CrownOfMagnets
06.15.11 | needs ctts |
Decapod
06.15.11 | Honorable mentions:
Thursday - Full Collapse
Neutral Milk Hotel - In the Aeroplane Over the Sea
My Morning Jacket - Circuital/Evil Urges
Animal Collective - Merriweather Post Pavilion (what a shit band)
|
Decapod
06.15.11 | Ctts? |
CrownOfMagnets
06.15.11 | circle takes the square, bro. |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | Needs more Defeater and less Nirvana |
Decapod
06.15.11 | They suck as well. "As the Roots Undo". SHIT! |
Decapod
06.15.11 | Nirvana is the worst band ever. |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | explain |
Esky
06.15.11 | Completely disagree on one, not fussed on the others. |
Satellite
06.15.11 | intelligent list bro |
Decapod
06.15.11 | Boring song strctures, awful lyrics, even worse voice. Only thing that was good about Nirvana was Dave Grohl, and now hes
in the shitty Foo Fighters. |
Decapod
06.15.11 | intelligent list bro
Thanks BRO. |
cirq
06.15.11 | btbam |
Decapod
06.15.11 | btbam
btbam[2]
|
jayfatha
06.15.11 | Regardless of your opinion on Nirvana, list still needs Defeater, Isis, Circle Takes The Square and At The Drive-In |
Decapod
06.15.11 | Isis and At the Drive-In? I think not. |
Acanthus
06.15.11 | 2, 4, and 5 agreed. Haven't heard the others. |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | Oh, I think so. Two of sputnik's favorite snoozefest bands. |
rasputin
06.15.11 | lol at at the drive-in being a snoozefest
but then again
5 classic
Aesthetic Perfection Close to Human
Aesthetic Perfection A Violent Emotion
All That Remains The Fall of Ideals
All That Remains This Darkened Heart
Andrew W.K. I Get Wet
Behemoth Zos Kia Cultus (Here and Beyond)
Buckethead Enter the Chicken
Buckethead A Real Diamond In The Rough
Cannibal Corpse Tomb of the Mutilated
In Flames The Jester Race
In Flames Clayman
Iron Maiden Seventh Son of a Seventh Son
Iron Maiden Powerslave
Iron Maiden The Number of the Beast
Mitch Hedberg Mitch All Together
Nine Inch Nails Pretty Hate Machine
Nirvana In Utero
NWA Straight Outta Compton
Pantera The Great Southern Trendkill
Pantera Vulgar Display of Power
Primus Antipop
Primus Sailing the Seas of Cheese
Public Enemy It Takes a Nation of Millions to Hold Us
Red Hot Chili Peppers Californication
Scar Symmetry Pitch Black Progress
Slayer Decade of Aggression
Slayer Seasons in the Abyss
Snot Get Some
System of a Down Sugar
System of a Down System of a Down
The Sign of the Southern Cross Of Mountains and Moonshine
Whitechapel A New Era of Corruption
lol |
Slum
06.15.11 | Haven't seen this list before, well done! |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | Ok, now that we've established that we both have different opinions, I still think At The Drive-In is boring. |
Aids
06.15.11 | how is The Dear Hunter overrated here? i didnt even know people liked them much. and i dont think anyone likes evil urges by my morning jacket. z is good though. |
Slum
06.15.11 | If people like it, it's overrated |
Aids
06.15.11 | nice your got your 5s copy/pasted by rasputin. those are some pretty bad 5s haha sorry. |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | My 5s are my 5s man. Ain't shit gonna take my 5s away from me. |
linchpin313
06.15.11 | strongly agree apart from 5. |
Aids
06.15.11 | yeah i know i was just saying. irrelevant as fuck but still funny. |
Strider
06.15.11 | But, Decapod, are you sure you're on the right website? |
jayfatha
06.15.11 | It is kinda funny |
xenocide.
