana
08.22.11 | i don't think i ever 5'd anything upon first listen |
Electric City
08.22.11 | remain in light by talking heads and anything i listen to for the first time stoned |
Xplisit
08.22.11 | "I gave it a 5 while I was listening to the opening track for the first time."
dumb |
Emim
08.22.11 | Definitely Angel Dust and The Real Thing |
auberginedreams
08.22.11 | la dispute - somewhere at the bottom of the river...
circle takes the square - as the roots undo
i'm pretty sure my first two ratings were me 5ing them. |
ti0n
08.22.11 | Tool Aenima
Tool Lateralus
Animal Collective Feels
At the drive-in Relationship of Command
Built to Spill Perfect from now on
Modest Mouse Moon & Antarctica
Modest Mouse Building nothing out of something
|
xenocide.
08.22.11 | Tool - Aenima
Tool - Lateralus
Neurosis - Through Silver In Blood |
FromDaHood
08.22.11 | Prince- Purple Rain
Say Anything-... Is a Real Boy
Wu-Tang Clan- 36 Chambers
jack's Mannequin- Everything in Transit |
TheStefan
08.22.11 | Radiohead- OK Computer
i don't think i've ever 5'd something else after just 1 listen |
Kimm
08.22.11 | It usually takes me a while to rate an album, especially if I'm going to 5 it. Probably the quickest one I gave out was to
Guardians, but I think I'm going to change my rating to a 4.5 |
Knott-
08.22.11 | I think the only thing I've ever 5'd on first listen was
The Weakerthans - Live At Burton Cummings Theatre |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | I would easily 5 this Dole Mandarins in Orange Jello I'm eating right now.
It's Delicious! |
Kimm
08.22.11 | Ahh I love fruit in jello! |
JamieTwort
08.22.11 | ^upon first taste? |
omnipanzer
08.22.11 | First taste! |
Irving
08.22.11 | The Decemberists' Crane Wife. |
CrisStyles
08.22.11 | High Violet from The National |
DocSportello
08.22.11 | Radiohead - Kid A
|
North0House2
08.22.11 | LYSFLATH by GY!BE
F#A# (infinity) by GY!BE
Spiderland by Slint
TDAGARIM by Brand New
Tunnel Blanket by This Will Destroy You |
wyankeif1337
08.22.11 | Isis - Panopticon
GY!BE - Slow Riot... |
ThusSpokeZarathustra
08.22.11 | JOY DIVISION - CLOSER
Though these were pretty easy too:
Joy Division – Unknown Pleasures
Burzum – s/t
Burzum – Hvis Lyset Tar Oss
Graveland – Thousand Swords
Morbid Angel – Altars of Madness
Beherit – Drawing Down the Moon
|
ThusSpokeZarathustra
08.22.11 | Oops.. just realized I hadn't got around to rating the Joy Division albums, lolz.
'Closer' is probably my all-time favourite though.. |
dammets
08.22.11 | Atheist-Unquestionable Presence
Not sure about Angel Dust. I didn't think about stuff like this when I first listened to it, let alone even knowing that this site exists. |
Maniac!
08.22.11 | Tool - Aenima
Goodie Mob - Soul Food
Black Sabbath - Heaven and Hell |
Mewcopa0
08.22.11 | Electric Wizard - Dopethrone
Mr Bungle - California
Death - Symbolic |
aok
08.22.11 | kid a kid a kid a |
FrankRedHot
08.22.11 | Your mom |
JJwins
08.22.11 | F#A# (infinity) by GY!BE |
MentalityOfA
08.22.11 | Wonder What's Next, The Moon & Antarctica, Halo 3: ODST OST and Cities. Brother, Sister too. |
robertsona
08.22.11 | talk talk - laughing stock |
ffs
08.22.11 | i can only 5 an album after days of meditations and deliberating w/ the ancient pagan gods |
Motiv3
08.22.11 | pink floyd - wish you were here
opeth - blackwater park
edge of sanity - crimson II |
clercqie
08.22.11 | Don't forget the goat sacrifice to make the gods happy with your decision... |
ApplicationToHeaven
08.22.11 | slow riot for new zero zero kanada
|
MountainDewMe
08.22.11 | Eminem- The Marshall Mathers Lp. |
lucasjcockcroft
08.22.11 | blink-182, S/T |
YetAnotherBrick
08.22.11 | F#A#(Infinity) was an insta-5 for me. |
elephantREVOLUTION
08.22.11 | fun. - aim and ignite
fucking classic. |
nylertickel2
08.22.11 | Between the Buried and Me - Colours/The Great Misdirect
Protest the Hero - Fortress
Alexisonfire - Watch Out!
