Ok I recorded it again using a 2mm pick. A bit heavy, but the pick strumming isn't as noticeable. Although it is much more bright sounding.
Sound any better?
http://media.putfile.com/Opeth---Harvest-32
I also noticed, I can't hear it on my winamp nearly as much because I use an EQ on it. Through regular windows media player it is much more noticeable. So maybe it didn't help at all? =/