|
User
Reviews 28
Approval 85%
Soundoffs 78
News Articles 17
Band Edits + Tags 15
Album Edits 20
Album Ratings 1158
Objectivity 86%
Last Active 08-27-14 4:59 am
Joined 10-26-08
Review Comments 2,184
| Dream Theater Ranked
Can't wait for their new album!rLittle explanations with my favorite songs from each. | | 1 |  | Dream Theater
Metropolis Pt. 2: Scenes from a Memory
Despite the end of the album lacking a bit of energy and Beyond This Life being too long and crazy fore its own good, this album is incredible. The Spirit Carries On is also my favorite song from them, so that helps. (Spirit Carries On, Ouverture 1928, Fatal Tragedy.) | | 2 |  | Dream Theater
Six Degrees of Inner Turbulence
Extremely consistent and a good mix of short and long tracks. A lot of my favorite songs from them here (The Glass Prison, The Great Debate, War Inside My Head, About To Crash). | | 3 |  | Dream Theater
Awake
A really dark record that is extremely underrated. James Labrie's gritty vocals are well done too. (Innocence Faded, Erotomania, Scarred). | | 4 |  | Dream Theater
Train of Thought
Some of my favorite moments in their whole discography. Some songs are too long though. (Endless Sacrifice, In The Name of God). | | 5 |  | Dream Theater
A Dramatic Turn of Events
Best album since Train of Thought. Portnoy's departure was positive in the end. (On The Backs of Angels, Breaking All Illusions, Beneath The Surface). | | 6 |  | Dream Theater
Images and Words
Used to be one of my favorites but it has grown off me. Can't really put my finger on why. Still a superb album though. (Take The Time, Learning To Live). | | 7 |  | Dream Theater
Black Clouds & Silver Linings
Overpowering production and some songs could have been way shorter. However, no bad song in this one. (A Nightmare To Remember, Count of Tuscany). | | 8 |  | Dream Theater
Octavarium
Some good songs but it doesn't feel like an album. Every song is so different from the other ones. (Sacrificed Sons, Panic Attack). | | 9 |  | Dream Theater
Falling Into Infinity
Some great songs hidden in this overall cheesy and boring album. (Peruvian Skies, Lines In The Sand) | | 10 |  | Dream Theater
Systematic Chaos
Stupid lyrics and weird decisions in the songwriting department. (In The Presence of Enemies part 1 and 2) | | 11 |  | Dream Theater
When Dream and Day Unite
Rough around the edges and with a singer that didn't fit at all. (Ytse Jam, Only a Matter of Time) | |
JamieTwort
07.31.13 | Weird ranking. 5 is pretty average imo, 4 is way too high too. | peartnoy
07.31.13 | what would be yours? | TheNexus100
07.31.13 | "Stupid lyrics and weird decisions in the songwriting department"
thats every dt album | JamieTwort
07.31.13 | 1, 6, 3, 9, 2, 7, 4, 8, 11, 10 | peartnoy
07.31.13 | Falling Into Infinity in fourth place? Interesting. Why is that? | manosg
07.31.13 | Interesting ranking. 2 too high and 6 too low. For me it goes 3,1,6,9,4,2,7,5,11,8,10 | JamieTwort
07.31.13 | @peartnoy: I think it's really underrated. I like the fact that they toned down the wank and overall I find it more interesting than
most of their post-Scenes albums. | TheNexus100
07.31.13 | falling into infinity is barely a 2 | JamieTwort
07.31.13 | Oh, I see. | Artuma
07.31.13 | interesting list, not that bad though. i'd have 4 and 5 a lot lower and 6 a lot higher but decent ranking | peartnoy
07.31.13 | There is some good stuff on it but some songs are just awful. For me it's a 3/5 | peartnoy
07.31.13 | @Artuma
Yeah I knew 6 would be higher on almost everyone's list. I don't rank bands where everyone will agree. It's boring. | JamieTwort
07.31.13 | "There is some good stuff on it but some songs are just awful. For me it's a 3/5"
Well it's only a (high) 3.5 for me so not that much difference in our ratings. Actually on second thought I might rank Six Degrees slightly higher than it but I'm not sure, I tend to listen to FII more. | Keyblade
07.31.13 | Am I the only person who thinks 3 is 1? damn | peartnoy
07.31.13 | No manosg just said the same thing! | JohnnyoftheWell
07.31.13 | 3 is 1
So no, you're not
2 is too high, 8 is too low | Keyblade
07.31.13 | manosg and i have very similar tastes so not surprising :D | MO
07.31.13 | 2 and 6 are their best | peartnoy
07.31.13 | I understand how Awake could be number 1. Don't get me wrong I like from 1 to 7 almost on the same level. | JamieTwort
07.31.13 | 1, 3 and 6 are all pretty close for me and far ahead of everything else they ever did imo. I can understand any one of those three being someone's favourite. | Rsetness9
07.31.13 | I'm glad your honest about your taste. | peartnoy
07.31.13 | @Rsetness9
thanks man :) | Avagantamos
07.31.13 | pretty good ranking. 4 is 1 for me | Artuma
07.31.13 | oh and how come the title track of Oct isn't one of your favorites off that album? | NeroCorleone80
07.31.13 | 6 is 2 | peartnoy
07.31.13 | @Artuma
There are some great moments in it but it doesn't really feel like a song (a bit like the album doesn't really feel like an album). | tempest--
08.01.13 | dramatic turn of events above images and words lol oh MY god | sonictheplumber
08.01.13 | wtf?!?!?! | peartnoy
08.01.13 | @LloydNewgreen
Yeah opinions suck.
| tempest--
08.01.13 | dude how | dante1991
08.21.13 | Pretty similar to how I'd list 'em. Glad you put 5 over 7 and 8. It's far better than those albums and has a lower/same rating, so good on you sir. 3 is so awesome, it probably has their best lyrical work too. | sonictheplumber
08.21.13 | you suck | OmairSh
08.26.13 | New album will be a 3 | NightmareCinema16
08.26.13 | ...maybe. | OmairSh
08.26.13 | Uh oh, shouldn't have said that with nightmare around :D | NightmareCinema16
08.26.13 | whatever. :] |
|