|
MudIdol
08.22.11 | Tool-Aenima
The Red Chord-Fused together in revolving doors
Mudvayne-the end of all things to come |
Acanthus
08.22.11 | The Prodigy - The Fat of The Land
The Cure - Disintegration |
patroneyes
08.22.11 | dj shadow - endtroducing
gza - liquid swords
dinosaur jr - you're living all over me
coltrane - a love supreme
my bloody valentine - loveless
the clash - london calling
jay-z - reasonable doubt |
ITsHxCTOASTER
08.22.11 | I'm going to be a generic sputniker here and say Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven and F#A#(Infinity). But also these:
Mew - Frengers
Sufjan Stevens - Illinois
The Reign of Kindo - This Is What Happens |
paxman
08.22.11 | Can't really think of any that I would five without hesitation, because I'm very analytical. I guess it'd have to be something that ultimately blew me away on first listen.
Dredg - El Cielo
Tool - Lateralus
Coheed and Cambria - Secrets of Silent Earth
BtBaM - Colors
Defeater - Lost Ground
Rush - Moving Pictures
Trophy Scars - Never Born, Never Dead
|
SaneTBP
08.22.11 | Tool - Lateralus
Kashiwa Daisuke - Program Music I |
Baphomet
08.22.11 | Shpongle - Nothing Lasts... But Nothing is Lost |
Yotimi
08.22.11 | Flaming Lips - The Soft Bulletin
Flaming Lips - Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Radiohead - Kid A
Radiohead - OK Computer
Saves the Day - Stay What You Are
Sunny Day Real Estate - How It Feels to be Something On
Bjork - Homogenic
All my others had to grow on me to a 5 |
AliW1993
08.22.11 | I've never 5'd an album until I've listened at least 2 times.
For Emma, Forever Ago is the easiest 4.5 I've ever given (I've subsequently bumped it to a 5). |
IrishJay91
08.22.11 | Black Sabbath - Black Sabbath
Iron Maiden - Powerslave
Cynic - Focus |
sportsboy
08.22.11 | btbam - colors (of course)
miles davis - bitches brew
beatles - sgt pepper
cowboy bebop ost
spongebob squarepants movie ost |
ShadowRemains
08.22.11 | close to a world below |
TheSpirit
08.22.11 | your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom |
FearThyEvil
08.22.11 | Defeater-Travels
Tool-Lateralus |
ShadowRemains
08.22.11 | "your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom
your mom"
moar like a 10 |
derekkp
08.22.11 | animals |
wabbit
08.22.11 | you guys are doing a lot of lying.
Frank Turner- Love Ire and Song
I 5ed it before I knew prufrock before he got famous finished. |
Clamface
08.22.11 | Brother/Sister - mewithoutYou |
luschlotz
08.22.11 | 2,3, Sgt Peppers, Kid A, Hail To The Thief, Kind Of BLue, Time Out |
MisterSteel
08.22.11 | Mind.In.A.Box. - Crossroads |
cirq
08.22.11 | fuckin spirit took my post |
wabbit
08.22.11 | man I'm so elite I 5 jazz albums before I've even heard them #Sputnik |
PistolPete
08.22.11 | When I first listened to "White Pony" I 5'd it after one listen. Then I listened to "Around the Fur" and then "Diamond Eyes" started to sprout wings and resonate well so I had to move White Pony down to a 4/5 because it simply didn't compare. Only time that's happened. |
rockandmetaljunkie
08.22.11 | "i can only 5 an album after days of meditations and deliberating w/ the ancient pagan gods"
lol |
HaloDude442
08.22.11 | Counterparts - Prophets |
bry11
08.22.11 | Deftones - White Pony
Smashing Pumpkins - Siamese Dream |
FatChickIrl
08.22.11 | NSV |
OrangeHologram
08.22.11 | radiohead |
tarkus
08.22.11 | In the court of the crimson king
|
Sanders
08.22.11 | "Frank Turner- Love Ire and Song
I 5ed it before I knew prufrock before he got famous finished."