06.15.11 | "Overrating" bands/albums is helpful. If I see that certain number of people rates an album very high, I tend to check it
out. What I usually find is a piece of really good music. Maybe not 5-worthy for me, but often I can see why people
consider it classic, it just doesn't have such a strong impact on me. For example I don'think "Relationship of Command"
is a
masterpiece, but I have to admit it's a well crafted post-hardcore album, and a great addition to my music library. In
conclusion, "overrating" is OK. |
dimsim3478
06.15.11 | I can see how people would think these are overrated, but in my opinion, they are all pretty damn good (except one, 'cause I haven't heard it). |
omnipanzer
06.15.11 | Well your account was started in 09 so I can assume you are at least 15... can we stop with the "overrated" lists please?
Did you at least get the attention you were looking for deca? |
BallsToTheWall
06.15.11 | 3 is classic screw you. |
anarchistfish
06.15.11 | 4 is classic screw you. |
demigod!
06.15.11 | not sure why Nirvana is here |
VicariousIntent
06.15.11 | Weird choices for this list. |
Relinquished
06.15.11 | 3 is nearly a classic. and c'mon man you say boring song structures but look how repetitive godflesh
is. i love godflesh with my being but you gotta agree. |
Wolfhorde
06.15.11 | Mods could just name all "overrated/underrated" lists as "Let the bitchfight commence". |
Phideaux
06.15.11 | 1, 2 and 3 are good. |
PistolPete
06.15.11 | 4 is unreal, listen to it again! |
MO
06.15.11 | yea 3 is a great album |
Idnuf
06.15.11 | Never seen this list before. |
crabman
06.15.11 | Nirvana is underrated on this site
|
Trebor.
06.15.11 | 4 only has a 4, and 5 only has a 4.1
That's not that high. |
MopHeadOvMetal
06.15.11 | IN FLAMES - CLAYMAN! |
Blackbelt54
06.15.11 | I think 2 and 5 are overrated, but not 3 and 4 |
MopHeadOvMetal
06.15.11 | Beggars just has 3.9 |
FilthyBorgir
06.15.11 | I totally agree on 4 |
FatChickIrl
06.15.11 | lol its filthyborgir |
theusual1
06.19.11 | Looking at your music interests, i can see why you wouldn't like 1 and 2, but that doesn't make them overrated. If anything The Dear Hunter don't get enough credit for their work. They have just released 36 new songs none of which are repetitive. |
MalleusMaleficarum
06.19.11 | you sir, are a giant moron! 3 ruuuuuuules your faaayyyycceeee |
Psychopathologist
06.19.11 | 3 is ok but overrated |
Alexcore
06.19.11 | I'd be happy to offer you my cock for mentioning ctts,fuckers. |
Psychopathologist
06.19.11 | except that ctts is phenomenal |
MalleusMaleficarum
06.19.11 | nah 3 is classic for me bro fuckin classic dawg brejeroin |
Psychopathologist
06.19.11 | classic in the sense that it inspired countless bands to play the same style which ultimately led to the death of the whole metalcore genre? |
MalleusMaleficarum
06.19.11 | exactly. thats power right there. |
botb
06.19.11 | 5 yeah... but otherwise you're extremely dumb. |
Alexcore
06.19.11 | @ Psychopathologist
But...that's why I'd offer my cock.For punishment to those who underestimate ctts. |
Leviathan8937
06.21.11 | This list is just poop ,is lame as the list of the worst album ever where you included 3 masterpieces of the modern times , piss on you son of a bitch |
TheSadLittleDinosaur
06.22.11 | ... Nirvana. Overrated on Sputnik. What the hell are you talking about? And seriously? How can you think CTTS and BTBAM are overrated? So you don't like them. That doesn't mean they're overrated, or even bad.
I'm beginning to think you're just a bad troll. |
toxin.
06.22.11 | These just sound like bands that Sputnik loves, minus any ballsy choices (put Radiohead there and we'd be talking about a real [and controversial] list) |
jdennis31
06.29.11 | thrice is awesome f u hahaha jk, but seriously if thrice didn't have such a high rating on most of their albums i'd assume everyone on sputnik hates thrice just from looking through comments. |