Substance vs Substance

[br3ad_man]

I felt like making another vs thread. Has this been done before? I'm not sure.

Do you prefer New Order's Substance collection or Joy Division's Substance? I personally can't decide, but I think I might end up leaning more towards Joy Division's. On the other hand, there's a good chance I might not.

Post which record you prefer and why.

[Iai]

I thought this was gonna be a thread arguing music with real substance vs. music that sounds good when taking illegal substances.

Joy Division

[pixiesfanyo]

JD always beats New Division or Order

[br3ad_man]

I'm not sure what I'll go with, the JD one has songs I don't like, but the New Order one is massive.

I thought this was gonna be a thread arguing music with real substance vs. music that sounds good when taking illegal substances.

Joy Division

You could always make that thread.

[Dave de Sylvia]

I thought this was gonna be a thread arguing music with real substance vs. music that sounds good when taking illegal substances.

Joy Division
Me too. I suppose you could spin it into a music with substance (New Order) vs someone that could have benefit from more(or at least better) illegal substances (Ian Curtis) but that would have too many words I think.

Plus it's stupid.

Anyway, I vote Dokken or something.

[Iai]

Poll say: MX says NO to New Order.

[Zmev]

Pretty much

[br3ad_man]

I'm going with New Order now.

[morrissey]

I prefer Joy Division, but NO's Substance is a better/more comprehensive album.

[The_Passenger]

Tough call. It's going to have to be New Order's though.

[Little Man being Erased]

I haven't heard either of the Substance collections. In fact, the only album I've heard by either band is Closer. I've had it for a while now and I can't seem to get into it. As far as post-punk goes I much rather Gang of Four.

So I guess that was fairly bloody pointless wasn't it?