betray
04.10.14 | yeah |
RTCW
04.10.14 | A for effort |
manosg
04.10.14 | Agreed on 1 and 4 only but it's all good. Nice descriptions too. The Call of Ktulu is awesome though. |
Nocturnal
04.10.14 | 5 ahead of 6 is downright shocking to me and I would switch 3 and 4 but nice list either way. |
betray
04.10.14 | Cool man. Thanks.
I just can't wrap my dick around that song no matter how hard I try. |
Necrotica
04.10.14 | "But WTF is Escape? The Call of Ktulu? Fight Fire with Fire? Ew."
The gloves are off now bitch |
betray
04.10.14 | Welp, I did say to fight me about it.
THERE'S A REASON THEY NEVER PLAY THEM LIVE |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.10.14 | Yeah because they play most of Reload live all the time |
betray
04.10.14 | I didn't say they did, guy! |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.10.14 | Saying that a song sucks because they don't play it live is stupid,this is my point. |
PillowGuy
04.10.14 | Guess I'm the only one who likes Fight Fire with Fire. |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.10.14 | No you are not,it's a great song |
Tremz
04.10.14 | 5 above 6
good night |
betray
04.10.14 | Hold the phone.
Almost none of Metallica's songs "SUCK". Okay? I was more going for "they don't play it live because
nobody really likes it" When you're Metallica and your setlist can be any combination of THIS
http://www.metallicabyrequest.com/results.php?s=71
The Call of Ktulu, Escape, and Fight Fire with Fire probably aren't going to make the cut. |
tempest--
04.10.14 | lol wtf |
betray
04.10.14 | don't you acronym me, mister. |
Judio!
04.10.14 | Nope nope nope |
tempest--
04.10.14 | i mean this shitty terrible ranking is kind of expected from a shitty terrible user with shitty terrible taste |
betray
04.10.14 | I love how excited your posts look in "my discussions" |
sapient
04.10.14 | I mean, I completely disagree with this ranking, but at least you explain your choices
4 is my 1, but definitely dukes it out with MoP for that spot |
mandan
04.10.14 | 3 is my 1.
Overall I disagree with the ranking, but as already mentioned, at least you explain things.
I certainly wouldn't put 2 that high or 6 that low. |
BigSneakySnatch
04.10.14 | damn dude 6 is 1 |
sapient
04.10.14 | 2 probably shouldn't be that high, but going back to it recently I also think people give it way more criticism than it deserves.
It's one of the better and one of the heaviest pop metal records to be released in its era, and has some of Hetfield's best
groove-type riffs (can you say Sad But True?) |
mandan
04.10.14 | 2's been getting more love than flak lately, so idk. |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.10.14 | It's a good album but it definetely can't top the first four |
TalonsOfFire
04.10.14 | These descriptions are funny |
betray
04.10.14 | thanks man |
Wadlez
04.10.14 | damn good work sonny |
betray
04.10.14 | rly |
Grindalicious
04.10.14 | you have black album as 2 because it got you into emmure? do not compute |
betray
04.10.14 | That part wasn't serious. Just trying to overstate the fact that the Black Album opened me up to metal. And if it weren't for the Black Album I wouldn't be into any of the other metal subgenres I'm into today. (emmure being a joke) |
Emim
04.10.14 | " If it wasn't for the Black Album, I would have never found Emmure, The Acacia Strain, Bring Me The Horizon, and all of the other shittier, completely different stuff I love today."
Well at least we know what to blame. |
betray
04.10.14 | That part wasn't serious. Just trying to overstate the fact that the Black Album opened me up to metal. And if it weren't for the Black Album I wouldn't be into any of the other metal subgenres I'm into today. (emmure being a joke) |
mandan
04.10.14 | Also nice to see KEA in the top 3, that pleases me. |
SpiritCrusher2
04.10.14 | hahahahaha you just said "ew" to Fight Fire With Fire and Call of Ktulu |
Emim
04.10.14 | "This album's not even that bad. Some song are unnecessarily long. This album to me is comparable to Pantera's 'The Great Southern Trendkill'."
