Tell the Mods

[sweboy]

Yeah... don't... don't do that anymore. I'm kind of lenient but don't take advantage of it, or else I'll have to be a jerk. Too much spam makes the discussion thread lame.

The discussion thread, lame? It's not possible. Am I right? Am I right? Right? Am I right? In the house, am I right? Am I right?

[Jas]

*amirite

Gawd, Swe, can't you understand simple grammar?! :p

[sweboy]

*amirite

Gawd, Swe, can't you understand simple grammar?! :p
http://stfu.se

[PDWAB]

I haven't experienced any problems with it, and I'm running cable internet which is slower than Vince's.


Yeah the thread doesn't bug me at all, and I'm on Windows 98 for Chrissake.

[RazorsInTheNight]

Albert can you close some of the PP top 75 threads soon, I dont really mind do as you see fit its just its a bit annoying having so many threads just for voting...

[Dead Star]

Joel, can you close the New Officiail Blink 182 Thread

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=327692

I think thats it

[Virus278]

oh, i guess u guys really don't like it - i'm just saying that was the main reason i came to this forum

[Dead Star]

Its because Joel already closed one today, I dont see much point in opening another.

[PDWAB]

Eh, I'm going to try something. If it works then I can close it without people getting mad.

[The_Red_Death]

Ban this dumbass:

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7494198&postcount=34

For two reasons: One, for bumping an old-*** thread, and two, just for being an idiot.

Or just close the thread.

[Agent_Orange]

Has anyone been doing a news thread since I left? Or did ya'll decide not to have one? I was just thinking about doing one since I havn't the last month or so.

[Rancid Dan]

Sticky my FA please

[Kif]

I might start doing news again daily. I used to do it a lot more than I do now, along with my news buddy El Hefe :(

Oh Joel. I have a little request. Could you remake the Archive thread and maybe make it more public (As in, not have the Archive thread hidden in the Rules?). The Archive we currently have hasn't been updated in ages, and there are a lot of threads which need to go in there I think (The top 75 albums, Vince's info about making band threads, the Jukebox can as can the Recommendations).

Just an idea, since it's hard to dig around for important threads on MX that's to it's super-amazingly-accurate search function...

[ColdFire]

I think that if the Discussion thread is slow to upload b/c it is so big it should either be closed and restarted or closed and not restarted at all.

[PDWAB]

I might start doing news again daily. I used to do it a lot more than I do now, along with my news buddy El Hefe :(

Oh Joel. I have a little request. Could you remake the Archive thread and maybe make it more public (As in, not have the Archive thread hidden in the Rules?). The Archive we currently have hasn't been updated in ages, and there are a lot of threads which need to go in there I think (The top 75 albums, Vince's info about making band threads, the Jukebox can as can the Recommendations).

Just an idea, since it's hard to dig around for important threads on MX that's to it's super-amazingly-accurate search function...


Eh, I would rather just do away with the archive altogether, there isn't much in there that I think we actually need. I have all the FA's in the rules thread already, and it'd be easier to just make a "Important Links" post then have another thread and sticky.


I'm open to news threads as long as there is participation. I'm not too wild about news threads with no news in them.

[Agent_Orange]

Yeah that was always a problem. But if we can get a few people togather to work on finding good news then it wouldn't be so bad. I would be willing to help out if thats what you guys want to do. I love doing the news threads.

[Permanent Solution]

I think you should sticky the News thread, no?

[Rancid Dan]

Should i put my FA in Punk aswell ?

[albert_bass]

Please a mod unsticky my 3rd round polls thread and change the name of the threads A and B. I put 3rd round in A and it should be 4th round, and it B it says 4rd round... I suck, yeah I know.


And sticky the 4th round polls index please. It says 3rd round again so change the name please.

Sorry...

[Untitled]

Can you change them all to 4th, from 4rd too someone..

No offence albert :thumb:

[Virus278]

Hey, can u please change the name of "The New OFFICIAL Blink 182 Thread" to "The OFFICIAL Blink 182 Thread II" - i tried to by editing my first post but when your'e viewing the name of the thread from the forum itself it still says "The New OFFICIAL Blink 182 Thread."

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?userid=171329

ban for bumping a thread from august

[Rancid Dan]

Yeah, the discussion thread is slow loading for me

[sketchyjoe]

Advertising: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=330072

[Permanent Solution]

ATTN: Joel

3000 pages my ***

:mad:

[Permanent Solution]

/me reports you for spamming the hell out of your own community thread

[PDWAB]

Go to hell!

[albert_bass]

Again please Joel or someone sticky the round 5 poll index when it's done and unsticky the last one.

[sting-ray]

poll city :cool:

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Can a mod delete all the posts in the NEW forced listening thread that aren't reviews? It isn't even a page it yet and and it's f'ucked up because people don't understand what they're doing

[Rancid Dan]

Well, lets have more people contributing !

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Delete the posts you've made that aren't reviwes (Kif and anyone else to), post a song i want to review and i'll do it. I was gonna do your pennywise one but didn't have time last night

[Rancid Dan]

If someone asks a question, i'm not going to ignore it.

