Modest Mouse vs. American Idol

[Robert Crumb]

At the risk of starting a good argument...

lol

[Matt?]

oh man that was strange

[Boilermaker]

They both suck. Well Modes Mouse doesn't 'suck', I just don't like them.

So they win. Hey Matt, where you from in New Hampshire?

[Robert Crumb]

oh man that was strange

It seemed so superfluous. Like the fat guy with the jewfro thought it would be a good idea at the last minute.

[Matt?]

hampton

[A_Guy]

I just noticed the name Modest Mouse is strikingly similar to classic composer Modest Mussorgsky.

[Captain Rapeface]

Would it be overly sequiturous of me to suggest that Modest Mouse is not so modest?

[Zmev]

I like both of them.

[Sepstrup]

Me too. Is anyone else starting to get bored with the whole freak show thing though? I find myself wanting to watch the contestants that are actually good, more than the ones who makes asses out of themselves.

Only on American Idol could a singer be called 'Commercial with a capital C' as a compliment.

[PUNKrockMETALscreamo]

I think I would choose Modest Mouse over American Idol cause the contestants aren't as tough as last year's were.

[punkemohardcorekid]

At the risk of starting a good argument...

lol

XD . . .

[Neoteric]

punkrawkMETALdude

[Robert Crumb]

Mostly, I was wondering if anyone caught the episode last week where they all sung "Float On."

They're doing British Invasion songs tonite omg omg

[sutinblev]

ooooh. Glad I didn't catch that. I'm going with Modest Mouse though because some of its members still have some talent

[EinzingerIsGod]

hampton

I'm just over the line in MA

[ThePinkPanther]

modest mouse because i like them

[Eliminator]

american idol because the pink panther likes them

[DonBass]

american idols getting kinda lame. modest mouse definetly.

[DRUMMER MAN]

Would it be overly sequiturous of me to suggest that Modest Mouse is not so modest?

I agree.

[Reject_False_Idols]

hampton

aw man, live like 30 minutes from you.

[shugzz]

I just heard Modest Mouse on the radio, I'm gonna have to go with them.

[Yman]

good news for people who like bad news wasnt that bad. luckily for me, the frattiest kid in my dorm loves getting hammered and singing all of modest mouse's songs as loud as he can. So american idol and modest mouse are pretty much the same for me.

[punkerdan]

modest mouse because the song ´shít luck´ is awesome

[Aeaon]

I didn't even know one of those talentless losers even covered a modest mouse song. That's ****ed up!