The Top Metalcore Albums

[cbmartinez]

100 Demons- In the Eyes of the Lord
7 Angels 7 Plagues- Jhazmyne's Lullabye
All Else Failed- Archetype
All Out War- Condemned To Suffer
All Out War- For Those Who Were Crucified
Anodyne- Lifetime Of Grey Skies
Botch- American Nervoso
Botch- We Are The Romans
Catharsis- Samsra
Cave In- Until Your Heart Stops
Coalesce- Functioning on Impatience
Coalesce- Give Them Rope
Converge- Jane Doe
Converge- Petitioning The Empty Sky
Death By Stereo- Into The Valley Of Death
Earth Crisis- Destroy the Machines
Earth Crisis- Gomorroh's Season Ends
Every Time I Die- Hot Damn!
Integrity- Humanity Is The Devil
Integrity- Those Who Fear Tomorrow
Kiss It Goodbye- She Loves Me, She Loves Me Not
Poison The Well- The Opposite Of December
Ringworm- The Promise
Ringworm- Justice Replaced
Scarlet- Cult Classic
Turmoil- The Process Of...
Unbroken- Life Love Regret
Underminded- Hail Unamerican!
Vision of Disorder- Imprint

Okay, there's the list. If you've got any last minute nominations or problems, say them now. The old list can be found here (http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=300648); make sure nothing was left off that you guys would like to see on there (Cave-In? Turmoil? Martyr A.D?). As you can see the list is a bit large so I ask those who nominated to remember that this list is for the best of the best. If you nominated something just because you were listening to it at the time or just think it's a pretty good album, please don't hesistate to retract your nominations. Anyway, this thread is your last chance to make changes. Genre experts, don't hesistate to make removals (I tried to keep tech metal like #12 and DEP off).

[oopyman]

Put Turmoil - The Process Of... on.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Chris take Underoath off that list before I find your a'ss and kill you.


Earth Crisis are hardcore, but since you people on this forum suck I'll let it slide this time. Same with Hatebreed.

Add Cave In - Untill Your Heart Stops

[cbmartinez]

Done and done.

[oopyman]

Chris take Underoath off that list before I find your a'ss and kill you.


Earth Crisis are hardcore, but since you people on this forum suck I'll let it slide this time. Same with Hatebreed.

Add Cave In - Untill Your Heart Stops
I don't think EC are metalcore either, but I knew they'd be accepted so I put it up.

[cbmartinez]

I think they're hardcore. That makes three of us. I'll take them off the list if you guys want.

[oopyman]

Nah just leave em.

I think Integrity, 100 Demons, and Unbroken are hardcore too but I'm probably the only one.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Nah 100 Demons are deff metalcore, they just play with a lot of hardcore bands.

[oopyman]

What do you think about Unbroken and Integrity? And Ringworm? If you count Ringworm then add Ringworm - The Promise and Ringworm - Justice Replaced by Revenge.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

I'm not big on Ringworm, I'd put them somewhere between Crossover and Metalcore.

Unbroken I don't listen to and Integrity I would put somewhere close to Ringworm, I'm not a Integrity fan though so don't quote me.

[cbmartinez]

Pretty sure Ringworm are considered metalcore. I'll add them.

[south_guitar]

This is a thousand times better than the old one.

Earth Crisis and Integrity are close enough to be on the list.

[oopyman]

Pretty sure Ringworm are considered metalcore. I'll add them.
Well?

[south_guitar]

And you can probably take The Power & The Glory off. I'm just currently obsessed with the album at the moment. Unless anyone else wants it on there?

[oopyman]

And you can probably take The Power & The Glory off. I'm just currently obsessed with the album at the moment. Unless anyone else wants it on there?
It's a good album, but I dunno if it should be on the top metalcore albums of all time list.

[waronpeace]

im sorry but underminded isnt metalcore. i love them and all, but theyre not really metal.

[cbmartinez]

Yeah they really are.

[oopyman]

im sorry but underminded isnt metalcore. i love them and all, but theyre not really metal.
They definitely are not hardcore.

[south_guitar]

It's a good album, but I dunno if it should be on the top metalcore albums of all time list.
Yeah, it's best left off of the list.

