CIV, Shelter, Quicksand > GB and YOT

[Tyler]

I speak troof

[Mr. Ron]

Quicksand is amazing.

[Brain Toad]

Civ is better than Gorilla Biscuits, I agree.

Haven't heard the other bands except Youth of Today.

[The Great Decay]

Quicksand is amazing.

I downloaded Slip a little while ago, but I have yet to listen to it.

[Tyler]

Might take a few listens to get into it but it is a truly great album.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

OH SURE WHEN I SAY IT YOU GUYS ARE MEANIES BUT WHEN TYLER SAYS IT ITS COOL


f u ty

[Tyler]

when the cool kids come i'll get made fun of

[The Great Decay]

OH SURE WHEN I SAY IT YOU GUYS ARE MEANIES BUT WHEN TYLER SAYS IT ITS COOL


f u ty

Hardly anyone has posted in the thread, I'm sure there will be some haters.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

Well then I'm with you

[One Step Beyond]

Shelter is horrible. I just checked them out last night. I love Civ right now though.

[Tyler]

What did you listen to?

[One Step Beyond]

I downloaded the album "Mantra" and only listened to about two tracks before switching i to something better. I wouldn't even call them hardcore, more like a numetal wannabe.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

I think I'm the only one here who likes Mantra.

[One Step Beyond]

So they have better stuff?

[Tyler]

Yeah, Mantra is their worst album (I haven't heard all of it though), they went nu-metal/poppy/ska for a couple albums. Try 'Quest for Certainty' or 'When 20 Summers Pass'.

[young, loud, and andrew]

Even though I love all those bands, I disagree with you completely. To each his own.

[young, loud, and andrew]

Also, it's sorta like comparing apples and oranges because they are not all hardcore bands.

If you said YoT > Judge or something like that, I'd agree with you.

[Tyler]

A while ago I would have smacked myself for saying this.

and I'm just comparing them cause CIV, Shelter and Quicksand are the bands YOT and GB basically evolved into.

[young, loud, and andrew]

A while ago I would have smacked myself for saying this.

and I'm just comparing them cause CIV, Shelter and Quicksand are the bands YOT and GB basically evolved into.

Yeah, fair enough.

Let's devote a thread to how Judge is overrated.

[Tyler]

Yeah, fair enough.

Let's devote a thread to how Judge is overrated.
FINALLY SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS

[young, loud, and andrew]

FINALLY SOMEONE WHO UNDERSTANDS

Judge is so f.ucking boring.

The best edge NYHC bands are YoT, Bold, and GB.

[One Step Beyond]

I've never heard Judge, but there was a time that you guys wouldn't shut up about them.

[young, loud, and andrew]

I've never heard Judge, but there was a time that you guys wouldn't shut up about them.

I'm was never part of that group.

[Tyler]

I think that was just shane...

[young, loud, and andrew]

One of the most underrated NYHC albums is Bold's Looking Back. I suggest you guys give it a listen.

[One Step Beyond]

Could've been. :p

[Tyler]

never could get into Bold...

[REINER]

GB > This thread

[cbmartinez]

Slip is an awesome album.

[young, loud, and andrew]

never could get into Bold...

SDLIF:LKJSDfkj

IM me now. You will pee yourself when you hear Looking Back.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

I've heard Looking Back, made me like them a little more, but not that much more.

I'm sorry Andrew....

[Tyler]

ahh i've been listening to 'Empathy' on repeat for like 20 minutes now. Maybe Mantra's not so bad.

[young, loud, and andrew]

I've heard Looking Back, made me like them a little more, but not that much more.

I'm sorry Andrew....

You're the only one, dude. I'm just sorry you don't see how good it is. The guitar work is amazing.

[NewKindofArmy03]

SOIA is probably my favorite NYHC band.

[Tyler]

Soooo much good hardcore has come out of NYC.

[young, loud, and andrew]

SOIA is probably my favorite NYHC band.

For me, it's:
GB
YoT
Bold
Absolution
Underdog
Antidote
Maximum Penalty.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

Underdog
Supertouch
GB
Killing Time
Burn
Agnostic Front

[young, loud, and andrew]

Underdog
Supertouch
GB
Killing Time
Burn
Agnostic Front

Very very nice list.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

Very very nice list.

Likewise

[Mute Print]

I downloaded Looking Back by Bold a few weeks ago. Awesome album.

Gorilla Biscuits and Youth of Today are great too.

I'm working on downloading stuff from Civ, Quicksand, and Shelter now.

[Forest_Fire]

GB is my favourite out of most bands mentioned here, YOT are alright. Underdog has some great songs, and some bad ones. They have one song, "Friends like them", I think, that is amazing.

I don't really like Quicksand at all.

[bryce_the_cat]

Yeah, fair enough.

Let's devote a thread to how Judge is overrated.
**** off

[40 oz 2 freedom]

yeeeeowza

[Mute Print]

I'm listening to Civ right now. I like them, but I like the Gorilla Biscuits a lot more.

[young, loud, and andrew]

**** off

haha

[shane italian]

Better Than A Thousand > Youth Of Today

Juss sayin

[BuddyBigsby]

Shelter weren't very good.

Quicksand ruled hard.

Civ are easily better than GB and YoT.

[BuddyBigsby]

OH SURE WHEN I SAY IT YOU GUYS ARE MEANIES BUT WHEN TYLER SAYS IT ITS COOL


f u ty

I for one have made the "Civ > GB" statement AND thread many times in the past.

[shane italian]

And Burn are obviously better than the aforementioned.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

Quicksand > Burn

GB > Burn

Civ > Burn

Burn > Most

[shane italian]

And cmon, someone else has to think BT1K > YOT.

[Tyler]

I do.

[40 oz 2 freedom]

And cmon, someone else has to think BT1K > YOT.

Of course

[Tyler]

Shelter put out so many different sounding records it'd be hard not to find one you like.

[shane italian]

Of courseI mean who wouldn't after they hear Ray actually sing a note.

[Tyler]

The Purpose The Passion and When 20 Summers Pass contain some of the most positive music ever created by man.

[One Step Beyond]

When 20 Summers Pass has completely changed my opinion of Shelter. This albums kicks.

[Tyler]

Damein likes it, it must be good.

[One Step Beyond]

Damein likes it, it must be good.
urrite