MusicReviewer44
04.18.09 | Meant to put "AND" the E Street Shuffle on 9. Anyway, these arejust off the top of my head. No real thought put into it. |
fireaboveicebelow
04.18.09 | lol no real thought put into what you consider classic records? |
bodiesinflight57
04.18.09 | What an incredibly generic list of what are considered to be 'classic' classic rock records
5 is awesome
6 is quite awesome
I don't own any of the others |
ninjuice
04.19.09 | You know there's plenty of great music that's been made in the last 25 years. |
gaslightanthem
04.19.09 | doesn't stop all of these other than 8 being fucking awesome |
AngelofDeath
04.19.09 | Hey, what do you know? Four of the most overrated songwriters in history: Bob Dylan, John Lennon, Bruce Springsteen, and Tom Petty.
Pink Floyd can stay though. |
MusicReviewer44
04.19.09 | Shut up AngelofDeath. These are my opinions, not yours. Make your own list. |
AngelofDeath
04.19.09 | Just because Rolling Stone says these guys are good doesn't make it true. Don't listen to everything you're told to. Bob Dylan and John Lennon are terrible singers, terrible musicians, and their songwriting is mediocre at best. |
fireaboveicebelow
04.19.09 | newbie making a statement I like it |
ConorMichaelJoseph
04.19.09 | Nobody takes Rolling Stone seriously. A person is allowed to believe whatever they think is great, and to call Dylan and Lennon 'terrible' is incredibly ignorant. They were an inspiration to many and for good reason-they were great. I seriously doubt anyway that you are a better singer, musician or songwriter than them anyways. |
Yotimi
04.20.09 | AngelofDeath is just the only one smart enough to realize that all the greatest songwriters are in metal bands. |
AngelofDeath
04.20.09 | Oh, yeah, you pegged me. Roger Waters and Paul McCartney are incredible songwriters. The rest of these guys are not. |
Knott-
04.20.09 | AngelofDeath's comment makes him a moron but this IS an incredibly generic list. |
Yotimi
04.20.09 | agreed |
AngelofDeath
04.20.09 | I understand my opinion is no more valid than anyone else's. I guess I came off a bit too abrasive and apologize if anyone was offended. |
Knott-
04.20.09 | Nahhh I just think you're wrong, haha. Like, most people would agree that Dylan is universally considered a genius. The trouble is there's nothing on this last - at ALL - that stands out as being different or non-populist. Even I've heard 5 of them, and I HATE most music from before I was born. List is just so...generic. Word is 100% accurate. |
Chewie
04.26.09 | agreed with gaslight |
KILL
04.26.09 | what a surprise |
bloc
04.26.09 | i agree, this is a bit generic |
Ryus
07.27.20 | nice list |
Colton
07.27.20 | Lol I made this during a time when I thought the only modern music that existed was Kesha, Black Eyed Peas and Katy Perry. Reminds me how much this site shaped my taste growing up |
Ryus
07.27.20 | trust me i know how that feels lol
i probably made a list exactly like this |
Minushuman24
07.27.20 | Part 2 when |
Colton
07.27.20 | 11 year old me telling AngelofDeath to shut up holy shit lmao. I was so offended |
sixdegrees
07.27.20 | you were right |
Ryus
07.27.20 | "AngelofDeath is just the only one smart enough to realize that all the greatest songwriters are in metal bands."
lol |
Minushuman24
07.27.20 | lmao |
ArsMoriendi
01.23.21 | Wait this is Colton's old account? nice |
parksungjoon
01.23.21 | lol |
NorthernSkylark
01.23.21 | Back in the days when Colton didn’t contain multitudes |
SlothcoreSam
07.01.21 | Needs more variety |
Colton
07.02.21 | Shut up SlothcoreSam. These are my opinions, not yours. Make your own list.
|
FadedSun
07.02.21 | "Oh, yeah, you pegged me. Roger Waters and Paul McCartney are incredible songwriters. The rest of these guys are not."
Pfft, Tom Petty wrote a lot of awesome songs. Get out of here, dude. But, yeah, list is as generic as could possibly be. |
Colton
07.02.21 | same as previous comment except directed at you this time |
FadedSun
07.02.21 | I don't make lists. Maybe if Sput was better organized, I would. But lists suck haha. |