StallionMang
08.27.14 | off minor [2] |
Artuma
08.27.14 | [3] |
Gestapo
08.27.14 | orkid
but yea off minor [3] |
RadioSuicide
08.27.14 | [4] |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | neither are top tier screamo tbh though ppl who are cool like orchid a lot better than I do |
YakNips
08.27.14 | ugh i should've known the comments would be like this
jeromes dream is like 2nd best skramz band but orchid is 1st SOOO |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | off minor is first soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo |
YakNips
08.27.14 | ur wrong soooooooooooooo |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | pg. 99 and ampere are both better than jerome's dream tbh yak I'm sry I know you're weird about JD but whatever |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | I Hate Myself is better than both of these 2 *sunglasses* |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | I Hate Myself is better than both of these 2 *sunglasses*
maybe JD but idk about orchid. especially dance tomorrow you fuck |
YakNips
08.27.14 | havent jammed i hate myself in a loooong time and tbh pg. 99 might be better yeaaaaa but i've listened to a LOT of JD and ampere are def not better nahhh like shadows was meh but the rest of their stuff is great tho |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | I'm sorry I think I got into Orchid at the wrong time
for a lot of people they were like a formative emo band
but it's for me it's like okay I've listened to everything else might as well listen to Orchid... *okay well this is good* |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | that's just doing it backwards. but being honest there are lots of emo skramz bands i like better than orchid |
NordicMindset
08.27.14 | Is it bad I haven't heard either? |
YakNips
08.27.14 | tbh i can see that and i know some ppl that say that about Orchid and i can be an elitist idiot about 'entry-level' bands and shit but man they're p much untouchable IMHO just idk i don't rlly see any flaws in their music |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | it's not that they're obviously flawed -because obviously they're not- but orchid's music just never grabbed like saetia did initially or ten grand and moss icon and gospel and max colby and shotmaker did for a while or like off minor and pg. 99 still do |
Gwyn.
08.27.14 | never listen to emo/screamo anymore but orchid out of these two
but off minor [5] |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | agreed. i just happen to feel the same about COC pretty much.
|
Tyler.
08.27.14 | oh sea i think this is the way to rule is the best ten grand album. it's actually becoming one of my favorites in the genre rn tbh |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | I really prefer The Comprehensive List but Way To Rule is really good too nothing against that album |
Mort.
08.27.14 | yeah i listened to orchid after i listened to JFFB, Saetia, COC, Funeral Diner, Off Minor and all the others i like and i just dont really get it |
YakNips
08.27.14 | yea i feel u sea their music just really grabbed me, and continues to interest me still so idk
and JD is like 'woahh' to me they're really unlike any other band i can name just in how volatile their music and stylistically and Seeing Means More Than Safety is like the most intense skramz album ever |
YakNips
08.27.14 | it's just my opinion tho i just think Orchid's music works on like every level i can think of and is like perfectly executed |
Skoj
08.27.14 | Pg.99, Saetia > Off Minor, Orchid > everything else. It's a simple yes or no question. |
YakNips
08.27.14 | saetia is really great but also overrated
same with off minor imo |
SeaAnemone
08.27.14 | context is important. off minor (relative to music as a whole) > off minor (relative to other skramz bands, only) |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | saetia is overrated yeah
|
MalleusMaleficarum
08.27.14 | derp.jpg |
Gestapo
08.27.14 | emo is whiny |
YakNips
08.27.14 | emo is whinny |
akimbo
08.27.14 | off minor is underrated if anything
but orchid > jd |
Tyler.
08.27.14 | off minor is underrated if anything
|
YakNips
08.27.14 | not on here lol |
Gestapo
08.27.14 | never heard of any of these bands am i missing out |
Trebor.
08.27.14 | Orchid is my fave |
YakNips
08.27.14 | tbh yea i saw this list and thought ppl would either say neither or orchid lol
jeromes dream are criminally underrated here |
Supercoolguy64
08.27.14 | ONE THOUSAND BIRDS |
YakNips
08.27.14 | maybe best orchid song nice |
StallionMang
08.27.14 | Overall Orchid is the better band in terms of technical ability and consistently putting out classic albums, but I slightly prefer JD's sound and style, plus SMMTS is my favorite skramz album of all time
If I had to choose I'd probably go with Orchid |
YakNips
08.27.14 | yea SMMTS is my fave album of all time and it sucks that in my review i only described what made it good i didn't really touch on what made it the HOLY SHIT BEST ALBUM EVER which i could totally do now.
and yea JD have a more unique sound but Orchid are better overall and more consistent |
Skoj
09.02.14 | Probably orchid. |
Sniff
09.02.14 | Orchid > Off Minor > Skramz > JD |