The first time I heard that song I got ridiculous goosebumps. Still do when that build-up pays off. |
linchpin313
08.22.11 | Dry Kill Logic - The Darker Side Of Nonsense |
Torii
08.22.11 | The Beatles - Abbey Road
ISIS - Panopticon
Coheed and Cambria - SSTB
dredg - El Cielo
Discordance Axis - The Inalienable Dreamless
... Oh and: you guys are doing a lot of lying. [2] |
TheNotrap
08.23.11 | 5/5 without hesitation:
Pink Floyd-The Dark Side of the Moon. Best record ever made IMO
Iron Maiden-Powerslave. Best Metal album ever recorded IMO
Iron Maiden-Live After Death. Best live album ever recorded IMO
|
Mchailas
08.23.11 | Close to the edge... Opening riff, insta 5 |
Yuli
08.23.11 | LYSFLATH by GY!BE
Blood Sugar Sex Magik- RHCP |
Josh D.
08.23.11 | I don't know, probably The Moon Is A Dead World and Powerslave. |
Asiatic667
08.23.11 | Joy Division - Closer |
crazyblinddude
08.23.11 | Figuring that I had a lot of my 5's before I ever started rating, I guess the only album is De-Loused. The rest grew on me. |
coneren
08.23.11 | Dirt |
kangaroopoo
08.23.11 | Tool – Aenima
GNR – Appetite
Kyuss – Sky Valley
Pig Destroyer – Terrifyer
Cog – The New Normal
Porcupine Tree – FOABP
Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream |
Jethro42
08.23.11 | Close to the edge... Opening riff, insta 5 [2] |
whywontyoudie
08.23.11 | Miranda Cosgrove- Sparks Fly |
gotsthedewsdood
08.23.11 | i don't think an immediate 5 marks the excellence of an album. |
danielito19
08.23.11 | Bubblegum Octopus - 8 legged Dance Moves |
climactic
08.23.11 | dark side, blackwater park |
iFghtffyrdmns
08.23.11 | oh you know, all the good ones. |
someguest
08.23.11 | nothing in your list is a 5 |
HBFS
08.23.11 | the wild hunt |
ECRbubs
08.23.11 | Aeroplane |
RagingStorm
08.23.11 | it takes a while for me to give anything a 5 but the monitor i guess |
MickeyPHager
08.23.11 | Brand New - Deja Entend/ The Devil And God Are Raging Inside Me
Bright Eyes - I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning
Radiohead - Ok Computer |
GnarlyShillelagh
08.23.11 | 5'd Mono's Hymn to the Immortal Wind right after I heard it for the first time.
Still my favorite album of all time. |
nnnope
08.23.11 | Radiohead - In Rainbows |
JamieTwort
08.23.11 | "nothing in your list is a 5"
Says the guy with one of these album's 5'd... |
TheNotrap
08.23.11 | Hahaha ups... |
RCKilm
08.23.11 | btmi - scrambles
and la dispute / TA split.
i think those are my only 5s anyway. |
PayneTiger777
08.23.11 | The Mayan Factor - 44 |
Masochist
08.23.11 | Easiest 5 for me was Pink Floyd's 'Wish You Were Here,' King Crimson's 'In The Court of the Crimson King' and Nas's 'Illmatic'. |
GnFnRs87
08.26.11 | Pink Floyd- Wish You Were Here
Guns N' Roses- Appetite For Destruction
Black Sabbath- Master of Reality
Metallica- Ride the Lightning
Iron Maiden- Number of the Beast |
Knave
08.28.11 | I never 5d something after the first listen |
FromDaHood
08.28.11 | Ur so elite |
PedalToTheMetal
09.21.11 | mewithoutYou - Catch For Us The Foxes
Rosetta - A Determinism Of Morality
Underoath - Define The Great Line
Karnivool - Sound Awake
Arcade Fire - Funeral |
pcar
09.21.11 | Illmatic probably |
jdennis31
09.21.11 | thrice - vheissu
thrice - major/minor
trophy scars - darkness, oh hell
tallest man on earth - the wild hunt |
illmitch
09.21.11 | the high 5 i gave to my bro after we double teamed ur mom |
slutnik
09.21.11 | Majoras Mask and OoT Soundtracks |
toxin.
