The Scene

[Permanent Solution]

I thought about putting this in Punk and/or Hardcore, but I decided that at the core it would be best received here. I may repost it in another forum after I see how discussion goes here.

So, this is where I rant about the state of the scene, basically. I personally hate the modern day scene. I believe children coming into it have corrupted the nature of the scene and basically changed the meaning entirely in an entirely bad way.

The scene used to be a collection of diverse people united by their love of music, their choice of lifestyle and their beliefs. It didn't matter what you looked like, or what your social status was, everyone was friendly to one another and there was a sense of unity among all members of the scene.

Now that has been flipped around almost 180 degrees. It doesn't matter what you believe, and frankly most people don't even believe in anything. You don't have to like the music anymore, you just have to look like everyone else. The unity of ideals and the love of music is gone, to be replaced with a unity of appearances and in my experience, love of acting like a complete douche.

I've been to several shows where I overhear scenesters admitting they don't like the band that's playing, or don't even know who's playing. I love the band I'm coming to see, and they're coming to see a band to preserve their image. I can't unify myself with that.

Since when should appearance even matter? Who cares what you look like? An individual isn't made by what he looks like, an individual is made by how he thinks. The scene used to be full of individuals, sure they all loved the music, and shared ideals, but they didn't share ideals because the scene supported those ideals, they supported them because they believed in them.

Most kids in the scene nowadays aren't even old enough to care. Sure they jump on the anti-Bush bandwagon, but they really haven't even thought about it. Everyone in the scene now just conforms to non-conformity. Breaking the mold in the exact same way every other scenester does, listening to (or claiming to at least) the exact same bands, getting a crappy haircut, dying their hair, throwing on random mismatched clothing, and none of it matters. Who cares about any of that?

I personally cannot identify with the scene anymore. I can't stand the people I am sharing audience space with, I wish I felt a unity like I used to be able to, but now the only unity is a false one generated by people looking the same and acting the same. The anti-thesis of what the scene used to represent. At one time the scene was unified diversity, and now the scene is simply fake, on-the-surface unity.

Well, that's not entirely true. The scene is now socially united, it's full of privileged middle class suburban children looking for an identity and then stealing this one because it's convenient. There was a time when the poor and middle classes mixed in the scene. Now that you can only be part of the scene if you shop at Hot Topic the poorer classes have been thrust from the scene.

Anyways I'm ranting enough, my question to you is, how do you feel about this? Do you feel like you're part of the scene? DO you think it has changed for better or worse? Do you remember the scene before it became all about image? Anything else you want to discuss is welcome too.

[Excursions]

tl;dr

I used fancy mx talk. Honestly I hate the word scene. People always say the hardcore scene this the indie scene that. I think it's a load of bull****. Maybe back in the day when there was a group of people making new music and exploring and creating new music like the early DC heads like Ian Mackaye and Henry Rollins. Other than that I am not part of a scene and no one is in my opinion. Sure people listen to music, go to the local show, wank over the local bands but I don't think that makes you part of a scene, just a fan of music.

[PDWAB]

Originally Posted by zeppelinfan2k3

The scene used to be a collection of diverse people united by their love of music, their choice of lifestyle and their beliefs. It didn't matter what you looked like, or what your social status was, everyone was friendly to one another and there was a sense of unity among all members of the scene.

Do you personally remember this? Because I sure don't.

Honestly as far as I can tell, every musical movement's just been a sham because deep down you're never going to admit that people like music in the same way you do, or as much as you do.

Also, something I've noticed is that every music fan is a complete faggot, so generally I try not to associate with them anyways and just do my own thang, it's a lot easier.

[Permanent Solution]

Originally Posted by Excursions

tl;dr

I used fancy mx talk. Honestly I hate the word scene. People always say the hardcore scene this the indie scene that. I think it's a load of bull****. Maybe back in the day when there was a group of people making new music and exploring and creating new music like the early DC heads like Ian Mackaye and Henry Rollins. Other than that I am not part of a scene and no one is in my opinion. Sure people listen to music, go to the local show, wank over the local bands but I don't think that makes you part of a scene, just a fan of music.

I use scene to mean the trendy "myspace" scene if that wasn't obvious. But why does not sharing a love of a certain type of music make you part of a scene? Sure you can divorce yourself from it, but the opportunity is there as well.

Originally Posted by PDWAB

Do you personally remember this? Because I sure don't.

Honestly as far as I can tell, every musical movement's just been a sham because deep down you're never going to admit that people like music in the same way you do, or as much as you do.