I'll delete my posts then.

[Rancid Dan]

A mod needs to delete them all, it looks like people are taking to each other etc...

[sting-ray]

it'll take a while... i'm working right now so i may or may not get to it later.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Aren't you supposed to do songs you've never heard before?
There's not much point otherwise is there?

Do what you want. I'm not going to review bands i've heard and know absolute sh!te so i decided to do one i like and make a proper review of it.

Yeah, he doesn't have AIM i don't think.

Right, we need to delete our posts now.

ask me for my msn if you want it and i'll give it to you, it's just i don't want to many people on there i don't want.

I posted this hear as the forced listening is full of spam as it is. Do what Dan said, DELETE YOUR POSTS

[Rancid Dan]

I don't have MSN, sorry...

[sketchyjoe]

Close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=332008

It'll just lead to flaming and arguments.

[sketchyjoe]

I was right.

[albert_bass]

Hey mods, sticky the last poll please. And to all you guys who come to this thread: I guess it's about time you do your reviews for the list.

[Permanent Solution]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7635844#post7635844
Joel, ban everyone after the non-mod close, it'll be funny.

[RazorsInTheNight]

Yes joel, if people aren't gonna respect my athority, me having some 200+ posts I demand respect...

[Permanent Solution]

Remember now Joel, this is important...everyone posting after the close should be banned.

[nirvana_drummer's back]

in the pit someone made a spam thread for nirvana. i think its still on the first page.

[El_Shiznit]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7635844#post7635844
Joel, ban everyone after the non-mod close, it'll be funny.
Just making sure this is seen and enforced.



Where are you Joel?!?!?
I vote me for new pop-punk mod. ;)

[Rancid Dan]

Sticky me FA plz

[chumpradio]

Joel, great modding in the Simple Plan thread.
Carry on being strict towards the members who insult bands. And it's good that you banned people who post quite a bit as well, showing that you aren't biased.

[chirman_of_the_bored_1]

Joel, great modding in the Simple Plan thread.
Carry on being strict towards the members who insult bands. And it's good that you banned people who post quite a bit as well, showing that you aren't biased.


how long were we banned?

nevermind i looked-2 days,god i'm not posting in pop punk anymore.harsh as fuc'k :lol:

[Gnarmageddon]

how long were we banned?

nevermind i looked-2 days,god i'm not posting in pop punk anymore.harsh as fuc'k :lol:

It's not harsh. You were just being an idiot.

[RazorsInTheNight]

Joel, great modding in the Simple Plan thread.
Carry on being strict towards the members who insult bands. And it's good that you banned people who post quite a bit as well, showing that you aren't biased.

Read over the page. Joel knows im great ;)

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

People need to get a grip in the forced listening thread. It doesn't need to be continuosly bumped, and when people do reviews they can delete their dibs so we don't have one review and a pile of wank on each page

[Kif]

People need to get a grip in the forced listening thread. It doesn't need to be continuosly bumped, and when people do reviews they can delete their dibs so we don't have one review and a pile of wank on each page
Joel cleans it out a little as far as I am concerned, but yeah I'm gonna make an effort to remember to clean out my posts in there which aren't relevent

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Yeah i understand that. It's just that at the moment there's discussions and dibs all over the page before reviews. There's no need for dibs to be left on a page either, the only thing that's importnat in there are the reviews.

[Oz Rembrandt]

Hey Joel (or any other MOD), has Lilly (poprocksandcoke) been banned? I've been talking to her on msn, and she says she cant sign in!
Cheers guys

[Rancid Dan]

Yeah, because she bashed Simple Plan in that thread

[narcotictendencies]

WHAT?!

excuse me, in my defence, I wasn't the only one bashing Simple Plan, everyone was saying they sucked, my comment was pretty mild.


:angry:

[Rancid Dan]

I know, everyone got banned.

[Permanent Solution]

Ok...so my brainstorming has led to this as an idea...I'd like feedback before doing it though, because it will involve everyone so if there's no interest it won't work. I stole it from R&M but I think it would be neat here too, and that would be to have a bi-weekly featured genre, where we look at the evolution of a genre, list some bands, upload some songs, and spread out people's tastes. It could be as specific as you want it as long as you have like 3 bands included and some good info. If you don't like it I'll come up with something different though...

[Rancid Dan]

Yeah, cool.

I was thinking of doing a 'Legends of pop-punk' competition, where you all nominate for the people who you think should be in their and we vote for the most influential and important people in the genre ?
Kinda Like the top 75 albums but obviously not too similair.

[Kif]

To be honest, I don't really see a point in the "Featured genre" business. I think that if you want to research more about a particular style, you should just go the forum for that style and hang around there for a while, picking up on some good bands

[Permanent Solution]

So...second idea: Composition Competition? I don't know how many people can record judging from the problems we've had with the forum band, but would there be an interest in trying it out at least?

[Rancid Dan]

People would be too lazy to do it, it would be a good idea though.

