Nfl-Rookie of the year?

[acousto77]

who do you guys reckon will get it?

[sockmonkey]

At the moment, Ben Rothelisberger easily.

yea i go with ben

[Nuke Broadcast]

thats the only rookie i can think of at the moment.

[KarateExplosion]

Unless Roy Williams can play like Jerry Rice these next 8 weeks, Big Ben will easily get it.

[MattSharpIsCool]

Ya, Roethlisberger will probably get it.

Roy Williams is another good canidate.

So is Meldewe Moore. He wont get much consideration, but 600 yards in 4 games is not bad at all.

[acousto77]

Ya, Roethlisberger will probably get it.

Roy Williams is another good canidate.

So is Meldewe Moore. He wont get much consideration, but 600 yards in 4 games is not bad at all.
its not not bad, its f-in amazing

[ThePatient]

its not not bad, its f-in amazing
Indeed. But my vote would goto Roy Williams. That catch he made Week 1 made me go :amaze: .

[acousto77]

thing is, the majority of the rookies, especially offensive first rounders, are not starting and not given a chance.

fight for defensive rookie of the year is- jonathan vilma vs. d.j williams

[MattSharpIsCool]

I thought Larry Fitzgerald would have probably the best shot, but then Boldin went down, and Fitz has been ok, but not great.

[Illmatic]

Big Ben is the offensive rookie of the year fairly easily.

Defensive rookie of the year, I have no idea.

[Red Stripe]

Roethlisberger, he brought pitt. from nothing last year, to tied for first in the AFC

If John Vilma plays the rest of the year he could get defensive

[Against Miik!]

Winslow was looking promising until he went down. That was unfortunate.

[Syncratic]

Ben Roethlisberger, hands down...PITTSBURGH ROCKS!

[3074326]

I don't know how Roethlisberger can't get it.

I don't know about defensive.

[YDload]

Go ROFLsberger! Seriously, I am a Steelers fan through and through (unless they suck), so this guy's a big deal!

[Simple Man]

Yeah Definitly Roethlisberger..

[PumaPride77]

yeah go mewelde moore. it's pretty cool that he was like 4th string running back, then all of the sudden he comes up and outruns the starting runningback. if he keeps it up, he'll have a good chance, but he has a concussion right now so i dunno.

[pikester]

If Roy Williams didn't get injured he'd be up there with Ben.

Also Winslow was doing pretty good.

[hey, you're not cory!]

roethlisberger


or philip rivers from sand diego :rolleyes:

[Puma]

Roethlisberger will probably get it. And he deserves it most. I also think Roy Williams has been good, but Roethlisberger has led Pitt to victories over NE and Philly, so I think he has to be the favorite.

[Rockstar GSR]

The rookie of the year has to be Ben Rothlisberger. He has led his team to victorys over the two best teams in the NFL and has made the Steelers a Very Dangerous team. I'm a cincinnati fan, and I don't want to see them play the Steelers again, though i know they have to. The bengals will win 6 of the last 8 games this year... they are starting to get it together.

[4_degrees]

Big Ben.