Also, something I've noticed is that every music fan is a complete faggot, so generally I try not to associate with them anyways and just do my own thang, it's a lot easier.

I do. I still experience it to a degree. I work with/have in the past worked with many musicians who are unified through their love of music and share the same political ideologies etc. In fact the scene I was familiar with through my job was one of the most diverse, but unified I've ever had the luck to be part of.

There's a difference between not wanting to admit people like music as much as you, and people outright saying they don't like the band they're paying money to see.

That's just because you listen to bad music dear :-*

[PDWAB]

Originally Posted by zeppelinfan2k3

I do. I still experience it to a degree. I work with/have in the past worked with many musicians who are unified through their love of music and share the same political ideologies etc. In fact the scene I was familiar with through my job was one of the most diverse, but unified I've ever had the luck to be part of.

There's a difference between not wanting to admit people like music as much as you, and people outright saying they don't like the band they're paying money to see.

That's just because you listen to bad music dear :-*

That's interesting because as far as I've been able to tell most scenes that combine music with actual progress and political idealism just result in a whole bunch of bullshit from people that don't really know what they're talking about. Again, that's just what studying the various countercultures in the 60s and 70s said to me, so your own experience might be a little different.

People just like hanging out, and all ages shows are pretty decent for that. It's their money, not yours.

Mr. "I like everything as long as it's rock" strikes again!

[Permanent Solution]

Originally Posted by PDWAB

That's interesting because as far as I've been able to tell most scenes that combine music with actual progress and political idealism just result in a whole bunch of bullshit from people that don't really know what they're talking about. Again, that's just what studying the various countercultures in the 60s and 70s said to me, so your own experience might be a little different.

People just like hanging out, and all ages shows are pretty decent for that. It's their money, not yours.

Mr. "I like everything as long as it's rock" strikes again!

What about the original Punk culture? Hippies started out well but as soon as it became a large trend that problem plagued the movement. I think that's common to any movement though. Once it becomes large enough, people don't know what they're fighting for.

I just have an aversion to spending time listening to music I love, while the kid next to me hates the band and is only there because his friends are going to be there.

/me puts on some Schubert to spite you

[PDWAB]

Originally Posted by zeppelinfan2k3

What about the original Punk culture? Hippies started out well but as soon as it became a large trend that problem plagued the movement. I think that's common to any movement though. Once it becomes large enough, people don't know what they're fighting for.

I just have an aversion to spending time listening to music I love, while the kid next to me hates the band and is only there because his friends are going to be there.

/me puts on some Schubert to spite you

What about the original Punk culture? The earliest parts of it were just people trying to play rock and roll, they weren't trying to change the world. As soon as it moved past that it became a sham. The hippies were full of it too, they only thought they were smart because they used so many drugs.

Eh, that's life. I honestly wouldn't let it bother me, because it's honestly not that big of a deal.

Well well well, if it isn't Mr. "I have some classical stuff so I can pretend to like it and discuss the virtures of the Romantic period and sound smart"

[Permanent Solution]

Originally Posted by PDWAB

What about the original Punk culture? The earliest parts of it were just people trying to play rock and roll, they weren't trying to change the world. As soon as it moved past that it became a sham. The hippies were full of it too, they only thought they were smart because they used so many drugs.

Eh, that's life. I honestly wouldn't let it bother me, because it's honestly not that big of a deal.

Well well well, if it isn't Mr. "I have some classical stuff so I can pretend to like it and discuss the virtures of the Romantic period and sound smart"

Exactly. It's not about trying to change anything, it's about just being yourself. Nowadays that sense of individual is what has died. Back then they did what they want, and sometimes it meshed with what other people were doing and sometimes it didn't. The only progressive idea being pushed forward was the individual ideology, but it was the most important one.

To you I don't know, shows aren't as fun if everyone doesn't dig the music, you know?

I do like Classical :-\ I actually prefer the Baroque I think, but I don't recal what era it all is, I just put on what I like. I could also put on some Flamenco if that suits you better. Incredible music.

[PDWAB]

Originally Posted by zeppelinfan2k3

Exactly. It's not about trying to change anything, it's about just being yourself. Nowadays that sense of individual is what has died. Back then they did what they want, and sometimes it meshed with what other people were doing and sometimes it didn't. The only progressive idea being pushed forward was the individual ideology, but it was the most important one.

To you I don't know, shows aren't as fun if everyone doesn't dig the music, you know?