[Mr. Ron]

100 Demons- In the Eyes of the Lord
7 Angels 7 Plagues- Jhazmyne's Lullabye
All Else Failed- Archetype
All Out War- Condemned To Suffer
All Out War- For Those Who Were Crucified
Anodyne- Lifetime Of Grey Skies
Botch- We Are The Romans
Buried Alive- Death Of Your Perfect World
Catharsis- Samsra
Cave In- Until Your Heart Stops
Coalesce- Functioning on Impatience
Coalesce- Give Them Rope
Converge- Jane Doe
Converge- Petitioning The Empty Sky
Death By Stereo- Into The Valley Of Death
Earth Crisis- Destroy the Machines
Earth Crisis- Gomorroh's Season Ends
Every Time I Die- Hot Damn!
Hatebreed- Satisfaction Is The Death Of Desire
Integrity- Humanity Is The Devil
Integrity- Those Who Fear Tomorrow
Kiss It Goodbye- She Loves Me, She Loves Me Not
Poison The Well- The Opposite Of December
Ringworm- The Promise
Ringworm- Justice Replaced
Scarlet- Cult Classic
Turmoil- The Process Of...
Unbroken- Life Love Regret
Underminded- Hail Unamerican!
Vision of Disorder- Imprint

Okay, there's the list. If you've got any last minute nominations or problems, say them now. The old list can be found here (http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=300648); make sure nothing was left off that you guys would like to see on there (Cave-In? Turmoil? Martyr A.D?). As you can see the list is a bit large so I ask those who nominated to remember that this list is for the best of the best. If you nominated something just because you were listening to it at the time or just think it's a pretty good album, please don't hesistate to retract your nominations. Anyway, this thread is your last chance to make changes. Genre experts, don't hesistate to make removals (I tried to keep tech metal like #12 and DEP off).



Sup. :cool:

[mikexmcdaniel]

People really need to listen to Lifetime of Grey Skies. And anything else by Anodyne, for that matter.

[Mr. Ron]

People really need to listen to Lifetime of Grey Skies. And anything else by Anodyne, for that matter.
Anodyne are great.

[X_DeathRunsUponUs_X]

Dead to Fall - Everything I Touch Falls To Peices.

idk if thats metalcore or death metal.. but that cd kicks sooo much f*cking ***

[Let's Chop Cats!]

They just suck.

[The_shotgun_message]

Does anyone else agree that you come before you is an awsome cd aswell? I reckon that its as good as t.o.o.d. but tear from the red was a definite dissapointment imo

[Billy]

Paria - Misanthropos.

Oh, and maybe Deadwater Drowning's ST.

[Berserker!]

I don't think EC are metalcore either, but I knew they'd be accepted so I put it up.
Then I nominate The Promise-Believer

[Mr. Ron]

Paria - Misanthropos.

Oh, and maybe Deadwater Drowning's ST.
Misanthropos is a really good album, but idk if you would call them metalcore or not.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Then I nominate The Promise-Believer
Are you retarded?

[whiteminority]

Botch- American Nervosa

i forgot to mention it during nominations

[A-Life-Less-Plagued]

Then I nominate The Promise-Believer
What the ****...?

[Berserker!]

What the ****...?

It's sort of metalcore.

[JACK!]

Born From Pain - In Love With The End definatly deserves a mention.

[Fabz]

It's sort of metalcore.

Seriously, no

[Berserker!]

Metallic hardcore...

C'mon if we're talking about Earth Crisis

[A-Life-Less-Plagued]

It's sort of metalcore.
How?

[A-Life-Less-Plagued]

Metallic hardcore...

C'mon if we're talking about Earth Crisis
They sound nothing like Earth Crisis. Where'e the metal in the Promise?

[Berserker!]

Where'e the metal in the Promise?
I here quite a lot of that 'chugga chugga' riffs and stuff...

whatever

[Times Ten]

The Promise is great but they aren't metal at all.

[Berserker!]

Maybe a tiny bit but meh

[Concubine]

Heh..Anodyne metalcore?

[mikexmcdaniel]

Heh..Anodyne metalcore?

umm....yeah

[Billy]

Misanthropos is a really good album, but idk if you would call them metalcore or not.
Eh, it's really on the metal side, maybe even grind, but I think it should be added because it's generally metalcore, and it's such an incredible album.

[oopyman]

Dom, listen to **** other than Firestorm. The entire Gomorroh's Season Ends album has tons of weird metallic riffs and what not. The Promise are like melodic hardcore.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Listen ot the All Out War 7" and try and tell me that is not hardcore.

[blklbl]

you should add:

unearth: the oncoming storm

as i lay dying: shadows are security

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Ughh no thanks.

[Let's Chop Cats!]

Buried Alive are hardcore also. Just noticed them on the list.

[oopyman]

At least no one nominated Shai Hulud.

[NewKindofArmy03]

Buried Alive are hardcore also. Just noticed them on the list.
So is that Hatebreed album.

[Mr. Ron]

At least no one nominated Shai Hulud.
I think they have some of the best lyrics ever.

[oopyman]

I think they have some of the best lyrics ever.
I think they're a great band. They aren't metalcore though.

[Mr. Ron]

I think they're a great band. They aren't metalcore though.
I know that.

[oopyman]

I know that.
Oh, the way you said it made it seem like you were defending them as if I attacked them. My baddd.

[ITRIEDVOODOOONCE]

Paria = amazing most def put on Misanthropos

[lunchforthesky]

killswitch engage deserve a mention both end of heartache and alive or just breathing.

