|
I don't have any problem with you, I stated my opinion, and you challenged me. If anyone has a problem, it would be you.
Don't tell me to "quit my bitching" I will bitch as much as I want, thank you very much. Sure, you might not be the only one to do a 6/5 rating, but that doesn't make it alright. It is still stupid for the reasons I posted above.
You are right, this is an internet forum, but this is also a review forum, where people review CDs. There should be some standard of professionalism used when reviewing a CD. I fail to see how using an accurate scale is depriving you of fun on the forum.
Regardless, stop with the personal stuff. I never wanted it, I just want to discuss the album. You are the one who has to go and challenge people and whatnot. I don't want Sting to come in and have to intervene here again.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Just because Mer de Noms is in a different genre then Aenema (which is debatable), doesn't mean you can't compare them. Furthermore, that is irrelevant for the points I made. Aenema is a CD that is just awsome, truely deserving of the 5/5 rating. Whereas Mer De Noms is not as good as Aenema, regardless of the genre, it just isn't as good (my opinion of course). I didn't have to use Aenema, I could use any awsome CD in any genre, and my point still stands.
And I obviously stated that I liked the CD, and it was my cup of tea. However, it isn't as good as you are making it out to be, which is my main point.
I'm not being condescencing to you or your reviews. I am critiquing what you are doing because it has several fatal flaws in it, and you are blowing a roid over the slightest disagreement someone has with your rating.
You need to calm down and learn that people will have other opinions on CDs then you do, and they will voice them when you post a review. You need to learn to live with and tolerate those opinions, and not try to challenge them because you think they are some kind of threat to your review.
And Sting-Ray, I'm sorry this had to be posted here, but it does. I'll refrain from getting into any longwinded arguments with rob in the future. However, I feel that it is important that posters be allowed to voice their opinions about CD reviews, even when they don't agree with the main poster, without being challenged and attacked, like I was.
|