Edit button for comments... yay/nay?

[Jom]

Jeremy, could we please have an edit button for our comments, instead of just making another post below the initial post confirming that we screwed up?

Just a suggestion, I don't mean any harm by it :)

Also, is there going to be a function on Sputnik where we can see who voted for our reviews and what their votes were?

And finally, is there going to be a way where we can see where we have commented in reviews, similar to a "look for all posts by [user]" function on MX?

[Witty Username]

Also, is there going to be a function on Sputnik where we can see who voted for our reviews and what their votes were?
:lol: uhoh.

I agree with and support all of these suggestions, especially the edit one.

[Permanent Solution]

I'm for all of these suggestions.

[Damrod]

I strongly support the EDIT-Button idea.

The others are good ideas too, but the Edit-button is by far the most usefull out of those

[Jom]

I strongly support the EDIT-Button idea.

The others are good ideas too, but the Edit-button is by far the most usefull out of those

Well, the Edit button is the one that I want to see most, that's why it was in the title.

To be honest, the initial post had just that in it, but I ninja-edited the other two questions because they sprang to mind :)

[Iai]

Jeremy, could we please have an edit button for our comments, instead of just making another post below the initial post confirming that we screwed up?

Just a suggestion, I don't mean any harm by it :)

And finally, is there going to be a way where we can see where we have commented in reviews, similar to a "look for all posts by [user]" function on MX?
Great ideas.

Also, is there going to be a function on Sputnik where we can see who voted for our reviews and what their votes were?

Really bad idea.

[Jom]

Outside of retaliatory "no" votes, I don't see why that was a bad idea :(

But again, I would be more than happy if the edit button was implemented moreso than the other two ideas.

[sting-ray]

i think editting is always good

[Iai]

Outside of retaliatory "no" votes, I don't see why that was a bad idea :(
Circle jerking.

[Damrod]

Yeah, if one knows who voted negative on an review, the chance is great that a lot of people will seek out a review by the 'offender' and rep-- it as revenge

[Jom]

Ah, yeah, that makes more sense.

So, how about that edit feature?

[the2stranger]

/raises hand in favor of the edit button :wave:

with my sucky typing it would be great to have a edit button, so that I don't have to type another post to say/ change what I typed wrong in the first post :p

could we also have an 'advanced' button or something?
so we can easily quote, and fix Url's and all.

[Brain Toad]

I'm in favour of an edit button.

[Damrod]

I think we all are :)

[Dancin' Man]

Circle jerking.

Similar to the way Rep spiral out of hand with people signing their comments.

I would love to have an edit button available for comments though.