[Kif]

So...second idea: Composition Competition? I don't know how many people can record judging from the problems we've had with the forum band, but would there be an interest in trying it out at least?
Yeah, Dan's right. Effort in this forum is a rarity

I was thinking of doing another Battle Of The Pop-Punk Bands, but it's kinda early for that I think

[Rancid Dan]

Should I do mine then ?

[Permanent Solution]

Well see, I like composition myself because I have no band but still can participate. It's too bad effort is so rare, but if I don't come up with something better I might just try it anyways :-/

[Permanent Solution]

Should I do mine then ?
I'd wait till the top 75 is totally done and listed, since the reviews are still needing to be done and such, but maybe start it in 2-4 weeks, depending on when the list is done. I'm still in preference of a profile over a competition on it though.

[Rancid Dan]

The Competition is over now.

[Permanent Solution]

The reviews aren't all done yet and the list isn't posted yet. It'd be wrong to shift attention to something new without finishing the other thing.

[Rancid Dan]

Ok, sorry.

[chips88]

Yeah, cool.

I was thinking of doing a 'Legends of pop-punk' competition, where you all nominate for the people who you think should be in their and we vote for the most influential and important people in the genre ?
Kinda Like the top 75 albums but obviously not too similair.

I tried that before, but it was more of just alist. Everyone's just gonna pick someone from Green Day or Blink-182, so I don't see a point.

[Rancid Dan]

Ok, whatever.

[Permanent Solution]

I tried that before, but it was more of just alist. Everyone's just gonna pick someone from Green Day or Blink-182, so I don't see a point.
Well to be honest they have been very influential in the scene. In the same way people list Metallica in metal influences even though they're nowhere near the best at what they did. The bands that make the music mainstream still have tons of influence even if they weren't first, or best at it.

[Gnarmageddon]

Stupid post:
http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7655634&postcount=3

User Profile:
http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?u=172976

[chips88]

Well to be honest they have been very influential in the scene. In the same way people list Metallica in metal influences even though they're nowhere near the best at what they did. The bands that make the music mainstream still have tons of influence even if they weren't first, or best at it.

I didn't say that they didn't deserve it, even if I was thinking it, it's just we all know it will be someone from those bands, so why even go through with it?

[Permanent Solution]

I didn't say that they didn't deserve it, even if I was thinking it, it's just we all know it will be someone from those bands, so why even go through with it?
That's why I'm in favor of profiles instead of a competition :)

[RazorsInTheNight]

That's why I'm in favor of profiles instead of a competition :)

I was thinking of doing a melodic hardcore profile, but since you ask I was thinking of doing a general jazz profile...

[PDWAB]

I'm not sure what you guys are talking about, but whatever. My internet access will be limited this week, so I dunno how often I'll be able to come on. Go bug the other mods if you need anything.

[RazorsInTheNight]

If your alive joel close the PPOTM nominations thread, or just let it fade into obscurity either way im fine...

[Rancid Dan]

I think he's dead...

[sting-ray]

i shall close it

/moment of brilliance

[RazorsInTheNight]

Many thanks mr mod

[sting-ray]

anytime..

[Gnarmageddon]

I'm done with the NOFX FA. Let me know when you want it posted. :thumb:

[sting-ray]

haha, is there like a schedule or anything ? If its time for the other one to come down then go for it right away.. i'll give you the benefit of the doubt.

[Permanent Solution]

The current one has been up 4 days, leave it up at least a week me thinks.

[Gnarmageddon]

I was planning on posting it Saturday.

I was just wondering if I should wait longer.

[sting-ray]

that's fine i guess.. post it saturday and we can keep both up for a day or two

[Gnarmageddon]

I can wait longer, it's no big deal. I guess it depends on how much discussion Dan's Alk3 one has.

[sting-ray]

so then anytime from saturday on would be good

[Gnarmageddon]

Ok.

[RazorsInTheNight]

My Rise Against F.A will be teh secks

/probably wont finish it till next year

[Rancid Dan]

My two FA's this month have been ace :cool:

[metty16]

My two FA's this month have been ace :cool:

Agreed, but why are the stickied?

[Gnarmageddon]

Agreed, but why are the stickied?

So people will see them and so they don't go to the second page.

[sting-ray]

correct

[Gnarmageddon]

If a mod could sticky this (http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7728352#post7728352), it would be greatly appreciated. :D

[Rancid Dan]

Could someone actually put my Alk3 one on the FA page ?

[PDWAB]

It is...?

[Rancid Dan]

Well, it wasn't untill very recently

[PDWAB]

I put it in as soon as I unstickied it.

[sweboy]

Alright... *looks at own shoes* Uhm... *looks at ceiling* ...

[Rancid Dan]

I put it in as soon as I unstickied it.

Ok, sorry.

I thought you put it in the list of FA's, when it's made.

[Agent_Orange]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?u=166347

this guy should be banned. For the post in the news thread.

Also I thought there was a rule for spamming in the news thread. When I used to do it it was for news only comments was not allowed. Can we do anything about that or have we just let that one slip?

[PDWAB]

I'm letting it go, seeing as Kif is has that index in the first post now.

[Agent_Orange]

okay cool

[chumpradio]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showpost.php?p=7819836&postcount=48

He is dissing a band in their own thread.

