hey it is stickied!!
nice

Wow, this list is amazing. Good Job on the reviews everyone. :thumb:

[QUOTE=ihatecelebrities]I liked your 17 Reasons blurb silver, good job Joe and everyone else who helped[/QUOTE]
Thank you.


Sketchy, you did a wicked job.

[QUOTE=sketchyjoe]Psychobilly is good but most of the psychobilly on Hellcat isn't.[/QUOTE]
amen. I don't think the horrorpops should be on there.

Good job, all involved (some more than others, but you know). I know all of about a dozen albums on there, if that, but I can see this thing being of immense use to me in future.

Awesome

[QUOTE=Silvermedalmafia]amen. I don't think the horrorpops should be on there.[/QUOTE]
I'm the only one who voted for them...

I do think it's weird that chips88 put them on the list when I'm pretty sure I was the only one.

Oh well. At least I'm one of the other three people here who are happy about it.

[QUOTE=Silvermedalmafia]amen. I don't think the horrorpops should be on there.[/QUOTE]

that's what I thought before I signed up to do the review.

[QUOTE=DDM]that's what I thought before I signed up to do the review.[/QUOTE]
Imaginary rep+

I just cant seem to see how Rancids 'Lets Go' album got higher than 'And Out Come The Wolves'? Not my favourite list, seeing that Black Flag - The First Four Years so high in the list... but thats my opinion and opinions are full of **** right?
Thanks to the guys who made the whole list and stuff, good job :)

I think it's because that and out come the wolves was in a harder poll than lets go. I remember it so.

[QUOTE=GREENDAY]good job joe u sexxy son of a bi'tch[/QUOTE]
hey *******, im hte only one here who is allowed to have a bob sager avatar. check the rules

[QUOTE=Namdrater]I just cant seem to see how Rancids 'Lets Go' album got higher than 'And Out Come The Wolves'? [/QUOTE]

Let's Go is a better CD than Out Come The Wolves

[QUOTE=Namdrater]I just cant seem to see how Rancids 'Lets Go' album got higher than 'And Out Come The Wolves'? Not my favourite list, seeing that Black Flag - The First Four Years so high in the list... but thats my opinion and opinions are full of **** right?
Thanks to the guys who made the whole list and stuff, good job :)[/QUOTE]

as dboon put it


'...and out come the singles'


it was a mediocre album, with a few songs that got popular

awesum awesum list glad to see op ivy. on there and anti-flag! :thumb:

[QUOTE=Brothel_Creeper]as dboon put it


'...and out come the singles'


it was a mediocre album, with a few songs that got popular[/QUOTE]

It was still a great album, with better songs on than Let's Go. London Calling is also mediocore, but it is still great. :chug:

[QUOTE=Henrik]It was still a great album, with better songs on than Let's Go. London Calling is also mediocore, but it is still great. :chug:[/QUOTE]

Let's Go had way better songs, i reckon. Nihilism, Salvation, Radio, Side Kick etc are all classics and the average song is way better than on AOCTW.

How can London Calling be mediocre and great?

[QUOTE=honkybrewster]I'm the only one who voted for them...

I do think it's weird that chips88 put them on the list when I'm pretty sure I was the only one.

Oh well. At least I'm one of the other three people here who are happy about it.[/QUOTE]

There were like 50 cd's that had only one nomination, I chose that one cause I felt like putting some diversity in there, and I thought more people liked them, but turns out I was wrong. My bad.

I just found this list. Lots of good stuff, but why are The Boys completely missing?

Hey guys, you know I've been some time out of these forums, I'm sorry I only did 2 reviews and I know Joe has done lots of reviews and a lot of work so thanks Joe. This is way better than I could imagine when chips started this list. Great job of all you guys and specially Chips and Joe.


EDIT: Now that I've read it I see it's pretty much an awesome list. Some albums fail but it's the best list I've ever seen about punk albums. I say Sketchyjoe for mod (If he wants), he really deserves it.

[QUOTE=Henrik]It was still a great album, with better songs on than Let's Go. London Calling is also mediocore, but it is still great. :chug:[/QUOTE]

lets see shall we


good songs on aoctw - ruby soho, roots radicals, the wars end, the way i feel

good songs on let's go - nihilism, radio, i'm the one, 7 years down, st marys, sidekick, gave it away, motorcycle ride, solidarity, dope sick girl

easy innit

[QUOTE=Henrik]It was still a great album, with better songs on than Let's Go. London Calling is also mediocore, but it is still great. :chug:[/QUOTE]
How can something be mediocre and great at the same time?

Sublime???
 

I dont understand why isnt sublime on this you have catch 22 and not sublime thats a little harsh.

Because Sublime are overrated and not very good?

And they didn't get nominated.

[QUOTE=sketchyjoe]Because Sublime are overrated and not very good?[/QUOTE]

123

[QUOTE=cinemanine]I dont understand why isnt sublime on this you have catch 22 and not sublime thats a little harsh.[/QUOTE]

Because Catch 22 > Sublime in every way possible.

Rep ++ !!

Idk i think sublime was able to throw a ****load of cool music styles together, and is overated because people mostly listen to their major label debut, the self titled album. Anyone that isnt really into sublime should check out Robbin' the hood, its a good one. Great list though, the only thing i can really complain about is 98, the Nekromantix album, Whoever did the review is an a'sshole. I know im going to get BLASTED because "i had the chance blah blah blah". But there is a lot of stuff on that list, that doesnt mean i would just **** on everything i didnt like... maybe someone who gave a **** about nekromantix couldve written that review instead of some as'shole who says something as unintelligent as "this **** sucks, whoever voted for it is retarded"...but all in all great list

[QUOTE=sketchyjoe]How can something be mediocre and great at the same time?[/QUOTE]

Sorry my fault, I wrote a mistake. I didn't meen mediocore, just a cd with lot's of catchy hits on it. London Calling was a great album, but it was very popish,(if that is a word).

I still tihink that ..and out come the wolves is a way better cd than Let's Go. I think that all the songs are great on it, even though it is not very punk.