clavier
08.16.17 | May the games begin. |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | judges - I'd rec getting together a google doc where u consolidate ur writeups/scores.
lemme browse thru the judges' ratings before I give my first rec. gonna be hard to find an album all of u havent heard |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | I won't rec anything until I know all the competitors are it. |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | oh nice site is working again |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | I wanted to check if Sputnik was down on Isitdown.com and the Isitdown.com broke down... |
clavier
08.16.17 | Alright, I've made a doc, gonna shoutbox DeadlyNightShade with the link since he's not on Discord
|
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | ok I checked all ur ratings and u didnt have this artist let alone album rated so:
1. Algernon Cadwallader - Some Kind of Cadwallader
some classic emo revival shit |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | 1) Cap'n'Jazz - Shamp'n'Shmazz
Keepin' it safe. |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | hahah perfect, u get to hear the OG and then the band that is the OG revived |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | Should have waited for Artuma to show up. Now I feel bad that he didn't even get to be around the grand opening. |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | yeah he in Scandinavia so his time zone is a bit fucked |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | also 10 bucks says Jack (LandDiving) already knows both those albums we rec'd |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | I'm in Europe now too and he should have around the same timezone. So like 19-21 or something. |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | I checked and he hasn't rated mine yet... |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | he hasnt rated a lot of things tho so his ratings are basically useless |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | and wait really Unique? why you in Europe? |
clavier
08.16.17 | jack unfortunately doesn't rate everything he's listened to (neither do I, but I can promise I have not heard these yet) |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | btw since theres 5 of u, you can keep the writeups p short (2-4 sentences) |
ZombieToyDuck
08.16.17 | agreed con and I took the liberty of organizing the google doc (inspired by our post-punk chat that we set up for the other competition) |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | yeah the post punk google doc is a fun place
almost wish I was a judge for this one! |
clavier
08.16.17 | Thanks for organizing it, much appreciated |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | Can the rest of us at least have a peak at the docs once this is over? |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | yeah when post punk is over we will make public |
ianblxdsoe
08.16.17 | heckin yeah |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | Has anyone shoutboxed the other participants? |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | u mean Art? |
ianblxdsoe
08.16.17 | cmon art where u at |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | Frivolous
LandDiving
Artuma |
Artuma
08.16.17 | no worries guys i'm here to save this round
the jim yoshii pile-up - it's winter here |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | He came, at last |
Artuma
08.16.17 | interesting to see how a cap'n jazz rip-off band will fight against the legends |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | ikr I literally said that ahah. but in a nicer way (; |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | Man, next time I'll wait for Con to rec first again, so I can find a fitting anti-rec. |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | not fair man! |
clavier
08.16.17 | ok, now I can start listening
I've messaged all the judges, jack's probably sleeping rn |
clavier
08.16.17 | A quick warning: should I end up going on vacation without much internet, someone will need to temporarily make the threads (I will alert beforehand) |
Conmaniac
08.16.17 | thx for the heads up! if needed, in a couple days Asleep can fill in as a judge so that might be something to consider since he wanted to be included as well |
clavier
08.16.17 | sure, that might a good idea, we'll see when the time comes |
Joeman82
08.16.17 | CAP'N JAZZ! Supreme rec Unique |
ianblxdsoe
08.16.17 | when we gotta have these done by would you say?? |
Papa Universe
08.16.17 | As soon as possible. Not necessarily within three hours after the albums are submitted, but like at least a day, two days tops (that'd already be a stretch). |
Conmaniac
08.17.17 | ill jam 4 and do short write ups as well |
Papa Universe
08.17.17 | [2] |
Conmaniac
08.17.17 | Art with quite the contrast of a rec I must say |
Artuma
08.17.17 | lol yeah it's not a very lively album |
Conmaniac
08.17.17 | I dig tho man. on the last song |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | anddd this already is taking longer than it should smh... if I can do this, run the post punk competition, still do my work at my job, and listen to other recreational albums then we should have writeups and ratings done already |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I can only assume that others also take extra long perscription naps. Don't question it, it's a condition. |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | truth man, we have a lot of judges so if any judge feels the need to drop now please do so before you drag this out longer than necessary
not trying to be mean, just realistic... |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | Unique, I'm an impatient individual its in my blood, pretty sure you are a bit too haha |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | oh all three of us are dont kid yourself |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | I mean shit con we gave prior notice to all involved that they need to be on top of it and if not don't get involved so I don't find it mean at all.