I do like Classical :-\ I actually prefer the Baroque I think, but I don't recal what era it all is, I just put on what I like. I could also put on some Flamenco if that suits you better. Incredible music.

If the individual is so important, then what's the point of the scene?

It's true, the best shows are when everyone is enjoying the music, but that doesn't always happen. Make a thread about it... whoops.

See now you're just trying too hard.

Also this thread looks hella schizophrenic.

[Excursions]

People bash me here for liking the music I like, to no fault of my own.

[Permanent Solution]

Originally Posted by PDWAB

If the individual is so important, then what's the point of the scene?

It's true, the best shows are when everyone is enjoying the music, but that doesn't always happen. Make a thread about it... whoops.

See now you're just trying too hard.

Also this thread looks hella schizophrenic.

Finding other individuals like yourself. The point is to get to where you want to be, and then find other people you connect with.

*shrug* Close it if you dont think it's providing good discussion. I mainly made it because I'm in a bad mood so I wanted something to debate, I'm not going to lie.

I can't win

I know, change your avatar nub :-\

Adam: Which music? Most of the time when I make fun it's joking, I hope you know that :-\

[PDWAB]

Eh, I don't care. I'd like to see what other people think, I am kind of a jerk about these things anyways because I really can't stand music fans.

[Excursions]

People seem to have a problem with me liking Kelly Clarkson and having a Black Flag avatar.

Vince: Not you.

[Independent_CA]

Hell fucking yeah PDWAB. I'm only 20 and I see what you're seeing. However I still think there's hope. I just went to Fall Fest yesterday to see Bad Religion headline, and while there were a lot of stupid people, by the end of the day it was the true, unified diehards for the mostpart that were left. I totally agree with what you said. I'll probably post my own rant later when I have more time.

[Untitled]

I didnt read the majority of that, i will later, bu i must say i do realy hate the scene atm. Well the kids, some of the bands are ok i guess.

[Kif]

I've gotten so sick of hearing about the scene I just don't notice it anymore, like Hollywood movies and Big Brother. It just flies by me.

People complaining about dress codes, discussing the number of Myspace comments they got for their latest picture and how they "stole someone's comment virginity". It's ridiculous sometimes, and has gotten to the point where the scene is just a group of people who decide on incoming trends and music for everyone else to love.

I think one reason for this however is the over-exposure of talentless bands. OK, talentless might be a bit harsh, but unoriginal definately. Purevolume and Myspace have opened the window for homegrown bands to advertise, even though a lot just sound like their favourite bands. I do it, my music sounds similar to bands. Not necessarily my favourite ones, but bands that inspire me to write music, their traits are certainly in the music I write.

And of course, it's the bands that set these fashions. You get bands like My American Heart, Funeral For A Friend, Bullet For My Valentine, Senses Fail. They all look similar, with black band tees/clothing company tees with pictures of bleeding hearts and whatnot. Tight jeans and Converse shoes.

Like I said, I don't like discussing the scene because to me it's pretty non-existent. I listen to music I love, dress how I want to dress and act like I want to act. Of course, it's not completely my own because we are all influenced by the media and things like websites, our friends telling us about bands and stuff. I think that's the reason I don't like talking about the scene, because I don't want to get sucked into a lifestyle I don't want to live in.

[albert_bass]

I don't care about the "scene". I don't even know if there's a scene, all I know is I go to the shows I want, just because it's good fun.

And if I go to a show I might not love it's because a friend asked me to go with him and because even if I don't love it I like to dance to da music.

[Oz Rembrandt]

Its true, when I started into "The Scene", there was about 12 of us in my area, and none of us looked the same as eachother let alone the other kids. Now I walk around, and being "Different" or "Alternative", is the new cool thing, and if everyones doing it, how can it be different?

I gave up caring a long time ago. I still wear the clothes I always wore, I continue to like the bands I liked before half these kids could even spell. It dosn't bother me anymore.

[Untitled]

Originally Posted by albert_bass

I don't care about the "scene". I don't even know if there's a scene, all I know is I go to the shows I want, just because it's good fun.

And if I go to a show I might not love it's because a friend asked me to go with him and because even if I don't love it I like to dance to da music.

If you want to see the scene in all its wrath, go to the millenium gardens in manchester, on a saterday, AKA, THE UBRIS!!

I know its a bit of a treck for you.

[Angry Balled Fists!]

There is no scene here.

Well, kinda but they are all gay and i don't mix with them really...