[Agent_Orange]

This guy should be banned. scentless.apprentice for the post in the Green Day thread. Can't miss it it's huge.

That BFS thread should be closed to. No one likes them whats the deal?

[Oz Rembrandt]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?userid=172388

Permenant ban I suggest :thumb:

[sting-ray]

he's done

[Rancid Dan]

Good Good

[Agent_Orange]

Yay! the idiot is gone.

[sweboy]

There was an idiot in my forum? I'm shocked!

[sting-ray]

:eek:

[Gnarmageddon]

Someone please ban the cunt in my NOFX FA thread.

[Brain Toad]

I feel sorry for you guys, he was doing some dumb s'hit in punk too. I'd ban him if I could, but I reported him in the mod forum.

[10571z]

ban this guy came in to insult people wierd

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=7892704&posted=1#post7892704

[RazorsInTheNight]

I feel sorry for you guys, he was doing some dumb s'hit in punk too. I'd ban him if I could, but I reported him in the mod forum.

nick for super.

[GoM]

And so I said..

who the hell is everybody?

[RazorsInTheNight]

And so I said..

who the hell is everybody?

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=330628&page=221&pp=25

Your loved :cool:

[GoM]

Kick. ***. I don't know who the devil you are, but hey, who's counting :thumb:

[sweboy]

It's the GoMizzle, straight up in the hizzle!

[Luxor]

Oh fo sho

[sting-ray]

Kick. ***. I don't know who the devil you are, but hey, who's counting :thumb:


haha you'd be surprised at the lovers you have since you left :-/

[RazorsInTheNight]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=344318
http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=344324

Close, you secksy mods

[atreyu_rocks_perth]

i am the starter of the official used thread.. could i please get it closed.
thank you

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=345291

close and ban. The f'ucking official thread is only 1 below it

[Rancid Dan]

And why did people carry on posting in the thread ?

[Oz Rembrandt]

Because we like to flame the n00bs...

:upset:

[Rancid Dan]

Yes, but you should have ignored it.

[RazorsInTheNight]

And why did people carry on posting in the thread ?

Joel only bans people after I close it, nothing against you :cool:

[StruckEverywhere]

Get a girlfriend Adam.

[El_Shiznit]

Get a girlfriend Adam.
Ban this guy for breaking edge.^

[StruckEverywhere]

Every chance you get, eh Dustin?











































I hate you. And I did not break edge.

[El_Shiznit]

I hate you. And I did not break edge.
Last time we spoke, the only thing you said to me was that you love me.

And you haven't broke edge.......... YET. Better to ban in advance since you are planning on it.

My spam stops........... HERE.

[StruckEverywhere]

Ah good times, anyway, you're the one that had a sip of the forbidden juice. And I am NOT planning on it.

[RazorsInTheNight]

Get a girlfriend Adam.

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: You make me roll on the floor laughing sam :amaze:

Every chance you get, eh Dustin? I hate you. And I did not break edge.

You're all talk edge breaker, me and Dustin can see right through you

[StruckEverywhere]

You signed a pact with the devil, all hope is lost for you my friend.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close, delete, whatever. just do it quick

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=345407

[Gnarmageddon]

My NOFX FA can be un-stickied now, if someone wants to do it. No one really posts in it anymore.

And are the PPOTM nominations going to start soon?

[cbmartinez]

Yeah, I'll do it. I'd like to introduce that nominating procedure I was talking about.

[Gnarmageddon]

Care to fill me in?

[cbmartinez]

When you nominate someone, you have to write two or three sentences on why you think they were a helpful member that month.

[Gnarmageddon]

Oh. Cool.

[RazorsInTheNight]

When you nominate someone, you have to write two or three sentences on why you think they were a helpful member that month.

Thats a good idea, I thought of doing that as well...

/quickly prepares to post a F.A ;)

[Gnarmageddon]

w00t. A new FA.

And that's a good idea for the PPOTM nominations, but I can really only think of a few people that I could name things that they have done.

[Kif]

We need to bring back the news thread, but I'd like to do it differently this time

Instead of doing it in months, we just have a thread for it all. Why do we need it in months anyway? If you wanna do it in months so it's easier to put in the Archive, that's fine by me

Also, I think we should have dedicated newsposters who post news everyday or whatever, kinda like an e-zine for the forum. I think this way, people will be able to read news daily and properly. I'm not sure how this will work at the moment, that's why I'm putting it here for "discussion" with the mods.

But anyway, that's my idea. I personally love those threads, but I feel they don't get the recognition they deserve.

[Untitled]

Im liking Kif's Idea. Different people should watch out for news on Different bands. Id like to do that.

[Dead Star]

I would be up for helping with that.

[Rancid Dan]

yup

[jonesi1992]

never posted in here before,
close the 'this is cool....' thread someone

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=346934

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

advertising: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=346934

EDIT: if you want it closed, why did you keep posting in it?

