avonbarksdale221
07.31.13 | I'll start.
Wish You Were
Dark Side
Animals
Ah this is really hard... The Wall. |
MO
07.31.13 | animals
so fucking hard |
DominionMM1
07.31.13 | wish you were here
dark side of the moon
animals
meddle |
InFiction
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side Of The Moon
The Wall
Animals |
StallionMang
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side
Piper
Meddle |
StallionMang
07.31.13 | Scratch that, Animals instead of Piper. |
avonbarksdale221
07.31.13 | Much as I love Piper, it has to be Animals. |
ChuckyTruant
07.31.13 | Fuck |
ExcentrifugalForz
07.31.13 | piper
animals
wish you were here
meddle |
tommygun
07.31.13 | wish you were here
dark side of the moon
animals
meddle |
Cygnatti
07.31.13 | meddle, fuck the rest. |
demigod!
07.31.13 | lol cyg try harder to be elite k? |
Irving
07.31.13 | WYWH
DSOTM
Animals
Meddle
...fuck The Wall. |
tommygun
07.31.13 | srs though fellas just just skip straight to the grand final
wywh vs animals GO |
demigod!
07.31.13 | tough one
probably wywh though, packs harder feels |
MO
07.31.13 | "srs though fellas just just skip straight to the grand final
wywh vs animals GO"
nice their two best, I like you |
SIMBOLIC
07.31.13 | just skip the shit and hold a vote for DSOTM v WYWH |
SIMBOLIC
07.31.13 | 1,3,5 havent fully listened to both Walls but Meddle fucking owns |
DominionMM1
07.31.13 | ...fuck The Wall. [2]
In relation to its predecessors its weak |
SIMBOLIC
07.31.13 | the wall still seems so far to be a great record whats with the hate |
demigod!
07.31.13 | it is great overall, just watered down with filler. gets a bad rep cause of that + cause it's not as good as the predecessors as dom said
|
MO
07.31.13 | the only way to experience the wall is with the movie
that's where it really shines |
DominionMM1
07.31.13 | the wall could've been soooo much better had dave and rick been more involved in the writing process |
avonbarksdale221
07.31.13 | Agreed, its not perfect, but its still a great record. |
MasBarHigeuoris21
07.31.13 | the only way to experience the wall is with the movie [2]
And tripping balls. Adds to the experience |
MasBarHigeuoris21
07.31.13 | WYWH
DSOTM
Animals
The Wall |
Rowan5215
07.31.13 | Sweet finally a madness where I've heard all the albums
WYWH (although I fucking love Obscured)
Dark Side
Animals
Meddle |
EverythingEvil2113
07.31.13 | WYWH
The Wall
DSOTM
Animals |
manosg
07.31.13 | WYWH
DSOTM
Animals
Meddle |
danielcardoso
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side of the Moon
Animals
The Wall |
SCREAMorphine
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Animals
Dark Side of the Moon
The Wall
It's so hard because I have most of their albums on a 5.
Special mention to Meddle and The Final Cut. |
JamieTwort
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side
Animals
Meddle |
Rowan5215
07.31.13 | IMO all of these are pretty clear choices except for The Wall vs. Meddle, every seems to pick DSOTM, WYWH and Animals. The competitors could've been picked a lot better. |
JamieTwort
07.31.13 | All of these were really easy choices for me, including The Wall vs. Meddle. |
NeroCorleone80
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side of the Moon
Animals
Meddle |
Rowan5215
07.31.13 | Oh yeah for me Meddle was an easy winner for that one but that seems to be the one that people are most divided about; you know how much some people adore the Wall. The others, though, there's no competition. |
Cygnatti
07.31.13 | wall sucks, agreed. |
tempest--
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side of the Moon
Animals
Meddle |
BigPleb
07.31.13 | Animals. |
charbyno
07.31.13 | Wish You Were Here
Dark Side of the Moon
Animals
The Wall |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | dude way to neglect half their albums |
avonbarksdale221
08.01.13 | Pretty sure I said why I did in the summary. 14/2 doesn't really work mathematically now does it? |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | dude you coulda put ummagumma as 2 separate albums and included relics
boom |
avonbarksdale221
08.01.13 | Dammit. Didn't think of that. The top four were pretty much guaranteed anyway though. |
Collis
08.01.13 | mathematically it's wish you were here. although on a personal level i'd tie wish you were here and animals. |
avonbarksdale221
08.01.13 | Vote on the other thread man! |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | well now you have to do a pink floyd madness 2 with the other 8 albums |
avonbarksdale221
08.01.13 | Eh I can't be bothered to be honest |
wacknizzle
08.01.13 | MEDDLE |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | you CAN be bothered to actually, and i intend to bother you relentlessly until you do it |
wacknizzle
08.01.13 | Meddle has the same varied awesome flow that WYWH has, I love them both deeply. Animals is mindblowing but it doesn't have the same personal appeal. All 5's regardless. |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | hear relics dude |
wacknizzle
08.01.13 | Obscured By Clouds is pretty meh |
Permabanned
08.01.13 | i think it rules
hear relics dude [2] |
avonbarksdale221
08.01.13 | Haha now I'm definitely not gonna do it :) |
wacknizzle
08.01.13 | Damn are you right Piss, I didn't know Relics was all non-album material stuff(minus Interstellar). Gonna check that, I need some more See Emily Play era jams. |