[Mr. Ron]

killswitch engage deserve a mention both end of heartache and alive or just breathing.
Definetly not.

[PenguinOfDoom]

What about the number twelve looks like you, would they warrant.

[Mute Print]

Nope...

(I tried to keep tech metal like #12 and DEP off).

[The_shotgun_message]

At least no one nominated Shai Hulud.

Wouldnt they be considered kinda metalcore or what, melodic hardcore?

[Mr. Ron]

Wouldnt they be considered kinda metalcore or what, melodic hardcore?
I'd just say hardcore.

[The_shotgun_message]

That within blood ill tempered has a definite metal edge to it

[Let's Chop Cats!]

So does Terror doesn't make them metalcore.

[The_shotgun_message]

Ye but shai hulud are far more technical than most hardcore band IMO. Ah never mind fair enough

[oopyman]

Ye but shai hulud are far more technical than most hardcore band IMO. Ah never mind fair enough
No Warning have solos. Are they metalcore? With Honor have complex harmonies. Are they metalcore?

[srt-4]

either way shai hulud rules

[oopyman]

either way shai hulud rules
This is not false.

[The_shotgun_message]

Set your body ablaza is an awsome song as is much of TWBIT, havnt heard much older stuff

[Malice]

I nominate Parkway Drive - Killing With A Smile

[cbmartinez]

The Best Metalcore Albums

A List By The Hardcore/Emo Forum

100 Demons- In the Eyes of the Lord
7 Angels 7 Plagues- Jhazmyne's Lullabye
All Else Failed- Archetype
All Out War- Condemned To Suffer
All Out War- For Those Who Were Crucified
Anodyne- Lifetime Of Grey Skies
Botch- American Nervoso
Botch- We Are The Romans
Catharsis- Samsra
Cave In- Until Your Heart Stops
Coalesce- Functioning on Impatience
Coalesce- Give Them Rope
Converge- Jane Doe
Converge- Petitioning The Empty Sky
Death By Stereo- Into The Valley Of Death
Earth Crisis- Destroy the Machines
Earth Crisis- Gomorroh's Season Ends
Every Time I Die- Hot Damn!
Integrity- Humanity Is The Devil
Integrity- Those Who Fear Tomorrow
Kiss It Goodbye- She Loves Me, She Loves Me Not
Poison The Well- The Opposite Of December
Ringworm- The Promise
Ringworm- Justice Replaced
Scarlet- Cult Classic
Turmoil- The Process Of...
Unbroken- Life Love Regret
Underminded- Hail Unamerican!
Vision of Disorder- Imprint

Okay Reiner, there's the list. Post it in the rules.

[Mr. Ron]

I thought everybody didn't consider All Else Failed metalcore? Meh, oh well they deserve praise.

[NewKindofArmy03]

I thought everybody didn't consider All Else Failed metalcore? Meh, oh well they deserve praise.
I always did.

[Arrakakaka]

What about the number twelve looks like you, would they warrant.
They're grind.

Aaagh, Knut gets no love.

:(

[whiteminority]

They're grind.

Aaagh, Knut gets no love.

:(
Knut are good, but The Number 12 is not grind at all, they are metal with a heavy dose of scene.

[ZaaR]

Damn, I wanted to put Himsa - Courting Tradgedy and Disaster :(

[whiteminority]

Damn, I wanted to put Himsa - Courting Tradgedy and Disaster :(
That would be wrong.

[Malice]

I take it none of you guys have heard "Killing With A Smile" by Parkway Drive?

[Arrakakaka]

Unearth-The Oncomming Storm
That is all. Or would be all if I wasnt too late.
:rolleyes:

Not metalcore..

Knut are good, but The Number 12 is not grind at all, they are metal with a heavy dose of scene.
Well, whatever they are, they're not metalcore.

They are grindish..

[whiteminority]

:rolleyes:

Not metalcore..


Well, whatever they are, they're not metalcore.

They are grindish..
i know they are not metalcore, but they are not grind.

[Unleash the bastards]

That would be wrong.
Himsa are lightyears better than Underminded. I'd be cool with it being on the list. They're one of the better metalcore bands around.

[whiteminority]

Himsa are good but Courting Tragedy and Disaster is not metalcore.

[SunnyDayRealEstateAM]

Himsa are straight up metal.

[stinger]

surely last night in town is a much better example of metalcore over hot damn! i take it your also trying to avoid 'scene' bands because there are a **** loads missing, like darkest hour, bury your dead, scars of tomorrow and all that shite, maybe not good examples of metalcore, but metalcore none the less

[whiteminority]

Well when a scene band makes a top metalcore album of all time they will get on the list.

[stinger]

oh right, i didnt realise you were actually basing this list on anything other than coming up with a list of bands, my bad

[xcolormebloodredx]

No one included Arkangel's 'Dead Man Walking'? Suprising.