[jonesi1992]

so there is no temptation

[Kif]

OK, it's sone gonna be June so I want the news thread up soon. I'm obviously going to be posting news in it, I'd like about 1-2 other newsposters who can

Post news daily/around a schedule if we sort one out
Not just post old news/news which has already been posted that day

Like I said, I'd like to discuss this with Joel, but since he's just disappeared off the face of the planet, I don't know what to do

[cobert]

If like kifs idea about different bands. I never understodd why we did it in seperate months either, especially when some months didnt start until midway through the month.

I got dibs on Coheed and Cambria.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=347624

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8089927&posted=1#post8089927

are there any mods in this forum at all?

[Rancid Dan]

I know, it's a joke

[PDWAB]

Sorry. :-/

I like that news thread Idea, Kif. I'm just going to re-name the one up now and you can edit your post with whatever you want changed.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8149764#post8149764

[Oz Rembrandt]

What Twat said

[Kif]

Coming soon to a thread near you; Fall Out Boy: The FA!

Just gotta upload the last few songs, then I'll post it up for all to adore and gaze and in some cases, wet their pants a little, over

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

^^ that review is very good, very well done

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=348059

[felch182]

^^ that review is very good, very well done

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=348059
your like a little girl, running away from the heat :thumb:

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

your like a little girl, running away from the heat :thumb:

hahaha what does that even mean? F'uck me, go back to the Blink182 thread

[Kif]

your like a little girl, running away from the heat :thumb:
If I was a mod, you'd be banned by now

You are not only starting fights with other members in thread, but you come in here to do it as well, a place which is for serious talk to the mods.

Just save yourself the trouble of the forums, go to the pit and post a link to ******* so you can make this forum a better place

[felch182]

If I was a mod, you'd be banned by now

You are not only starting fights with other members in thread, but you come in here to do it as well, a place which is for serious talk to the mods.

Just save yourself the trouble of the forums, go to the pit and post a link to ******* so you can make this forum a better place
i did not start the fight, i am only defending myself. Is he allowed to abuse and get away with it is he.

[Kif]

i did not start the fight, i am only defending myself. Is he allowed to abuse and get away with it is he.
You're the one who is saying he gets raped by his dad, has no missus and stuff like that. Granted, Twat did start it by telling you to **** off, but do you know how sad it is to hear you respond?

[felch182]

You're the one who is saying he gets raped by his dad, has no missus and stuff like that. Granted, Twat did start it by telling you to **** off, but do you know how sad it is to hear you respond?
dude go through the whole argument, from the start. And see who got personal first, then respond.

[Kif]

dude go through the whole argument, from the start. And see who got personal first, then respond.
OK, you thought you'd be funny (Or at least try to be) and vote for yourself. Twat then flamed you for doing so, then you again thought you'd be funny and responded to him. Twat then started being cocky and agreed with you, and you called him hxc. Then Twat called told you to **** off, and you again tried to be clever and acted as if you didn't care

It's not that I don't agree with you that he started it first, but you had to try and act like everyone wants you to. Well, that's how you think everyone wants you to act. The truth is that after this, no one will even glance your posts. They will see you as another desperate wannabe trying to fit into the forums so hard

My point is that you pretty much made him start the argument, and then you continued it.

[felch182]

haha, dude if you took me voting for myself serious you are one of two things, a- a loser with no life, and actually takes that ppotm crap seriously, or b- a loser

[Kif]

Stop trying to post like the forum idiot and use your head for a change. It isn't that I took it seriously, it's that you don't take your posts seriously. All of them have to be a joke, and it's tired now

In other words, stop posting like a complete tool and get some sense before you hit the "Post Reply" button

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

haha, dude if you took me voting for myself serious you are one of two things, a- a loser with no life, and actually takes that ppotm crap seriously, or b- a loser

voting for yourself indicated that you only come on the forums to try and be funny and you don't actually want to talk about music, you just have nothing better to do.

Now stop spamming up this thread as well and go and hide away in the blink thread. You're boring go away

[Gnarmageddon]

My NOFX FA needs to be un-stickied and Kif's FOB one needs to be stickied.

[metty16]

should I make my Rancid thread become an official thread?

[El_Shiznit]

No.

[metty16]

:upset:

[El_Shiznit]

He's done enough in my opinion to deserve a ban.
http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/member.php?userid=168118



And close the thread while you're at it.
http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=351027

[sweboy]

Chop chop!

[Blink_182_rocks]

Why are you all argueing about threads and pathetic stuff. This site is just for talkin about music!

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

because if people could get away with all the threads they could there'd be no chance to talk about music as it would be full of sh!te threads.

And your username is terrible by the way

[Ganondorf]

The forum is fine as it is. If you wanna talk about music, start a new thread or post in an existing one. No one's forcing you to read non-music related threads. It's not as if there's an excess of off-topic threads for them to be considered a problem or anything.

[metty16]

exactly

[Stew_Blink]

I disagree. If the thread is for example an Iron Maiden thread, you shouldn't be talking about your grandmother's sister's cousin's shirt that has bananas that are wearing ties on it...I don't care if it's in the pit, but I don't think you should be posting stuff that has nothing to do with the thread, in that thread.

[Untitled]

Blink182 thread needs closing, cleaning, something.

