Judio!
10.08.14 | lol k |
ArsMoriendi
10.08.14 | This guy doesn't get that "classic" here means "perfect" or at least "near-perfect." It's outside definition is irrelevant.
Weird. |
Lethean
10.08.14 | 5.0 "Classic" |
NorthernSkylark
10.08.14 | soo... what? |
toomanyxsinmyname
10.08.14 | 5.0 Classic
Dj Shadow |
Havey
10.08.14 | amazing list |
Phlegm
10.08.14 | heyvy |
deathschool
10.09.14 | Angry puppy doesn't fully grasp the concept behind synonyms. Why am I not surprised? |
omnipanzer
10.09.14 | yes, literally. |
TheSupernatural
10.09.14 | classic and perfect really aren't synonyms |
ArsMoriendi
10.09.14 | "classic and perfect really aren't synonyms"
On here they are. The outside definition is irrelevant. |
deathschool
10.09.14 | They actually are synonyms. Like they are literally listed as synonyms so yee. |
Funeralopolis
10.09.14 | I would say 5 means near perfect, I try to avoid the forced classic tag because it is dumb, an album can be important and influential but not perfect. |
climactic
10.09.14 | "5.0 classic" is pretty dumb imo, classic is pretty much an objective term. personal classic would make more sense but thats kind of dumb. perfect would be better but i dont think an album has to be perfect to be a 5. "masterpiece" maybe? |
someguest
10.09.14 | I quit rating albums a few years ago. Why do we explain to others why albums are so important?
Isn't keeping that to ourselves what makes it sacred? |
titanslayer
10.09.14 | "There are lost of classic albums"
lost |
Deviant.
10.09.14 | Completely agree. Bear with me a moment while I completely revamp the ratings table to reflect your clearly universal opinion |
Muisc4Life26
10.09.14 | slipknot self titled a classic? lmfao |
pedro70512
10.09.14 | How is American Idiot a classic? = Wasn't it released like...oh, wait.
I'd put Venom as the archetype of a classic that's terribly flawed. |
mxbrady
10.09.14 | Spooky is pretty spot on tbh |
deathschool
10.09.14 | Spooky is always spot on. He is this site's savior. |
Keyblade
10.09.14 | "This guy doesn't get that "classic" here means "perfect" or at least "near-perfect." It's outside definition is irrelevant."
And you don't get that ratings are completely subjective, so can mean anything to anyone. |
tempest--
10.09.14 | There are lost of classic albums that is nowhere near perfect (5/5), for example, Green Days American Idiot, Slipknots S/t and Nirvanas Nevermind |