laughingman22
08.23.13 | I still think 6 is much better than 5, but whatever, good ranking
|
kingsoby1
08.23.13 | nice list have a feature |
chemicalmarriage
08.23.13 | wow |
JamieTwort
08.23.13 | The Final Cut is far too low (again). |
MosesMalone
08.23.13 | They must really be hurting for features right now. |
kingsoby1
08.23.13 | yeah i dont think weve changed for a while |
Rowan5215
08.23.13 | The Final Cut is far too low (again). [2] |
RogueNine
08.23.13 | Second list is a feature; must be some kind of record. |
Mad.
08.23.13 | THANK YOU, finally someone sees that 1 is 1.
Odd thing to feature, but ranking [i]is[/i] correct. |
ILJ
08.23.13 | this needed a feature
/sarcasm |
someguest
08.23.13 | "I've been on Sputnik ten years and the only discography I got through was Pink Floyd." |
evilford
08.23.13 | The Final Cut is far too low (again). [9]
|
avonbarksdale221
08.24.13 | I'd have The Wall above Piper. Other than that, good ranking. |
OmairSh
08.24.13 | Damn 10 doesn't get enough love |
avonbarksdale221
08.24.13 | @CSR
They might be skippable when left on their own, but when played in the context of the album, each individual song works pretty much perfectly. The only thing I'd change is maybe shaving some time off On The Run. |
Gwyn.
08.24.13 | why is this featured |
sleepdirt
08.24.13 | Was a control used in verifying this? |
tommygun
08.24.13 | wrong |
sblevins95
08.24.13 | I really like San Tropez, Seamus is the only shit song on Meddle |
sideburndude
08.24.13 | When the guitar enters with those four notes in Shine on You Crazy Diamond makes WYWH my #1 |
Aids
08.24.13 | Why are there people itt acting like The Final Cut isn't terrible? |
evilford
08.24.13 | Because it actually rules duh |
evilford
08.24.13 | Also, just saw this
"kingsoby1
08.23.13
[Report this Post] nice list have a feature"
Fucking hope to satan for the sake of humanity this is the biggest joke feature ever
|
Aids
08.24.13 | wow dude chill out. why are people losing sleep over featured lists on sputnik?
and no dude Final Cut is their only bad album
*ahem* in my opinion |
tommygun
08.24.13 | it's better than the wall :] |
SIMBOLIC
08.24.13 | |
Aids
08.24.13 | I just died a little bit. |
JamieTwort
08.24.13 | "and no dude Final Cut is their only bad album"
hahaha, it's not even close to being one of their worst.
"thats usually how I listen to music, shuffling songs"
Really? I imagine you're missing out on a lot of albums that work best as a whole. I personally never shuffle songs, I'm much more of an album person. |
manosg
08.24.13 | Yeah, The Final Cut is top 6 probably. And how can you fully appreciate a work of art if you listen it in shuffle? |
SIMBOLIC
08.24.13 | agreed albums or go home |
Aids
08.24.13 | uhhhhh what the fuck? I definitely did not think I was alone in that opinion but whatever. yall are crazy.
top 6 lolllll I feel like I'm on crazy pills |
JamieTwort
08.24.13 | I can understand to an extent why some people might not like The Final Cut if they haven't managed to connect with it
emotionally, as it's the lyrics and the emotion behind the concept that makes the album so powerful. Musically it could be
seen as a slight step down from previous Floyd albums (despite having some of Gilmour's very best solos) but what it lacks in
that department it more than makes up for in emotion and atmosphere. |
Rowan5215
08.24.13 | ^^^ |
Artuma
08.24.13 | wrong again |
SitarHero
08.24.13 | Why is this bullshit featured? |
MeatSalad
08.24.13 | scientists and shit |
SitarHero
08.24.13 | This is the same clown who said that no Pink Floyd = no Rush |
geasoftime
08.24.13 | The Final Cut is good, but it's placed pretty appropriately on this list. I would switch some of those above it around, and put Final Cut at 8 followed by Obscured By Clouds. It's Pink Floyd's last 4 album on the list, everything below it is 3.5 (and maybe less in Momentary's case) material. |
JamieTwort
08.24.13 | The Final Cut is a high 4 for me while The Wall is a low-ish 3.5. |
Rowan5215
08.24.13 | The Final Cut is a high 4 for me while The Wall is a low-ish 3.5. [2]
I AM JUST A NEW BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOI |
Hoppoman
08.24.13 | Scientifically incorrect. |
Minus.
