Who's your favorite Critic?
 

Who has offered you the best advice with strong criticism and good ideas..

for me I'd haveta say

Bexi
Sade
Pirate Satellite
and Disco Dragon

Remember just because you may have not liked what they had to say.. either because that's not what you wanted to hear or whatever.

Doesn't mean you didn't recieve a good criticism..

well I don't really have a favorite critic, because I for one believe that as long as someone can say what they like or dislike and explain why and can tell you a way to improve, means he or she is already a good critic

broken, POOstain, and Merkaba-1. my buddies. :D i haven't seen poostain for a while though...

that perfect sonnet guy usually has good advice

[QUOTE=MicMidas14]broken, POOstain, and Merkaba-1. my buddies. :D i haven't seen poostain for a while though...[/QUOTE]
:chug: woot woot. its all about being honest, I've said your work has sucked before micmidas, but i also said why. but usualy your a machine at writing, lol.

lol i like bexi corupt and maggot, they have a good idea of what they are talking about and usually give me good advice to my song style, even though they dont like emo :'( oh well, still good

lol, i suppose when im into it my critiques actually get into some good depth ;)

I like Corupt, Bexi, and when your not being a flamming faggot, Sonnet

I havnt posted any work in awhile but I think I will right now. All Please crit me :D

I Like Me!

[QUOTE=maggotfelon]I Like Me![/QUOTE] :thumb:

:D

I can't help but fvcking love me man!

lmao, im a flaming faggot? someone call the fab 5! its cool man, i do get dumb sometimes, but every once in a while i give some good advice

It happens, what can I say, lol.

i'd go with theredwonder or whatever his name is. lol. he's awesome at telling me how my songs could be improved. thanks dude. oh, and MisterXisSilent. he's cool too. :D ...lol.

heh alot of people like bexi that's cool but
[sarcasm]
everyone seems to love maggotfelon...
cmon man how do you do it..?
[/sarcasm]
lol

hey fvck you... you know you love me bioche. :D You can't hide it mofo.

lmao yeah

Dude, no one mentioned me?!?! Good, cause I really can't say anything about songs I like, I just tear up the ones I don't as a public service to shame bands from putting terrible lyrics to music.

As for my lyrics, I haven't posted them in a while...not since the laughable joke that was Closet Christian (but apparently it was a good joke, cause most people liked it!) I know I'm becoming the Axl Rose of these forums always promising new stuff then delaying it every other day, but THIS TIME new stuff really is on it's way;)

lmao xhinde your not a critic at all.. your an awesome basher! I loved the bash on the Ska Song

^Um....thanks!!!!:)

I prefer to be called "critic" anyways;)

Ska Song belongs in the Hall of Fame of Roasts.

how about "The Critic" like that show on comedy central, good stuff i say... yeah your bash of ska song was ownage :)

will you bash one of mine? just look for a search on crap

haha if you insist ;)

I hate everyone on these forums.

















you all SUCK.




































Seriously....


hahahah, just kidding...I'd have to say I like Bexi alot, she had.."good advice"

And I also respect Disco Dragon, he's a very mature critiquer

Also there's some guy on here obsessed with blind guardian, always makes references to them, and for that-I love him. (Whoever he is)

sade go back and read my reply on the decision dreamt

I atta bitch slap you lmao!

joshmay and pixiesfanyo are good with letting me know what's wrong and Disco helped a little, too, I think, so they get brownie points and a gold star.

omg i only get a silver star... :(

sonnet you only get butter bars so I dunno why in the hell anyone gave you silver stars those are reserved for.. err.. who cares lol

i think A_Perfect_Sonnet writes some good critiques, and hes **** sexy, just IM him for his pic (xzxdanzigxzx), he shows his nipples too!

wtf is a butter bar?

I like Rollerqueen and Benbaker. Because I like both of their writings alot.