guilouzzz: Blackwater Park VS Still life ?

MeatSalad 09.23.15	Still life probably, doesn't drag as hard as bwp
MotoOnSputnik 09.23.15	Still Life for the atmosphere and overall album cohesion, BWP for individual tracks. They sort of line up with Lateralus and Aenima in the same way, with Lateralus being a more fully realized album, and Aenima having more songs that are good on their own.
jtswope 09.23.15	Still Life
MotoOnSputnik 09.23.15	Both are 5s btw
MistaCrave 09.23.15	Still Life
CapnJizz 09.23.15	my arms your hearse > both
ScuroFantasma 09.23.15	Still Life overall, though I could probably listen to BWP more and not get bored of it as quick
CaimanJesus 09.23.15	Heritage is undeniably better than both.
porcupinetheater 09.23.15	Everything MotoOnSputnik said is dead on the money.
MistaCrave 09.23.15	But yeah My Arms, Your Hearse schools both of these.
Keyblade 09.23.15	bwp
dathvada321 09.23.15	Blackwater Park
MotoOnSputnik 09.23.15	Hey thanks porcupine :D
SharkTooth 09.23.15	bwp
Spec 09.23.15	Still Life.
StarlessCore 09.23.15	mayh is better than both
Dinosaur 09.23.15	Bwp has the sparklez
DungeonBoy 09.23.15	Still Life
Funeralopolis 09.23.15	still life not even close
zaruyache 09.23.15	I've never understood the crazy hype for either album, but they're both pretty good. BWP all the way, though. Still Life feels like individual sections in songs are good, but a lot of them just never click altogether for me. BWP's a little better in that regard.
Funeralopolis 09.23.15	because still life is haunting, has great atmosphere, genuine emotion, next level songwriting where riffs repeat but never overstay their welcome every member of the band greatly contributes to the story, emotion and feel of the album. The soft/heavy transitions are absolutely seamless and feel completely inspired. Many excellent riffs, incredible vocals and absolutely breathtaking moments.
zaruyache 09.23.15	Ghost Reveries does it better :3
Nocturnalize 09.23.15	Colors
JohnnyoftheWell 09.23.15	I've never understood the crazy hype for either album, but they're both pretty good. BWP all the way, though. Still Life feels like individual sections in songs are good, but a lot of them just never click altogether for me. BWP's a little better in that regard. [2] (although I did have a BWP fangirl phase). Morningrise is better than Still Life
Keyblade 09.23.15	morningrise is best yeah but agreed hard with zaru
GnarlyShillelagh 09.23.15	Black water but still life isn't far behind Haven't listened to either in ages tho, damn needa reconnect with mike n the boys
CamiloG 09.23.15	Still life for me, the concept is excellent, the atmosphere, and the compositions are top notch. Though Blackwater Park is awesome, it has more down points than Still Life.
HellPriest 09.23.15	Orchid. They steadily went downhill after the first one
evilford 09.23.15	Still life
smaugman 09.23.15	bwp
Flugmorph 09.23.15	Still life. Has best riffs
BandNewbac 09.23.15	neither
Aftertheascension 09.23.15	BWP but it's very close. "Orchid. They steadily went downhill after the first one" how so?
JokineAugustus 09.23.15	Still Life is better easy
Flugmorph 09.23.15	Shut your cunt todds
romulanrancor 09.23.15	bwp, but still life is amazing as well
FluttRTrank 09.23.15	Still Life is years better.
InFlamesWeThrash666 09.23.15	Ghost Reveries yo
Spag 09.23.15	BWP.
Flugmorph 09.23.15	MA,YH jo
Davil667 09.23.15	[2]
MO 09.23.15	SL hard but yea MAYH forev
TheSpirit 09.23.15	Ghost Reveries
HellPriest 09.23.15	@ Aftertheascension Each successive album got steadily less adventurous and more boring. Once BWP hit, it became so formulaic. Maybe it's because MAYH was my first exposure to the band when it first came out and I worked my way backwards.
Aftertheascension 09.23.15	Lmfao static I almost didn't notice @hellpriest fair enough, I just disagree because I'm a helpless fanboy of bwp.
trvvve 09.23.15	bwp still life's second half simply doesn't do it for me
bnelso55 09.23.15	Still Life's concept, composition, and atmosphere produce a sort of folktale-like quality, which I appreciate. The consistent presentation of the storyline also helps the album function well as a unit. That said, I think some of Blackwater Park's individual moments have a greater emotional effect on me.
EyesWideShut 09.23.15	Still Life but Ghost of Perdition is their best song
zaruyache 09.23.15	Orchid was them just copy-pasting guitar riff sections together tho. On their later stuff they actually wrote songs.
HellPriest 09.23.15	boring ones
Flugmorph 09.23.15	@trvvve still life's second half is the reason its my fav album
DoctorDoom 09.23.15	Still Life always.
Flugmorph 09.25.15	How could you not like the last 3 songs on still life just why.
Insurrection 09.25.15	still life is damn near perfect so that
CamiloG 09.25.15	"Still life is damn near perfect..." Still life IS perfect
emester 09.25.15	Morningrise
DominionMM1 09.25.15	blackwater park. it has a sense of menace that still life doesn't. oh and the t/t of course.