also I know you are con lol |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I think you're being fairly mild... |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | i agree i agree. i kinda figured this might happen, hard to coordinate between 8 different ppl all in scattered time zones tho. |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | yeah, I suppose but still its been an ample amount of time for 3 albums to listen to and give a 2-3 sentence writeup for... |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Shit, I listened to four albums today alone. And each of them more than once and I've got more than three sentences written down. |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | I have my writeups ready as well, even tho I've only listened to Capn Jazz's discog album, all the songs on this album are in there |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | sincerelyaural is posting this shortly, we are just missing ian but shes gunna post anyhow |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I think he can't do anything anymore since than Brand New album numbed down his senses. |
clavier
08.18.17 | updated! |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I think it's about time I post something as well. |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | nice nice, in last place but tis a small set back. that Jim Yoshi Pile Up album was fantastic so im not even mad. here are my write ups |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | By the way, are we going with averages or sums for the competitors? |
clavier
08.18.17 | oh, i think sums might be better |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | Cap'n Jazz - Absolute classic even if it's very rough around the edges. Really revolutionized the idea of sporadic, messy emo which we see so often today, even if its now a bit more refined (although I believe Algernon did a fantastic job of recreating this feeling) 3.9/5
TJYPU - Im just now learning and beginning to appreciate restraint within music, and although this at first seems like one of those loud/soft emo albums it resides within the subtleties. Some gorgeous stuff on here, I must say. The vocals are so emo but they are what I strive for in my own softer vocals, impassioned yet gorgeous and actually accurate note wise. I figure this one will win the round, well done. 4.2/5 |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | and yeah do sums not avg |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Jeez, am I the only one, who's not so head-over-heels about that Yoshi album? |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | i guess so, I'll admit defeat when it's warranted but I would give my own rec a 4.1...
I'm not worried though, this round was just a warm up (: |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I'd give my rec around 4.0-4.1 too. It's not my favourite Emo album, but I went with a fairly safe choice, no risks yet. |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | The Jim Yoshii Pile-Up - It's Winter Here
The instrumetnation on this album ranges from impressively progressive and inriguingly engulfing, to uneventfully tedious and forgettably dreary. The subpar vocals don't really help either. However, this album has a certain odd charm to it that just grips, besides, the aforementioned intriguing parts, where the instrumentation keeps progressing and building up towards something are actually worthwhile, it's just that their destination is often unreached. 3.3/5
BEST SONGS: Jetzt Mit Iodine; Peter Vonn Pinnon Final Draft; partially Before I Left, After I Got Back
Algernon Cadwallder - Some Kind of Cadwallder
Vocally annoying and also quite drab in songwriting, but still having some kind of angered and tormented charm to it. It's in no way an outstanding record, it's just a little intriguing at times, and forgettably bland in others. 3.0/5
BEST SONGS: Horror, Yo Soy Milk, partially In Response to Irresponsibility |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | you won me over con haha |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | also scores:
Con: 14.9
Art: 17.2
Unique: 16 |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | but yeah that jim yoshii album was something special |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | I would've rec'd Fun by Algernon if I could but thats an EP |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | We can do an all EP round. This was, I assume, the only round with no restrictions. |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | The judges have to decide upon the criteria for individual future rounds. |
ZombieToyDuck
08.18.17 | I was thinking that too Unique but we will see |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | yeah not up to us, judges should decide! excited to see whats in store next |
Artuma
08.18.17 | wait i defeated cap'n jazz? sweet |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | But you (judges) do have some kind of idea of a challenge for the next round, right? |
clavier
08.18.17 | indeed we do! |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | :D |
clavier
08.18.17 | alas, i'll be away starting tomorrow |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | For how long? |
clavier
08.18.17 | a week |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | We'll get someone to take over the steering position... |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | away without wifi? |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Can we get AsleepInTheBack in or do we just go with 4 judges (that might be a tad easier)? |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Ian still hasn't submitted? |
Conmaniac
08.18.17 | ian is out of the judging panel, I can ask Asleep |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Or we can just leave 4 people in the running...but yeah, we kinda promised Asleep a gig, so let him know. |
AsleepInTheBack
08.18.17 | You said my name, I appear |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | Man, he's like a genie of self-love... |
AsleepInTheBack
08.18.17 | I'm totally freed up and down for this, but if it's easier to just leave it as is that's cool |
Papa Universe
08.18.17 | I mean, I'll have to scour through your ratings a little, but that's fine. I'm down for it, if others are. Go talk it over with the other judges, they've got like some kind of Google Docs hideout. |
AsleepInTheBack
08.19.17 | ey the site is back up. so, whats happening? |
Papa Universe
08.20.17 | You're in the team now, congrats. |
AsleepInTheBack
08.20.17 | sweet. am I jamming these or starting in the next round? |
Papa Universe
08.20.17 | Next round, but we first need to figure out, who's gonne be in charge of the administration. |
Papa Universe
08.20.17 | It could be you, though. |
AsleepInTheBack
08.20.17 | Plot twist |
ZombieToyDuck
08.31.17 | this jim yoshii album is fucking me up rn |
Artuma
09.01.17 | my point right there |
AsleepInTheBack
09.01.17 | Stay safe deadly, don't listen to too much depressing shit given your current circumstances; it probably won't help |
Drifter
03.09.22 | wait wtf how did i miss this |
Conmaniac
03.09.22 | What happened with this holy |