Also, HA |
betray
04.10.14 | Yeah. I'll say it again. Ew. Songs are weak.
St. Anger's NOT even that bad. Some of the songs*** ARE unnecessarily long. (Unnamed, Monster, Shoot Me Again all over 7 minutes) And it's comparable to Pantera's TGST because of the circumstances in which the album was recorded under. |
climactic
04.10.14 | 1 is 1, rest of this ranking is ???? |
FearTomorrow
04.10.14 | this is so fucked lol
Reload is worst, then St Anger, Death Magnetic, Load... then the top 5 (great albums, IE RTL, MOP, KEA, AJFA and s/t)
oh and having RTL where it is is just no |
Emim
04.10.14 | ^^^ |
betray
04.10.14 | In your opinion(s). |
FearTomorrow
04.10.14 | IMO this is literally the worst way you can rank Metallica. well, almost. |
facupm
04.10.14 | reload's place on the list automatically makes it the worst list ever
also if you dont like fight fire with fire or ktulu youre a) gay b) gay |
SatanicPeanuts
04.10.14 | 'I would have never found Emmure, The Acacia Strain, Bring Me The Horizon, and all of the other shittier, completely different stuff I love today.'
Holy fuck. Please Kill Me Now |
Muisc4Life26
04.10.14 | Ride the Lighting
Master of Puppets
Kill em all
And Justice For All
Black
Load
Death Magnetic
Reload
St. Anger
|
NordicMindset
04.10.14 | Ride the Lighting
Master of Puppets
Kill Em All
And Justice For All
The Black Album
Death Magnetic
Load
Reload
St. Anger |
betray
04.11.14 | Satanic, really?
I explained that comment TWICE in the comments, and called it SHITTY right in the damn explanation. If you didn't catch that I might not have been 100% serious you've got some work to do. |
betray
04.11.14 | Getting lots of flak for 6 being 6. I really just don't see the appeal other than it being a transition from Killems sound to Puppets' sound. The Bell, Creeping, and Trapped are all classic tracks, but even those are dragged down by Hetfields' voice. |
NordicMindset
04.11.14 | Ktulu is a masterpiece.
Have you heard the riffs |
Emim
04.11.14 | "Getting lots of flak for 6 being 6. I really just don't see the appeal other than it being a transition from Killems sound to Puppets' sound. The Bell, Creeping, and Trapped are all classic tracks, but even those are dragged down by Hetfields' voice. "
Well seeing as how you ranked MoP and KEM at 1 and 3, respectively, logic follows that an album that bridges their two sounds should rank rather highly as well. |
Thibs
04.11.14 | I wholeheartedly disagree with this ranking.
Good day. |
InFlamesWeThrash666
04.11.14 | 1) Master 2)Kill 3)Ride 4)Justice 5)Black 6)Magnetic 7)Load 8)St Anger 9) Reload |
Thibs
04.11.14 | Justice
Master
Ride
Kill
Black
Wtv |
scottpilgrim10
04.11.14 | 2 is really average and boring.
Cool List, even though I disagree with everything. |
js2014
04.11.14 | Ride the Lightning's definitely gotta be higher |
betray
04.11.14 | Boring is not a word I would use to describe the Black Album.
And I'm just not the biggest fan of RtL. I just simply enjoy listening to the others rated above it so much more; even Reload. |
betray
04.11.14 | *still an amazing album however* |
TheNotrap
04.11.14 | Creeping Death alone is better than ReLoad and all music that came after.
|
mandan
04.11.14 | ^this so hard, m/ |
EvoHavok
04.11.14 | Pretty much anything off RtL is better than ReLoad and later. |
Kusangii
04.11.14 | To have RTL at #6 is pretty much a mockery |
facupm
04.11.14 | "The Call of Ktulu? Fight Fire with Fire? Ew. No thanks"
confirmed worst taste ever |
betray
04.11.14 | I had a feeling sputnik users would cling to those widely considered bad songs like they were the band's greatest material written. I fucking knew it lol. It's just how this website is.
