gwynbleidd
11.29.12 | Blah blah blah Division bell sux u sux blah blah blah WYWH > DSOTM Blah blah blah
|
Chortles
11.29.12 | swap 2 and 1 and i'd agree |
Skweetis
11.29.12 | Comfortably Numb by itself > 5 |
demigod93
11.29.12 | Atom Heart Mother is so underrated |
gwynbleidd
11.29.12 | Eh I think it's pretty good. Not really anything special though. |
WhiteNoise
11.29.12 | I seriously can't fucking get into DSOTM, god knows i've tried! Wish you were here is badass though. |
ThunderNeutral21
11.29.12 | jesus....this list is actually right. except honestly the wall is so overlong and boring i might even like 9 more somehow. rest is correct, specially top 5. |
ApexPredator
11.29.12 | 3 is 1 for me |
gwynbleidd
11.29.12 | "9 is easily better than 7 or 8, and fuck yeah 1 is in fact 1"
You don't say, lol |
milkwizard
11.29.12 | implying meddle isnt their greatest work |
gwynbleidd
11.29.12 | Echoes is one of the best songs ever yeah, but everthing before that pales in comparison. |
TronaldDump
11.29.12 | 4 does have the benefit of having the best song ever |
Polyethylene
11.29.12 | 2, 3 and 5 are my top three, I like Animals a lot but I don't think it deserves the top spot... |
gwynbleidd
11.29.12 | I like Animals' lyrical themes, besides I believe it was them perfecting their prog side(Since really for a band cathegorized as progressive, there wasn't a hole lot of that in a good part of their music). |
ThunderNeutral21
11.29.12 | lol not true, i mean animals is their perfect but they progged before it hard
and echoes isnt their best song |
TronaldDump
11.29.12 | animals is amazing, but DSOTM is just....timeless |
SCREAM!
11.29.12 | 1 and 2 are so close. Used to like Animals better but Dark Side has been creeping up there and I just don't know anymore. Agree with your 3 and 4 though. Haven't heard 5 or 7. I would also definitely put Atom Heart Mother over Ummagumma |
Graveyard
11.29.12 | asfos is 1 |
jungletiger
11.29.12 | Hey division bell has high hopes which is one of my fav pink floyd tunes |
ThunderNeutral21
11.29.12 | "asfos is 1"
if u aint trolling youre out of your mind |
Graveyard
11.29.12 | it haz all da memberz so u knw its all good |
ThunderNeutral21
11.29.12 | god you are more elite than riff holy shit bro damn |
menawati
11.30.12 | Nice ranking, id put atom heart mother ahead of the wall tho.
and Final Cut is great (altho looks like u not heard yet) |
ThunderNeutral21
11.30.12 | finally people who know the wall is a poopfest |
menawati
11.30.12 | wouldnt call it that, i like it, but its definitely one of their lesser ones |
Chortles
11.30.12 | the wall is overrated but it still rocks |
Atari
11.30.12 | haven't heard them all but animals is my favorite too |
Polyethylene
11.30.12 | The Wall is crazily overrated, half of it rocks whilst the other half I really struggle to enjoy. If they compacted it onto one disc it'd be their best album maybe, as it stands though it's bloated and swamped with filler |
Polyethylene
11.30.12 | ASFOS may have all five of the boys and a number of awesome tracks, but it still feels flawed and incoherent (two front men can't be a good thing) |
Dunpeal
11.30.12 | recently got my hands on Discovery the Samurai edition. forgot how good PF is yeeeeeeeeeeee |
JamieTwort
11.30.12 | 1 is 1 for me too. |
NightmareCinema16
11.30.12 | Nice list. |
MiniatureHorse
12.12.12 | 1 will always be 1 in my ears. |
MiniatureHorse
12.12.12 | 3 is 2 and 2 is 3, imo. |
Strider
12.12.12 | not a big fan of 1, but am in love with 2-4 (well Echoes for 4, but the album still rules) |
MeatSalad
12.12.12 | How can you not like 1 if you like 2-4 |
Strider
12.12.12 | Didn't say I didn't like it, said I'm not a big fan. it's still a good album imo. I didn't listen to it as much as the others, it'll probably sink in one day |
MeatSalad
12.12.12 | Gotta jam it more man, it's easily in their top 3 |
Strider
12.12.12 | I will |
NightmareCinema16
12.12.12 | I've yet to hear one. I probably should. Both 2 and 3 are pretty incredible. |
evilford
12.12.12 | Didn't even rank the final cut, Jesus fuck. Album is so well-written, focused, well done, emotional and thought provoking. 98% of people probably won't even give it a chance cuz "oooooooooo it's POST WALL FLOYD EEEEWWWwW" fucking fools |
NightmareCinema16
12.12.12 | The rest...he hasn't heard, sooooooooo......yeah. |
evilford
12.12.12 | I'm pisssed!!!!!!!!$ |
tommygun
12.12.12 | fuckin opinions man what are they even for |
