trve
04.07.15 | the first half would be exactly my list but 14 is clearly 15 |
TheSpaceMan
04.07.15 | as usual on these lists obscured is criminally low |
KerfuffleinaHussle
04.07.15 | 1 is 1 fo sho |
CapnJizz
04.07.15 | 5 is 1
9 is 2
13 is too low
pretty much agree with the rest |
Tunaboy45
04.07.15 | 1 is 1 |
Artuma
04.08.15 | better than most floyd lists here but wtf is 13 doing down there |
evilford
04.08.15 | 10 should be higher, 3 is 1 |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | @artuma how this looks like every sputnik user's floyd ranking ever |
evilford
04.08.15 | Also 6 is bottom 5 |
oltnabrick
04.08.15 | 12 is 1 |
Artuma
04.08.15 | "how this looks like every sputnik user's floyd ranking ever"
somewhat yeah but usually there are at least a few albums placed somewhere completely else than i'd place them. this has only one of those albums. and the wall of course but i've given up on trying to make people like it more |
evilford
04.08.15 | 3> 1> 5>10> 2> 4> 8> 7> 13> 9> 12> 15> 11> 6 |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | cmon ford 6 is better than 10! though a lot of the true proggers on here probably disagree with hat |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | holy fuck I posted that before I saw your ranking theres no way I could persuade you. on the money with dark side tho
@artuma I getchya, and yeah the wall hate is ridiculous |
ConcubinaryCode
04.08.15 | The wall is awesome |
evilford
04.08.15 | I know most people don't share my high opinion Of the final cut but I love it hard. Wayyyyyyyyy better than 6 Imo. TDB was utter horse poop |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | Dark Side > Wish > Meddle = Animals > Piper > The Wall > Obscured > Saucerful > TDB > TFC > Atom Hear > rest which are tied - endless river because I still haven't gotten around to that |
DrGonzo1937
04.08.15 | 5 is too high, but I agree with the top two |
evilford
04.08.15 | piper fuckin rules |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | agreed syd is a genius |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | wish he took one less tab of acid and at least kept up his solo work madcap rulez |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | huh I see a floyd list here, contractually obliged to post, so on so forth
sup fordy/nick? |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | duuude sup did your floyd senses tingle? |
nakedwesmile
04.08.15 | the elevator music of the division bell is fighting hard with the banal 80s "art rock" of a momentary lapse of reason for the most worthless floyd release award |
evilford
04.08.15 | Yo dude how's it goin? Just doin my part to represent TFC!! |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | i have a complicated web of informants, black market dealers and bitcoin hired assassins who inform me when a list about pink floyd is posted on sputnikmusic.com
at the centre of this web i sit like a grotesque, gilmour-worshipping arachnid
i sense every tingle and quiver
EVERY ONE
...
sup ford yeah TFC is a fucking tops album, I wouldn't put it any lower than 6 because of HOLD ON TO THE DREEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAM mostly |
evilford
04.08.15 | *Feely sax solo* |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | that vocal meld into the sax goddamn man it gets me everytime |
CrazyDiamond7
04.08.15 | The Division Bell is waaaaaay too high, and I'd put Piper above Mettle, but other than that it's a pretty good list |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | lol rowan i picture you having all eight of your arachnid arms clasped together in a tibetan monk meditation during the "animals >" convos, only raising an eyelid for a true pf comment |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | also sorry for a lack of capitalization in that comment im eating Cheetos with my left hand and respect my shift key |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | 5 is 1 is acceptable but yeah 9 aint 2 esp if 5 is 1 |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | nick you basically nailed it lol I'm in deepfreeze Han Solo style whenever the threads devolve into that rankin bullshit |
tempest--
04.08.15 | haven't seen rowan in months
pink floyd ranked
well look who it is |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | I was around like last week lad what are you on about |
tempest--
04.08.15 | DUDE |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | MATE |
ButteryBiscuitBass
04.08.15 | 1 is 1 [2] |
Rowan5215
04.08.15 | butteryballs too, it's positively the brady bunch in here |
ButteryBiscuitBass
04.08.15 | It's unreal. |
DrGonzo1937
04.08.15 | Gilmour-Waters >>> Syd |
TheSpaceMan
04.08.15 | theyre all equal in a triangle of ingeniousness |
Ryus
04.08.15 | 10 should be higher, 3 is 1 [2] |
smaugman
04.08.15 | correct |
JamieTwort
04.08.15 | 6 is ridiculously high. |
guitarded_chuck
04.08.15 | switch 13 with 6 and u p much have my ranking not bad for a NOOB |
TalonsOfFire
04.08.15 | I'd switch 7 and 5 |
DrGonzo1937
04.09.15 | Yeah 6 is quite high, too. |
