musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | I literally mean it, you decide. I'm not voting on this thread, it's just too hard for me, 4 albums on this list are 5's for me and the other might just become one some day. |
Funeralopolis
01.05.14 | still life |
JamieTwort
01.05.14 | My Arms, Your Hearse
and it's not even remotely close for me. |
JamieTwort
01.05.14 | at least not between these 5. |
Judio!
01.05.14 | Still Life |
DeathGrinder
01.05.14 | Still Life. |
Betacra
01.05.14 | Still Life, just. |
CalculatingInfinity
01.05.14 | BWP. |
Artuma
01.05.14 | still. fucking. life. |
Keyblade
01.05.14 | Where the hell's Morningrise?
Out of these tho, BWP |
musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | DAMN, Still Life is destroying everything!
MAYH 1, Still Life 5, BWP 2, Damnation and Ghost Reveries 0.
Morningrise is an amazing record, but I couldn't feature every Opeth album. 5 is enough, so I featured the 5 highest rated Opeth records on the site, although Morningrise is as good as Reveries for me. I guess. |
NordicMindset
01.05.14 | BWP |
conesmoke
01.05.14 | throw morningrise in between bwp & damnation and i'd be feeling this. |
Keyblade
01.05.14 | Replace the last 2 with Morningrise and Orchid and it would be a nice battle |
musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | Okay, counting votes for Morningrise as well, truly a deservant album.
It's 2 for BWP anyway (greenlinkinmuse voted BWP) and 1 for Morningrise. Cone, is your vote for Morningrise too? |
DominionMM1
01.05.14 | still life |
musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | Still Life is 6 now, damn, it truly is destroying stuff around here. |
SpiritCrusher2
01.05.14 | BWP |
CK
01.05.14 | Still Life |
charbyno
01.05.14 | BWP |
ExcentrifugalForz
01.05.14 | morningrise is the only one i have so it gets my vote |
sputnik1
01.05.14 | Still Life |
Solaire
01.05.14 | Morningrise |
Surtur
01.05.14 | Still Life, then MAYH for me |
evilford
01.05.14 | Mayh |
thumbcrusher
01.05.14 | MAYH |
BigPleb
01.05.14 | MAYH |
Solaire
01.05.14 | On Sputnik you will hear MAYH or Still Life for the most part. |
PortraitsOfDecay
01.05.14 | still life |
demigod!
01.05.14 | Morningrise |
Underflow
01.05.14 | Still Life |
MoosechriS
01.05.14 | ............. can't decide |
demigod!
01.05.14 | morningrise dude, its so blackened and eerie |
MoosechriS
01.05.14 | i have morningrise on vinyl, gonna play that shit now! |
musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | Morningrise - 4
MAYH - 4
Still Life - 11
BWP - 4
Damnation - 0 (pretty surprising)
Ghost Reveries - 1 |
demigod!
01.05.14 | Jelly dude!
and damnation would be my second choice |
undertakerpt
01.05.14 | Don't see what everyone sees in still life, apart from the awesome intro.
Damnation! |
JamieTwort
01.05.14 | Damnation is the most boring album ever! (I'm exaggerating but still it's pretty boring.) |
JokineAugustus
01.05.14 | Still life then Ghost reveries |
PunchforPunch
01.05.14 | Still Lyfe |
undertakerpt
01.05.14 | I've only heard the middle 3 on this list, and I'd say still life is the worst of them |
undertakerpt
01.05.14 | I changed my mind, bwp over damnation, but storm corrosion is prob the best thing akerfeldt put his name on |
DANcore
01.05.14 | Still life |
ValarMorghulis
01.05.14 | Blackwater Park |
musicalmedicine
01.05.14 | Morningrise 4, MAYH 4, Still Life 14, BWP 6, Reveries 1. Fuck, SL is wrecking every other Opeth record down. |
MO
01.06.14 | Mayh consider this the tie breaker album wins all |
Necrotica
01.06.14 | Watershed |
SpiritCrusher2
01.06.14 | Still Life deserves this, album is just constant perfection. although I've already voted for BWP, which has always been my personal fav :] they're both 5s imo |
JaySpiral
01.06.14 | Ghost Reveries
Don't understand why everyone loves Still Life so much. It's probably like my fourth or fifth favorite Opeth album. |
SpiritCrusher2
01.06.14 | I consider Still Life to be the biggest grower of all of their albums, so maybe you should just give it more time idk |
Tyrael
01.06.14 | Morningrise |
Betacra
01.06.14 | If I had to rank my Opeth albums they'd probably be:
Still Life
My Arms, Your Hearse
Blackwater Park
Ghost Reveries
I don't listen to the rest half as much any more but to be honest I'd probably end up sticking Orchid there in fifth spot, because it's a seriously under appreciated album.