[metty16]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8213582#post8213582

this thread is so off topic it's rediculous. there's no point in it being around anymore

[Stew_Blink]

I agree with both of those, especially the Blink thread. They've all become morons in there..close it or clean it, or at least do something to it. There's no blink new's right now anyways, so I think it would probably be better off being closed.

[10571z]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8214140#post8214140


band felch 182, 6 spam posts in a row.
ok 2 is alrite 3 is pushing it 4 is riduclas 5 is just out of this world but 6 its recking the thread.

[metty16]

band felch is really annoying

[metty16]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=350712&page=3

this thread is going nowhere

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

^^yeah

run its course: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=350712

[Stew_Blink]

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8214140#post8214140


band felch 182, 6 spam posts in a row.
ok 2 is alrite 3 is pushing it 4 is riduclas 5 is just out of this world but 6 its recking the thread.
Yeah, BAN felch 182, don't band him..
He's being rather stupid, I say not a permanent ban, but something he will notice.

[10571z]

lol that was pretty poor spelling by me right there.

[vote me]

band felch is really annoying
he has :thumb:

[PDWAB]

I gave him a tenner.

[MattSharpIsCool]

Why should the Blink 182 thread be closed? There's nothing wrong with it.

[slug]

Why should the Blink 182 thread be closed? There's nothing wrong with it.
:confused:

[Kif]

There is nothing wrong with the Blink-182 thread. The fact is that Blink-182 aren't doing anything interesting at the moment. They aren't touring, they aren't recording, they aren't advertising. This means that it's just being spammed by worthless arguments like "Who is the better drummer; Tré from Green Day or Travis from Blink-182?".

Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining. I don't want those illterate retards in the Discussion thread. But still, it's a band thread, so maybe they should just stop using the thread until they have some new Blink news to talk about

[MattSharpIsCool]

I dont know. A lot of the posters in that thread, only post in that thread and nowhere else. So I kind of see it as sort of a discussion thread for them. That way, they stay out of the normal open thread, and it gives that thread a reason to stay open. The spam in there isnt horrible...the green day thread is nothing but a pure spam thread anymore, and theres no talk of closing that. So eh, I think it should stay open.

[Dead Star]

I would have to argue that quite a lot of the Green Day thread isnt spam, and it isnt constant, like the Blink 182 thread.

[Kif]

In the end, Green Day are still around promoting and touring and there is a lot to talk about that band. You don't see old threads about bands like Taking Back Sunday or Rancid getting bumped everyday purely for spam, do you? No, because those bands aren't doing anything at the moment

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

I know what Kif means, but to be honest i'd prefer it if the people who post in the Blink182 thread stayed in the Blink182 thread. Unless by closing it they would leave, i'm all for that

[jcxstargazer]

In a way, I'd like to see the randomness stopped, but then again i'd rather have it in those threads than people making more threads to say it. There may be spamming, but if you dont want to see it, then dont open the thread - its simple

[Kif]

I know what Kif means, but to be honest i'd prefer it if the people who post in the Blink182 thread stayed in the Blink182 thread. Unless by closing it they would leave, i'm all for that
To be fair, this isn't the only place they can talk about this band. The official websites has a "forum" kinda thing, and there are plenty of fansites where they can talk to other huge fans of the band

But unless we get some kind of topic going on, they are just going to keep spamming the thread. Without a topic, post quality decreses more and more, and that's not good

[MattSharpIsCool]

I'm not trying to start a fight or anything, but I look at the last couple pages of the green day thread and all I see is talk about wallpapers for a computer. And there is a lot of talk about blink in their thread, you act like all the thread is is spam.

There is a "green day community" is there not? billiejoe84, Oz Rembrant, poprocksandcoke, Mike Dirnt 310, Untitled...I'm sure I'm missing some. That little group hangs out in the green day thread and talks about their day and concerts they've been to and stuff like that. That is spam, but I dont see anything wrong with it.

All I'm saying is that people will continue wanting to talk about blink, and if you close the thread, we're just gonna have 20 threads on the first two pages about "omgz blink iz brakd upp?!?!?" or "u r such pozrs 4 likng blink"

[Oz Rembrandt]

Yeah, over at the Green Day forum, we get off topic sometimes, but its not harming anyone, and it usually comes back round to the band eventually. I can't comment on the Blink thread, I don't go in there.

[PDWAB]

I'm going to leave the Blink thread open. Just cuz a band isn't doing anything doesn't mean you can't talk about them. Closing the thread would bug a lot of people and right now leaving it open doesn't seem to be really bugging anybody.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=332001

i think every acoustic song ever has been mentioned and it's just going round in circles now

[cobert]

I would have to argue that quite a lot of the Green Day thread isnt spam, and it isnt constant, like the Blink 182 thread.

I think you have no clue what youre talking about. There almost always blink talk in that thread, the green day thread is more or less a seperate discussion thread for like, 5 people, where every so often green day pops up. And you cant say "their not around, the threads pointless." Go tell that to everyone in the pink floyd thread. Good call, joel, keep it open.

Also, KIF: Theres really only 2 illiterate retards in the blink thread, one of them is ban'd.

