PDA

View Full Version : "My Friend"...PLEASE CRIT THIS


ChickenSalad
03-08-2005, 05:56 PM
I have posted this here before but nobody ever gave me a crit for it. Please guys, do a guy a favour, crit this. This is one of my most personal pieces, Id like some opinion on it. Crit for crit again (not that it ever seems to matter!)

“My Friend” by Mark

“Hello old friend” I smiled serenely,
He froze but does so with regularity,
Time and time again he looked the same,
“How are you?” I pleaded,
I hadn’t spoken to him in so long; we never get a chance to reflect
He didn’t answer; he just looked back at me with that stupid smile,
I smile like that!
“Fine I’ll start” I say, and I hesitate,
I know when I speak I’m all he sees, me and that which lays behind me,
He never blinks, well maybe he does, but he must do it,
When I blink,
I never catch him!
I tell him about my day, my week, my month of Sabbath- less Sundays,
He takes it in, such a great listener,
He is quiet though, he knows me too well,
He knows I did not come to speak to him about my day,
He can hear my banal banter and is unimpressed, he frowns,
When I frown, frowns like me too!
“Big boys don’t cry” I murmur, my friend never cries,
I tell him about the guys in school, that Alan was at it again,
Always nay saying, putting me down, down further,
“I don’t like Alan” bellow the silent tears that swell in my eyes,
Like liquid confessions,
My friend looks back at me with a look that I have seen before in photos,
I could swear he was ready to shed a tear for me,
The weight of seclusion lifted, my plight shared and felt,
I smile,
I tell you, he keeps copying me!
He smiles too!
“Cut that out” I laugh,
He mouths some silent comment; he never speaks to me really,
He doesn’t have to, he just listens,
I get up and leave, my soul cleansed of a sour quandary,
I’m happy,
I can reflect now, much like my friend does,

What a great friend the mirror is.

slpntrx5
03-08-2005, 06:14 PM
is this a song or what?

ChickenSalad
03-08-2005, 06:16 PM
Its a poem?

bisnotch
03-08-2005, 06:33 PM
i would just like to say that this was orgasmic. I have been trying to put something like this together. I have wanted to do something like that for so long and you did exactly what i wanted you bastard. As soon as i started reading i was hoping by the end you were going to be saying something about how you were looking in the mirror. The message is amazing. The topic is amazing. Although it doesn't quite rhyme too well, it doesnt need to because the subject matter cathces any slack the rest of the poem throws off. the title is iffy, but so what. the title doesnt make the song. I thought it was going to be some queer cliche song about a friend and all that drama drama bullsh1t that everybody writes about so much on these forums. Thank you for pleasing me because nobody can seem to these days. wana wana wanna. i hate my dad, i'm sick of fads. i'll take this knife, and end my life. i'm sick of that horsesh1t. I can't really crit this cuz i dont think anything is wrong with it. 9.5/10. Keep going man. you rock. thanks for your crit by the way.

IOWNU200
03-08-2005, 06:38 PM
oh man, that was nice. Your message you put out there was nice. The end wwas quite moving, it speaks loudly. This works well as a poem, almost even prose-like, but whatever it is, it was well written. You brought your concept out really well. Deffinately powerful stuff man, keep writing, I'll be looking for your stuff in the future.

Daven
03-08-2005, 06:41 PM
i thought it was s ong, not a school play lol

good work dude, keep on doing it...

8/10

Corupt2057
03-09-2005, 08:49 AM
now your user title is starting to come through, this was good I'm impressed by far out of all your stuff this has the best wording, although partly that's easier to do in a story, however good job man I really felt this was a good read

Biancazzurri
03-09-2005, 09:12 AM
I don't understand how this hasn't bben critisized properly. This reminds me of some classic poetry or the 20the century classics attitude.. hope you understand what I mean. The surprise at the end is brilliant, though you give clues all the way till the end but /I didn't think about it that way. You made my hour better. Kepp going

TrentStevens
03-09-2005, 09:12 AM
thats prety personal man