View Single Post
Old 05-31-2005, 11:12 PM   #14
SubtleDagger
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
LOL hay SD quit banning me it totally sux!!!2

Kevbud - This song pretty much beat me over the head with the point and got old pretty fast. I'm talking after the first stanza, since that's around when I went, "Hey this song is about gold digging probly".
15th

DFelon
- Sorry man, but it reads like an encyclopedia, and is just about as poetic aside from the end. I don't care if it will work as a song, just if it works as poetry. I don't really think it does aside from the last stanza. I really do like the last stanza though.
8th

pixies
- It's good, but I did tell you that it's just too short for me. Has its moments though.
6th

toddcotham
- Well... it has a lot of potential. The lyricism is good, but the imagery and storyline sound like something Stevie Nicks would write. So it sounds a bit pretentious to me. It doesn't really come off that way for the most part though.
5th

RunAmok
- Tragically DQed.

super deluxe - I miss super d in here a lot because her songs are usually really good. This is no exception. I'm not a big fan of the overdramatic ending but everything else is aces.
1st

bowl of oranges
- It's decent. You need more command of grammar and sentence structure. Has potential though.
9th

SeasonOfTheMind
- Starts out okay, but then the forced rhymes start pummeling me. Awful, awful forced rhymes, especially in the third stanza. They're just relentless. No way I can give this a decent standing.
12th

Konrad
- Most of it is fine, until I come about that "WARNING" line, which is just way way way too pretentious for me. It's just not at all a clever device in my opinion. Aside from that and the sixth stanza, it's good. but those two areas really need work.
7th

addictedtochaos
- :|. Not my sort of thing. You seem to have found your writing style, I'm just not a big fan of it. Too ambiguous and I just don't seem to retain interest.
11th

WhatILiveFor
- You came out of nowhere as far as I can tell, but your songs are very good. This is no exception. Good job.
2nd

Corupt
- I don't see how you can put all these definitions for "big words" at the top and then use "soul" instead of "sole". And that's just a simple error honestly, you have major structural problems. "Reasoning this happines" makes no sense, "shock" should be "shocked", "rest" is "rests"... I could go on and on but I'll spare you. Work on the simple stuff first and not the complex stuff.
13th

jurial
- Good for the most part. Some of it's a bit too cliche for me and some is a bit too lengthy (that's right, I'm complaining that something is "lengthy"). Decent though.
4th

MMPR
- Very good, A bit too short. I like your writing.
3rd

k.s.e
- I personally thought this just was not interesting enough, which is probably why I saw it and yet completely missed critting it the first time around. I just couldn't really get into it.
10th

Tyrion
- Not that hot. Storytelling isn't interesting, imagery isn't good. Meh.
14th

Rushfan
- I'm sure I'll be hearing cries of "OMG biased", but your rhymes are forced and you have grammatical and structural problems galore. Wordplay isn't very clever either.
16th

Last edited by SubtleDagger; 06-05-2005 at 07:00 PM.