Muisc4Life26
09.06.13 | Animals
Wish You Were Here
The Wall
Meddle
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn |
Rowan5215
09.06.13 | Wish You Were Here
Animals
Dark Side
Obscured by Clouds
The Division Bell |
StallionMang
09.06.13 | Replace 4 with Piper and that's my list. |
Aids
09.06.13 | edgy picks |
DrHouseSchuldiner
09.06.13 | The Dark Side Of The Moon
Wish You Were Here
Animals
Meddle
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn |
YoYoMancuso
09.06.13 | Wish You Were Here
the other ones |
tlhk
09.06.13 | thank you so much for this |
Riviere
09.06.13 | "Replace 4 with Piper and that's my list."
Gtfo, Gilmour > Barrett all day
jk, but seriously, The Wall is greatness. |
JamieTwort
09.06.13 | Piper > The Wall, agreed. |
Rowan5215
09.06.13 | Most Floyd > The Wall. |
tommygun
09.06.13 | wywh animals piper meddle and
um
i spose dark side |
Speed512
09.06.13 | wywh should be 1 |
tommygun
09.06.13 | but yeah madcap laughs > dark side |
Rowan5215
09.06.13 | On an Island > Madcap Laughs bro |
tommygun
09.06.13 | nah |
Rowan5215
09.06.13 | yah |
ButteryBiscuitBass
09.06.13 | KC & The Sunshine Band > |
NeroCorleone80
09.06.13 | Animals
Wish You Were Here
Meddle
The Dark Side of the Moon
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn |
MAGNIFICENT
09.06.13 | Enjoying the diversity of your Floyd top 5's! Seeing some Piper, some Division Bell and some OBC!
And @thlk, you're welcome ; ) |
JamieTwort
09.06.13 | My top 5 is pretty much exactly the same as Nero's.
Although sometimes I think I prefer The Final Cut to Piper. |
BigPleb
09.06.13 | Needs more Piper.
The Wall is low tier Floyd imo. |
DominionMM1
09.06.13 | saucerful > piper and the wall |
linkinmuse
09.06.13 | Wish You Were Here
The Dark Side of the Moon
Animals
The Wall
The Division Bell |
DominionMM1
09.06.13 | "The Division Bell"
lol |
MAGNIFICENT
09.06.13 | What Dominion? He can't have an opinion?
Lebowski, I see where you come from, but The Wall belongs to any top 5 Floyd in my opinion. It's a cohesive record with an amazing concept and there isn't one song I don't like. And just like a story's listener has to be patient, one who listens to The Wall has to be patient. It's a musical journey. |
guitarded_chuck
09.06.13 | http://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?listid=129968&memberid=71831 |
JamieTwort
09.06.13 | The Wall is far from cohesive imo. It has some outstanding moments though. |
MAGNIFICENT
09.06.13 | Jamie, and then again, opinions. It feels great to me if I approach it thinking I'll have a long
journey ahead of me. I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it
instead of complaining about it
A little torn up between The Wall and Meddle though, both amazing records. |
JokineAugustus
09.06.13 | Here's where you laugh
Animals
Piper
WYWH
Obscured
Dark Side |
MAGNIFICENT
09.06.13 | It's a pretty original list, Augustus, although I'm not that much of a Piper fan. |
MAGNIFICENT
09.06.13 | Yeah, choosing Meddle over The Wall. Echoes ftw. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | "I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it instead of complaining about it"
I could never make an album like The Wall and I can quite happily admit that but that doesn't mean I can't still give my opinion on the album based on the level of enjoyment I get from it. |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | ^^^ Exactly. |
MAGNIFICENT
09.07.13 | Jamie, yes, I agree, but you didn't get what I wanted to say with that statement, There are people who say The Wall "sucks", that it is "a bad album", and that's the thing I just don't get, y'know? Of course I couldn't make a Justin Bieber album since I don't have his girly voice but I'm free to express my opinion about it. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | Fair enough. I certainly don't hate The Wall, I just think it's flawed and somewhat overrated and that Floyd have a lot of better albums. |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | He just said he didn't hate it dude, and he's right that they've done waaaaaaaaay better. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | @Decaying: I'm on about my opinion of The Wall. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | Along with like 5 of their other albums yea. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | It's good but not amazing. |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | Some songs on there are quite amazing, others suck hard. |
JamieTwort
09.07.13 | Agreed Rowan. |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | "But the wall and all its progness"
Cos you know no other Floyd has "progness" at all, right? |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | I was adding a joke to your joke bro |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | This thread. |
Rowan5215
09.07.13 | Haha I see you've learned Sput traditions well, not right now man. |
guitarded_chuck
09.07.13 | "I'd like to see everyone criticizing The Wall making an album better than it instead of complaining about it"
lolol |
Minus.
09.07.13 | We definitely needed another Floyd list |
Artuma
09.07.13 | the wall is a 5, fight me |
FuncrusherPlus1
09.08.13 | I've only heard three so far, i'd go.
The Wall
Wish You Were Here
The Dark Side Of The Moon |