MetalMassacreAttack: Metallica Albums, Best To Worst

MetalMassacreAttack 07.14.09	Really hard to choose between RtL and MoP, but I did. My ratings: MoP: 5.0 RtL: 5.0 AJfA: 4.5 KeA: 4.0 DM: 4.0 Black: 4.0 Load: 3.5 Reload: 3.0 st.A: 1.5
AliW1993 07.14.09	my list is mop (4.5) rtl (4.5) black (4.5) ajfa (4) dm (4) kea (4) load (3) sa (3) reload (2)
ninjuice 07.14.09	Best Metallica ranking I've seen in a while.
shindip 07.14.09	i think 6 should be higher, but otherwise everythign right
Zip 07.14.09	Well, if six was higher, where would it go? Think about it. Great list, completely correct.
Yazz_Flute 07.14.09	This is probably the most cliche Metallica ranking ever tbh. Personally i'd switch 1 and 2, as well as 3 and 4.
PanasonicYouth 07.14.09	Good thing they all suck.
Yotimi 07.14.09	List is correct, except I'd probably switch 5&6.
ConorMichaelJoseph 07.14.09	1, 3, 2, 5, 6, 4, 9, 8, and 7 for me
SeaAnemone 07.14.09	i think you mean worst to worst... with a load of worst in between.
ConorMichaelJoseph 07.14.09	stfu gtfo
KILL 07.14.09	good one
Zip 07.14.09	more lulz
Fxxkit13 07.14.09	RtL is so much better then MoP and KeA is better then And Justice... by far
robertsona 07.14.09	metallica is bad lal
ConorMichaelJoseph 07.14.09	:'(
robertsona 07.14.09	i dont care for their music and that's subjective but who else has found them self-obsessed and egotistical as if they like 'invented' metal or whatever. idk just a vibe i get
KILL 07.14.09	indie kids please leave this lsit
SeaAnemone 07.14.09	indie kids unite
Fxxkit13 07.14.09	They didnt invent metal, they only perfected it every way, shape and form possible
robertsona 07.14.09	lmfao what
ConorMichaelJoseph 07.14.09	Well they're constantly praising bands like Deep Purple, Aerosmith, Thin Lizzy, Iron Maiden and Motorhead as their favourite influences so I doubt they think that they invented metal. They have become a little bit too rock-starry though, mostly Lars but he's the least talented member of the band anyway, more of a business man so w/e
robertsona 07.14.09	not 'invented' but idk something else just bothers me about them
Fxxkit13 07.14.09	Their very pompous nowadays
SeaAnemone 07.14.09	meowadays
Phantom 07.14.09	Justice Ride Master S&M Kill Garage Death Black Load St. Anger Reload
M@rty 07.14.09	It's a good list, but I'd ditch Ride down to 4th. Kill, Puppets and Justice don't have a single bad track. Ride has Escape, definitely in the bottom ten if I were to rank every song they've done. I'd also put Reload over Load, but that's a closer call.
shindip 07.14.09	S&M tops all of their studio stuff, but its not on this list
Bullitt 07.14.09	All good except DM isn't better than the black album.
cvlts 07.14.09	@list prty much...
KILL 07.14.09	no shindip, just no
combustion07 07.14.09	Switch Kill em all with MoP and you have my list.
ConorMichaelJoseph 07.14.09	Death Magnetic owns the Black Album so hard in almost every way, except for the production. Also I much prefer St Anger to the Loads. @Shindip, as much as I love S&M I wouldn't say its their best effort, perhaps it would be number 6 on my list.
ninjuice 07.15.09	DM is easily better than the black album.
KILL 07.15.09	black album is better than death magnetic
Fxxkit13 07.15.09	i dont like either tbh
Phantom 07.15.09	Why is the colour of the 'username' and 'real name' switched round on this profile?
crismarschner 07.15.09	Except 7'd be my 1 LOL! Gudi listi
MetalMassacreAttack 07.15.09	Thanks everybody for the (mostly) smart comments. RtL is very special to me since it was my first metallica album and stuff, but after spending hours comparing and contrasting the two I found MoP slightly superior. KeM is fantastic but the production and overall package aren´t as good as AJfA´s, even though that album has its own issues. Black´s got some of the most amazing tracks Metallica´s ever written (The Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters, among others), but also has too much slow, filler material. Death Magnetic on the other hand doesn´t have such breathtaking moments, but sounds really good through all of its 75 minutes.
brainsheldis 07.15.09	Exactly mine except switch Black with Death
Matheusmetal 07.15.09	My list: MoP (5,0) RtL (5,0) AjA (4,5) Kill (4,5) Black (4,5) Death (4,5) Load (3,5) St Anger (3,0) Reload (3,0)
Greggers 07.15.09	This list is exactly the same as mine would be
Bullitt 07.15.09	Black album is better than DM...end of story.
ninjuice 07.15.09	no not at all
ninjuice 07.15.09	All Nightmare Long >>>>> Black album
Bullitt 07.15.09	Enter Sandman>>>>>> All Nightmare Long
ninjuice 07.15.09	no way
Bullitt 07.15.09	like a fox
KILL 07.16.09	"Enter Sandman>>>>>> All Nightmare Long" well duh
Matheusmetal 07.16.09	Enter Sandman >>>>>>>> All Nightmare Long³
MetalMassacreAttack 07.17.09	Comparing Enter Sandman to All Nightmare Long is kind of pointless to me, they're so different and don't even represent that much of their respective albums, even though the former probably is metallica's biggest mainstream hit (except maybe for One, not sure).
Bullitt 07.20.09	The point i was making was that imo enter sandman is better than all nightmare long. Which was the song he says is better than the whole black album. Chill.
MetalMassacreAttack 07.27.09	Aight, mate. All Nightmare Long seems to be a bit overrated. Fine tune, simply not that great.
FadeToBlack 07.27.09	2 1 4 3 6
Bullitt 07.29.09	Agreed
MetalMassacreAttack 08.04.09	These were exacly the positions that I was in doubt, Fade, but now I´m pretty happy with my choices.