Don't add these as votes I already voted, but we all know Still Life has won anyway! |
musicalmedicine
01.06.14 | FiveLeaves, wassup?
For me BWP, Still Life and MAYH are 5's. Morningrise 5, MAYH 5, Still Life 14, BWP 6, Reveries 2. Still Life is way on the
lead. I still can't vote tbh, so tight between 1, 2 and 3. Damnation grew a little off me (I mean, Death Whispered A Lullaby
and Ending Credits did, rest is still perfect. Oh, Windowpane/In My Time Of Need) |
SIMBOLIC
01.06.14 | still life yeah!!! |
CK
01.06.14 | Fuck yeah m/ |
tempest--
01.06.14 | bwp |
tommygun
01.06.14 | mayh |
Ending
01.06.14 | Still Life no doubt. It's their most coherent by far. |
MyNameIsPencil
01.08.14 | Suicide Season |
ButteryBiscuitBass
01.08.14 | mayh |
SIMBOLIC
01.08.14 | Still life |
NightProwler
01.08.14 | BWP = MAYH, can't decide. |
musicalmedicine
01.09.14 | Morningrise 5, MAYH 7, Still Life 17, BWP 8, Ghost Reveries 2. |
MeatSalad
01.09.14 | Mayh |
Avagantamos
01.10.14 | deliverance, but out of these my pick is bwp |
JamieTwort
01.10.14 | lol |
musicalmedicine
01.10.14 | Morningrise 5, MAYH 8, Still Life 18 (I'm voting for it, truly the best Opeth record), BWP 9 (although this has the most badass album cover), Ghost Reveries 2. |
JamieTwort
01.10.14 | MAYH is truly the best Opeth record. |
MeatSalad
01.10.14 | Still life is truly the most overrated opeth record. |
Necrotica
01.10.14 | ^ Indeed |
Necrotica
01.10.14 | Along with Damnation and Deliverance imo, but at least Deliverance actually does have a more mixed reception |
MeatSalad
01.10.14 | Yeah deliverance should have a lower average |
musicalmedicine
01.10.14 | ^ I second this, Deliverance is painfully boring at times, but Master's Apprendices and By The Pain I
See In Others slay the shit out of most metal bands today. Wreath and t/t are so freaking boring
though. A Fair Judgement is quite great but it really drags in the end. |
JamieTwort
01.10.14 | A Fair Judgement is the only song I really like on Deliverance. By The Pain is one of the worst and certainly doesn't slay the shit out of most modern metal. |
Avagantamos
01.11.14 | title track of deliverance is top 5 opeth imo |
musicalmedicine
01.11.14 | I love By The Pain, one of the first Opeth songs I've ever heard and I still play it some times. Of course, it's not top 20, not even top 25 Opeth, but I like it. Title track is a bit meh for me, I don't know, it just drags so much for me tbh. |
ShitsofRain
01.11.14 | 3> |
Myrkur
01.11.14 | Can't really decide between Still Life and Blackwater Park, both are classics |
L4titudes
01.28.14 | I will never understand how people dislike Deliverance.. I think that album is just as good as Ghost Reveries.. anyways my vote goes to MAYH if that counts for anything. I also agree that Still Life is over rated.
|
Inveigh
01.28.14 | I might argue that Deliverance is better than Ghost Reveries. Everything after Blackwater Park is of much less importance than the first 5 records though. |
JamieTwort
01.28.14 | Deliverance is easily their worst imo. Ghost Reveries is actually really good and miles better than Deliverance. |