The worst songs are the best
the first album is the best
the more obscure the better the music |
NordicMindset
04.11.14 | "the first album is the best"
ikr I love Pablo Honey's 4.6 avg |
Faraudo
04.12.14 | Oh no, Reload is better than Ride The Lightning? Emmure is mentioned? We're in for a fucking treat, sputs. |
betray
04.12.14 | AWWW SHIT! Faraudo crackin' the fuckin' case up in this bitch! You GOT me man. Totally figured that shit out.
You're about 70 comments late.
Reload is better than Ride The Lightning.
The Emmure part was a joke. Holy shit, people. |
Emim
04.12.14 | Well I'd say we have a pretty decent consensus here; your taste in Metallica sucks.
"The worst songs are the best
the first album is the best
the more obscure the better the music"
Well.......no one has argued any of those points because RtL is not their first album, is in no way obscure, and doesn't contain their worst songs.
Damn man, at least be logically dumb. |
JM18
04.12.14 | Lol @ the users that call other users and their taste shitty because they don't share the same opinion on a band. Get the fuck over yourselves
Anyways, nice list although i disagree in some spots. Lightning at 6? Come on maing. Nice to see Black getting more love though. |
facupm
04.12.14 | at least be logically dumb [2] |
Faraudo
04.12.14 | Well, I wouldn't be able to catch sarcasm on a list that seems entirely sarcastic because of how much it sucks. |
ultimatethrasher
04.12.14 | 6 is my 1 |
ultimatethrasher
04.12.14 | The black album at 2? Dude the first 4 destroys that album |
betray
04.14.14 | Lol @ the users that call other users and their taste shitty because they don't share the same opinion on a band. Get the fuck over yourselves [2] |
mandan
04.14.14 | That's the way Sput works dude. |
betray
04.14.14 | Trust me, I'm quite aware of this by now
just thought that summed up this thread quite nicely |
Emim
04.14.14 | You absolutely brought it upon yourself. |
betray
04.14.14 | "brought it upon yourself"
I brought other user's elitism upon myself?
ok |
Insurrection
04.14.14 | shit ranking. RtL is 1, reload is 9 |
BIGDIX
04.14.14 | oh my jollies am i tired of hearing about these goons god they suck LOLOL I LIKE METALLICA IM SO HARD YEAH fucking shutup already |
cryptside
04.14.14 | Nice descriptions to go with the list, man. I dig it, although the only two that I've taken a proper listen to is MOP and Kill Em All. Obviously people think that their logic>your logic, but that's to be expected. There isn't an objective way to look at music, no matter how many butthurt people seem to think otherwise. |
Insurrection
04.14.14 | "But WTF is Escape? The Call of Ktulu? Fight Fire with Fire? Ew. No thanks."
jesus |
cryptside
04.14.14 | I just take this stuff at face value. Some people are articulate enough to voice why they like certain albums better than others and other people aren't, but I don't have time nor do I care enough to flame someone for having different opinions than me. |
betray
04.14.14 | "LOLOL I LIKE METALLICA IM SO HARD YEAH"
yeah I don't know anyone who actually thinks they're hard for liking metallica
or any music for that matter |
chemicalmarriage
04.15.14 | "I just take this stuff at face value. Some people are articulate enough to voice why they like certain albums better than others and other people aren't, but I don't have time nor do I care enough to flame someone for having different opinions than me."
Holy shit, probably one of the best things I've ever read on Sputnik. Thank you sir |
cryptside
04.16.14 | Haha no problem chemical. Sometimes it's hard not to get caught up in slinging crap when discussing music, but I go to Sput to learn about bands I never would have heard of otherwise. |
macman76
09.30.16 | bump |
Muisc4Life26
09.30.16 | RTL at 6??? lol |