Oh yeah....

http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8261093

Close dat shiii

[Red Ink]

I'm going to leave the Blink thread open. Just cuz a band isn't doing anything doesn't mean you can't talk about them. Closing the thread would bug a lot of people and right now leaving it open doesn't seem to be really bugging anybody.

I would just close both the Blink and Greenday threads and start fresh ones. Both of those threads are nothing but pointless spam at this point and most of the things being discussed are just repeat discussions of things that have been addressed several pages back. It's a waste of space.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=353459

[Oz Rembrandt]

Yeah, it'll just be a spam/flame thread

not that I helped :upset:

[Kif]

close: http://www.musicianforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=353459
Why? It's a thread asking your opinion on a band that is closest to pop-punk, I don't see a problem with it?

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

GC aren't even close to pop-punk. They are a pop band who try to promote a tough guy image and have no place in this forum. It's already become spam

[Ganondorf]

It's because they're a succesful band, and as we all know

success = teh poseur!1!!

:rolleyes:

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

It's because they're a succesful band, and as we all know

success = teh poseur!1!!

:rolleyes:

don't f'ucking start you loser. This thread is serious, don't start filling it with your absolute crap

[Kif]

Who's fault is that? The threadstarters? No, it's everyone else thinking that a new guy posting a thread about Good Charlotte is grounds for both flaming and hijacking a thread. In the end, it's a thread about a band which are more closer to pop-punk than metal, alt and indie, punk and jazz.

[Ganondorf]

don't f'ucking start you loser. This thread is serious, don't start filling it with your absolute crap

:lol: Someone's had a bad day.

Anyway, most of us know GC isn't pop-punk, but it's pretty close to it.

It's power-pop kind of, and PDWAB said in the rules thread that that genre is to be discussed here......so why don't you stop filling this thread with your elitist crap?

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Trust me, look at what this guy has done.

1) he has made repeated bad thread

2) he has put threads into the wrong forums e.g. GC in pop-punk and Sum 41 in punk

3) Their posts are unintelligent, show no thought and don't use grammar.

4) they've posted nonsence in threads where they don't understand what's going on

:lol: Someone's had a bad day.

Anyway, most of us know GC isn't pop-punk, but it's pretty close to it.

It's power-pop kind of, and PDWAB said in the rules thread that that genre is to be discussed here......so why don't you stop filling this thread with your elitist crap?

You are one of the reasons why this forum has arguments. any suggestion of someone disagreeing with you comes back as 'elitism' or 'blink182 r teh secks'.

They are not pop-rock or pop-punk therefore have no place in the forum. You would not have bothered with this if your could just get your head out from Kif's a'ss.

Now let it go

[Ganondorf]

GC belongs here, retard.

[Kif]

Trust me, look at what this guy has done.

1) he has made repeated bad thread

2) he has put threads into the wrong forums e.g. GC in pop-punk and Sum 41 in punk

3) Their posts are unintelligent, show no thought and don't use grammar.

4) they've posted nonsence in threads where they don't understand what's going on
That still doesn't give people the right to piss all over his threads though. It's a thread about a pop-punk band (That's right I said it), get your head out of your arse and stop being suck a prick about it

I'm not in the mood for your "**** your opinion" ****

[Ganondorf]

Power Pop: This gets a little fuzzy, but most people in general think of power pop as bands like Good Charlotte and Simple Plan, bands that have taken the pop influence even further even in pop-punk.

Recommended Bands: Good Charlotte, Simple Plan, Busted


I rest my case.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

That still doesn't give people the right to piss all over his threads though. It's a thread about a pop-punk band (That's right I said it), get your head out of your arse and stop being suck a prick about it

I'm not in the mood for your "**** your opinion" ****

haha.

GC= not pop-punk or pop-rock.

GC= no place ina pop-punk or pop-rock forum.

You attempts to wind me up are fairly childish for someone who comes across as having a degree of intelligence

[Ganondorf]

And your attempts to wind everyone else up comes across as just about right for someone who has no intelligence whatsoever.


And how is saying GC are pop-punk winding anyone up anymore than you constantly saying Blink-182 are pop?

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

And your attempts to wind everyone else up comes across as just about right for someone who has no intelligence whatsoever.


And how is saying GC are pop-punk winding anyone up anymore than you constantly saying Blink-182 are pop?


Calling GC pop-punk in that context was a cear attempt to provoke a reaction. Please do not try and reverse what i've said against me, it's clear what you tried to do anyone can see it

:rolleyes:

[Ganondorf]

Sup elitism

[Kif]

If you hate Good Charlotte so much and agree that they are pop, why bother

A) Posting in the thread in the first place
B) Posting here to get it closed

I don't see what rule his thread is breaking, and the only reason it has turned into a spamfest is because everyone else has made it that.

And that's the end of this argument as far as I am concerned

[Ganondorf]

haha yeah, Twat is a retard.
End of.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

My point is that as it has no place in the forum then it shouldn't be discussed. My post in there indicated that this was just one of many out of place threads and posts that were unbelievably irritating.

Posting in here to get it closed was me hoping that someone else would take note of that fact and get rid of it.

