scottpilgrim10
09.21.14 | If an amazing band releases a bad/mediocre album, does it affect how we view their legacy? |
beefshoes
09.21.14 | Just pretend that the bad albums don't exist.
Always a surefire strategy. |
BigBlob
09.21.14 | even their good stuff isn't that good. puts me to sleep |
Ryus
09.21.14 | Just pretend that the bad albums don't exist.
Always a surefire strategy. [2]
|
sonictheplumber
09.21.14 | first 4 are good you know the drill
fools |
Insurrection
09.21.14 | thought this would be a snide list |
ArsMoriendi
09.21.14 | Just pretend that the bad albums don't exist.
Always a surefire strategy. [3]
Especially with Pixies. |
Gameofmetal
09.21.14 | Terrible headline, leave 'tallica alone.
I don't think it should. Sometimes there are bad records, it's natural. If it's all bad however.... |
EnyaFangirl
09.21.14 | creeping death is the only song i fuck with tbh |
ExplosiveOranges
09.21.14 | Was about to rage until I saw the list description. Every band makes a shit album occasionally. |
scottpilgrim10
09.21.14 | It is total title bait.
I'm going to pretend that Metallica disbanded in 1989. |
jagride
09.21.14 | not a typical example but bands like the bad brains are proof that if a tiny sliver of your overall
discog is considered important enough you can get a pass on releasing 90% garbage |
SIMBOLIC
09.21.14 | they're just at a stage these days where they're basically parodying themselves |
Lethean
09.21.14 | yea |
climactic
09.21.14 | of course it affects it |
evilford
09.21.14 | yes, but each album should be viewed in it's own context. for example, the shittiness of st. anger shouldn't affect how people view and love/hate ride the lightning at all, but it does cuz people r dum |
tempest--
09.21.14 | theyre actually the best band ever |
Avagantamos
09.21.14 | their best album is like a 3 |
Funeralopolis
09.21.14 | Never understood how Metallica can still be hailed as some sorts of gods yet everyone loses their shit just at the very mention of In Flames these days |
ExplosiveOranges
09.21.14 | "their best album is like a 3"
Jam Ride The Lightning or parachute into Mt. Vesuvius. |
SharkTooth
09.21.14 | "Never understood how Metallica can still be hailed as some sorts of gods yet everyone loses their shit just at the very mention of In Flames these days"
I get the feeling that nostalgia is involved... |
tempest--
09.21.14 | funeral its because people are fuckin stupid you should know this by now |
BlackLlama
09.21.14 | I can understand not liking newer Metallica, but fuck anyone hating on Kill, Ride or Master. |
SharkTooth
09.21.14 | "Kill, Ride or Master"
for first 2 agreed, Master is overrated tho |
ArsMoriendi
09.21.14 | Thrash metal? More like trash metal! ;)
Kidding, I'm completely neutral on the genre. |
RoundOnEndHiInMiddle
09.21.14 | i would never have known if you were kidding without that explanation, i mean its not like you have a wink face there or anything |
sapient
09.21.14 | almost every band has their missteps, I take bands for the good they've made and just ignore what I don't like |
Funeralopolis
09.21.14 | It doesn't matter if a band makes an awful album cus I usually don't listen to more than 1 or 2 albums by a band anyways. |
ArsMoriendi
09.21.14 | "i would never have known if you were kidding without that explanation, i mean its not like you have a wink face there or anything"
You'd be surprised by how literal people take me. Or how quickly that'd start an angry debate. |
BMDrummer
09.21.14 | it's amazing how bad 4 really is |
StallionMang
09.21.14 | Before I jam a new band I just look at Sputnik's average rating system to see which of their albums I should get
If I really like the good albums then maybe I'll check out some of their lesser ones, otherwise I don't fuck wit em |
Deathconscious
09.21.14 | i find even what people consider to be their classic albums pretty boring. |
tempest--
09.21.14 | you'd actually be surprised at how literal arsemoriendi takes everything |
Thibs
09.21.14 | "Kill, Ride or Master"
...and justice |
DominionMM1
09.21.14 | ^two perfect records |
Artuma
09.21.14 | sputnik is a liar |
Keyblade
09.21.14 | Caring about if the ratio of good to bad albums makes a band good or bad is stupid. I'll still be jamming
the fuck out of Ride and Master for years to come regardless of how many bad albums they release |
oltnabrick
09.21.14 | Metallica son leyendas thrash metal.
Brasil le gusta metallica ! |
oltnabrick
09.21.14 | perra estúpida. promedios sputnik suelen ser correcto y si su calificación es diferente, entonces usted es probablemente un imbécil. |
Artuma
09.21.14 | "The sputnik average isn't an objective truth."
fucking lol |
deathschool
09.21.14 | perra estúpida. promedios sputnik suelen ser correcto y si su calificación es diferente, entonces usted es probablemente un imbécil.
[2?] |
Keyblade
09.21.14 | "Since when does sputnik average ratings define personal taste? The sputnik average isn't an objective truth."
Whoosh. Woulda thought someone who posts with such an obvious satirical presence™ wouldn't be baited by that |
Artuma
09.21.14 | spooky is the best user on the site |
Keyblade
09.21.14 | ^^
Not a troll, just trolling the fact that you take this type of shit way too seriously |
toomanyxsinmyname
09.21.14 | St anger is their only bad album tbh. |
wwba
09.21.14 | The sputnik average isn't an objective truth. [2]
this is true......
there are typical sputnik genres (emo, chaotic hardcore, etc) and even the shittiest bands in these genres
get higher ratings than proper trancecore bands like Asking Alexandria just because the majority of
sputnik
users like that sound better, and you don't have to be good at it, even if your band is the cheapest
Converge ripoff band ever, you'll get better average on this site than bands who were PIONEERS of a genre
(Asking Alexandria, Attack Attack) just because they weren't going for the sound that snob sputnik-kids
want to
hear |
Flugmorph
09.21.14 | metallica is arbitrary lame |
ArsMoriendi
09.21.14 | "metallica is arbitrary lame"
The word arbitrary doesn't fit into that sentence at all. What the hell. |
Gameofmetal
09.21.14 | Is there nothing we can do about users like fucking wwba? |
Lethean
09.21.14 | uh ignore him? |
Flugmorph
09.21.14 | i know it doesn't fit. weird stuff happens on the internet. deal with it ^^ |
toomanyxsinmyname
09.22.14 | wwba
That doesn't matter if the genre they made sucks. Pioneers? Maybe. But that doesn't mean they're good. |