08.24.13 | This is a good ranking, but naturally I like mine better. |
guitarded_chuck
08.24.13 | "I've been on Sputnik ten years and the only discography I got through was Pink Floyd."
lol |
guitarded_chuck
08.24.13 | Thanks for the feature soby.
So much hate, my goodness, everybody calm down, love you all
"Fucking hope to satan for the sake of humanity this is the biggest joke feature ever"
ARE YOU FO REAL wow |
amemento
08.24.13 | stfu not u gutarded but people except jamie and aids stfu |
tommygun
08.24.13 | hey |
Rowan5215
08.24.13 | you |
SitarHero
08.24.13 | Soby for emeritus '13 |
guitarded_chuck
08.24.13 | ^he mad |
evilford
08.24.13 | people taking me too seriously itt
Also agreed with everything good anyone said itt abt the final cut and being better than the wall etc etc itt etc itt it'd eg it ieyxt |
evilford
08.24.13 | "thats usually how I listen to music, shuffling songs"
Wait lol who said this |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
08.24.13 | i liked the final cut b4 it was cool |
evilford
08.24.13 | KILL still likes the wall more so it's not officially cool yet |
mryrtmrnfoxxxy
08.24.13 | fuk |
sonictheplumber
08.24.13 | meddle is 1 |
DrGoatandTheWagons
08.24.13 | 1 is 1 |
chemicalmarriage
08.24.13 | reported |
JokineAugustus
08.24.13 | Walter White would be pleased |
BigRedSofa
08.24.13 | I am very pleased |
someguest
08.24.13 | glad I made you laff chuckles |
Scoot
08.24.13 | 2 is best |
JokineAugustus
08.24.13 | Hemispheres is best yes. |
jefflebowski
08.24.13 | isn't obscured by clouds a soundtrack too? |
Rowan5215
08.25.13 | Technically yeah but it's way more of a complete and full album than More was. |
MrSirLordGentleman
08.25.13 | 12 needs more love |
Greem
08.25.13 | Science fiction :D |
Greem
08.25.13 | Scientifically verified that The Wall is №1 forever. You've got wrong information |
Greem
08.25.13 | no way 8 above 9 |
beefshoes
08.25.13 | Pretty accurate but I'd switch The Wall with The Final Cut. |
treeqt.
08.25.13 | http://i.imgur.com/XpRPTUo.png |
CK
08.26.13 | Best ranking of the band yet |
TheSpaceMan
08.26.13 | Dark Side > WYWH > Meddle = Animals > The Wall
my top 5 that changes all the time because its so hard to pick from those masterpieces |
CK
08.26.13 | Switch your WYWH with Meddle=Animals and you're golden on my top 5 |
Gyromania
08.28.13 | so, so horribly wrong. the wall is way better than wish you were here or dark side |
JamieTwort
08.28.13 | ^ You're kidding right? |
Gyromania
08.29.13 | not even a little. dark side of the moon is so ridiculously overrated. the wall is their most creative and important imo. animals is right there next to it though |
walnuts
08.29.13 | 1 is too high, and 6 is too low |
JamieTwort
08.29.13 | ^Wow. 5 is easily better than 6 imo, it's not even remotely close. And Echoes is a million times better than San Tropez. |
TheSpaceMan
08.29.13 | some of these opinions are questionable |
guitarded_chuck
08.29.13 | I can see how different tastes might rate The Wall slightly higher than PATGOD, but either way it isn't "absurddddddededdd" |
LocustGrove
08.29.13 | Stop bumping this dumb ass list |
guitarded_chuck
08.29.13 | bump |
guitarded_chuck
08.29.13 | oh wait it's featured doesn't need a bump my bad |
LocustGrove
08.29.13 | Like being featured really means anything |
guitarded_chuck
08.29.13 | means u mad |
guitarded_chuck
08.29.13 | #bestlistever ;) |
omnipanzer
08.29.13 | 14 should be 9
7 and 8 are arguably better. |
CrimsonFloyd
08.30.13 | Meddle is the best for me, echoes is their best song and I agree Fearless Ned's more jams. I can digest San Tropez and Seamus as part of the great experience. |