09.21.11 | None, I'd say. The closest to a 5 automatically was probably Red-Innocence & Instinct though but it had time to grow before I joined Sputnik. |
taroo
09.21.11 | Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
Yes - Close to the Edge
Mother 3i
Team Shanghai Alice - Changeability of Strange Dream
Sound Horizon - Elysion
GZA - Liquid Swords
Johnny Cash - At Folsom Prison
Patti Smith - Horses |
DinoX
09.21.11 | pg.99- document 8
circle takes the square- as the roots undo
|
TheJackal
05.28.12 | Refused- Shape Of Punk To Come
Elliott Smith- Either/Or |
Jethro42
05.28.12 | countless |
Lelle
05.28.12 | I've never given an instant 5 (or many 5's at all for that matter), the best music takes a while to fully grasp, and if it's REALLY good you are still discovering things years later |
The7thVermicide
05.28.12 | Pink Floyd-Wish You Were Here
Megadeth-Rust In Peace
Opeth-Blackwater Park
Massive Attack-Mezzanine
Anathema-Judge
Nightwish-Oceanborn
The Mars Volta-Frances The Mute |
rockandmetaljunkie
05.29.12 | "the best music takes a while to fully grasp"
I can't say for sure if this stands me. There are some albums which i 5'd upon the first listen. Some artists are so good that you don't have to listen to them twice to grasp their magic. |
Venpts16
05.29.12 | Megadeth - Rust in Peace
Testament - The New Order
Blind Guardian - Imaginations From the Other Side
Gamma Ray - Somewhere Out in Space
Dark Tranquillity - The Gallery |
UnnamedOcean
05.29.12 | Both LYSF and F# by Godspeed and Talk Talk. |
londoncalling457
05.29.12 | real estate- days
yes- close to the edge
sabbath- master of reality |
Gwynbleiddsfang
05.29.12 | Brand New - TDaGaRIM
Radiohead - OK Computer (i also rated KID A with a 5, but that one took a while)
System of a Down - S/T
off the top of my head |
expire
05.29.12 | have heart - the things we carry |
treos777
05.29.12 | The Receiving End of Sirens-The Earth Sings Mi Fa Mi
Manchester Orchestra-Mean Everything to Nothing
The Felix Culpa-Sever Your Roots
Thrice-Major/Minor
|
BlueW
05.29.12 | Kyary Pamyu Pamyu Pamyu Pamyu Revolution |
Scoot
05.29.12 | endtroducing
everything goes numb
wish you were here
pree much the only ones, the rest have taken a lot of time. i need to fix some of my 5s that are no longer classics to me. hell, the moon is a dead world is my favorite album of all time and it took months before it grew on me |
Spec
05.29.12 | Goodbye Cool World I think then like Wish You Were Here but that's obvious.
And Yankee Hotel Foxtrot.
And Geogaddi. |
Spec
05.29.12 | And maybe Mezz.
Yeah mezz. |
ChuckyTruant
05.29.12 | Rush - discog |
HitlerIsGod
05.29.12 | Agalloch - The Mantle
Warning - Watching From a Distance
The Antlers - In the Attic of the Universe
In Flames - Whoracle, The Jester Race
Lustmord - Heresy
Ulver - Bergtatt |
MyNameIsPencil
04.29.13 | Weezer - The Blue Album
Portishead - Dummy
Led Zeppelin IV
Deftones - White Pony
Foo Fighters - The Colour and the Shape |
toxin.
04.29.13 | 2BA Master |
Chortles
04.29.13 | Better Music - discog |
demigod!
04.29.13 | bizarre ride 2 the pharcyde
animals
keasbey nights
liquid swords
jane doe
loveless |
Keyblade
04.29.13 | Music Has the Right to Children
lemon squeezy |
DrMaximus
04.29.13 | No question, Ulver- Bergtatt
|
JohnnyoftheWell
04.29.13 | None
Closest thing to it would be Oceansize - Frames |
lou1000
04.29.13 | Radiohead - OK Computer/Kid A
Burial - Untrue |
ViralOblivion
04.29.13 | Death- human and symbolic
Athiest- unquestionable presence |
demigod!
04.29.13 | oh yea kid a too |
toxin.
04.29.13 | None, I'd say. The closest to a 5 automatically was probably Red-Innocence & Instinct though but it had time to grow before I joined Sputnik. [2] |
zakalwe
04.29.13 | R.E.M - Automatic
Nirvana - Nevermind, Generation definer that blew the doors open,was instantly identifiable and still rocks to this day. |
Yotimi
04.29.13 | Only album I knew was a 5 before finishing it was Soft Bulletin |
DikkoZinner
04.29.13 | 2 & 10 |
ZilbelPing
04.29.13 | TDAGARIM by Brand New and F#A#oo by GY!BE
The one that took me the longest was Bad Luck by Trophy Scars but I fucking love it now. |
Gwyn.
04.29.13 | Not counting albums I heard before i started really using this website...
Jane Doe
Madvillainy
The Heat Death of the Universe
Worship and Tribute
Leaves Turn Inside You |
Kman418
04.29.13 | the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment
bomb the music industry - scrambles
converge - jane doe
the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment
glassjaw - worship and tribute
the arrogant sons of bitches - three cheers for disappointment |
Arnaud
04.29.13 | F#A#oo was also automaticly a classic when I first listened to it, but LYSF took more time to digest. |
Arnaud
04.29.13 | Haven't seen The Seer being mentioned above, anyone instant 5'd it? |
Cygnatti
04.29.13 | taylor swift - discography |
StallionMang
04.29.13 | Endtroducing
Frances The Mute
Dark Side of the Moon
In The Aeroplane Over the Sea
OK Computer
311: Greatest Hits '93-'03 (laugh if you want) |
climactic
04.29.13 | fucking POWERSLAVE |
facupm
07.29.13 | Master of Reality |
danielito19
08.01.13 | what fool dug out this corpse |
YakNips
08.01.13 | City of Caterpillar - self-titled
DGD - Downtown Battle Moutain
Godspeed - Antennas and F# |
keyokeyo
08.01.13 | 2 and 3, Nick Drake |
JohnnyoftheWell
08.01.13 | Oceansize - Frames was more or less a 5, but I don't believe in 1-listen 5s; an album has to grow on me or remain consistent for a decent while first |
Mongi123
08.01.13 | Upon first listen:
Brand New- Devil And God Raging Inside Me
Explosions In The Sky- Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place
10 Years- The Autumn Effect
Tool- Lateralus |
Mister Twister
08.01.13 | Probably both Majestic albums, but that's because I'm kind of a fanboy for that band, which is weird considering they've been broken up for 12 years and only made two albums that received very little attention anywhere. Not fair that they didn't since they're stellar, but w/e.
Easiest one going into not counting those two albums though, probably Extravasation by Aspid. |
MosesMalone
08.01.13 | Everything by that handsome devil, duh. |
Sleaper
08.01.13 | Maybe dark fantasy.
Watching the short film followed by getting a super early leak, it was amazing.
ACs MPP, feels
Beatles rubber soul
wu tang 36 chambers |
SIMBOLIC
08.01.13 | number of the beast, dark side, WYWH, Rust, Jane Doe, 36 chambers, Ziggy, Symbolic Human are all 5s no second thoughts for me |
PortraitsOfDecay
08.01.13 | Streetlight Manifesto - Everything Goes Numb
Brand New - The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me
Captain, We're Sinking - The Future Is Cancelled
|
Spag
08.01.13 | In The Woods... - Heart of the Ages
Devin Townsend - Ocean Machine: Biomech
Ulver - Shadows of the Sun |
adkymo
08.01.13 | the devil and god are 5ing inside me
and that one classic album weezer did |
SIMBOLIC
08.01.13 | idk about ocean machine solid 4 but thats it for me, but to each |
Spag
08.01.13 | well that's YOUR opinion and I respect it man! |