At the end of the day i want to talk about pop-punk, which for a lot of the time just isn't possible in here.

[Ganondorf]

Well then talk about it elsewhere, seriously, just **** of.

[Kif]

My point is that as it has no place in the forum then it shouldn't be discussed. My post in there indicated that this was just one of many out of place threads and posts that were unbelievably irritating.

Posting in here to get it closed was me hoping that someone else would take note of that fact and get rid of it.

At the end of the day i want to talk about pop-punk, which for a lot of the time just isn't possible in here.
No one is stopping you making a thread. If you want to talk about pop-punk stop expecting other people to start it off for you?

And as for that fact; there are more people in this forum than you. Everyone has different tastes. Name all you favourite bands and I can guarentee someone will point out at least 1 and say they aren't pop-punk

[Rancid Dan]

/reads

[Ganondorf]

My point is that as it has no place in the forum then it shouldn't be discussed. My post in there indicated that this was just one of many out of place threads and posts that were unbelievably irritating.

Posting in here to get it closed was me hoping that someone else would take note of that fact and get rid of it.

At the end of the day i want to talk about pop-punk, which for a lot of the time just isn't possible in here.

If you wanted the thread to fail, why did you even post in it?

[Padmé]

Those who say that GC is closest to pop-punk fail to notice the "other music" board. I'm not trying to be a jerk here, I just think that GC would go better in that board.

[Kif]

Those who say that GC is closest to pop-punk fail to notice the "other music" board. I'm not trying to be a jerk here, I just think that GC would go better in that board.
Good Charlotte = Power Pop

That is allowed to be posted in this forum.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Well then talk about it elsewhere, seriously, just **** of.

Look, i have absolutely no interest in anything you have to say. whether it's about football or the most hardcore band you've ever heard it is always bullsh!t

No one is stopping you making a thread. If you want to talk about pop-punk stop expecting other people to start it off for you?

i have made many a thread in this forum, proper pop-punk bands just aren't recognised by the vast majority. I can think of about 4 people who post in this forum who really know what a pop-punk band is


And as for that fact; there are more people in this forum than you. Everyone has different tastes.

so what? the idea of a pop-punk forum is that this is the area of the site where pop-punk is disgussed. If you can't see that then there's no point having this discussion



Name all you favourite bands and I can guarentee someone will point out at least 1 and say they aren't pop-punk

again, what has this got to do with anything? i like bands of lots of genres. My favourite pop-punk bands are NOFX, Descendents, Bouncing Souls and Captain everything.

Those who say that GC is closest to pop-punk fail to notice the "other music" board. I'm not trying to be a jerk here, I just think that GC would go better in that board.

exactly.

[Kif]

i have made many a thread in this forum, proper pop-punk bands just aren't recognised by the vast majority. I can think of about 4 people who post in this forum who really know what a pop-punk band is
Well then encourage people to listen to "proper pop-punk bands". It's not everyone else's fault if they don't like your taste in music. There's a recommendations thread, there's a Yousendit thread and there's a Forced Listening thread. USE THEM!
so what? the idea of a pop-punk forum is that this is the area of the site where pop-punk is disgussed. If you can't see that then there's no point having this discussion
Do you see a power pop forum on this site? Why do you find it so hard to accept anyone else's opinion about genres of music, and why do you have to turn every tiny problem which shouldn't even be a problem into this big drama?
again, what has this got to do with anything? i like bands of lots of genres. My favourite pop-punk bands are NOFX, Descendents, Bouncing Souls and Captain everything.
What has this got to do with anything? You are the one who in the same post just lashed out at Ganon for no reason? Anyway, I don't really care if you like bands of different genres. I'm not opposing your musical taste. I'm just saying that someone somewhere will disagree with your musical tastes and say one of your favourite bands is not pop-punk. Deal with it how you want, I was just saying that

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

Well then encourage people to listen to "proper pop-punk bands". It's not everyone else's fault if they don't like your taste in music. There's a recommendations thread, there's a Yousendit thread and there's a Forced Listening thread. USE THEM!

I do not care that people don't have the same taste in music as me. I expect people on a pop-punk forum to have the same taste as me. I.e. Pop-punk :rolleyes:
[/QUOTE]


Do you see a power pop forum on this site? Why do you find it so hard to accept anyone else's opinion about genres of music, and why do you have to turn every tiny problem which shouldn't even be a problem into this big drama?

No but i do see an 'others' forum. I have no idea accepting opinions, i do have a probelm accepting ignorant statements. I do not care if the guy likes good charlotte, but i don't want to see a thread full of sh'it when i log in to talk about pop-punk. I also don't expect to have to explain this to a bunch of morons who ignore what i'm trying to say every time but we'll save that for another day


What has this got to do with anything? You are the one who in the same post just lashed out at Ganon for no reason? Anyway, I don't really care if you like bands of different genres. I'm not opposing your musical taste. I'm just saying that someone somewhere will disagree with your musical tastes and say one of your favourite bands is not pop-punk. Deal with it how you want, I was just saying that

the fact is that if a band isn't pop-punk, i'm going to say it isn't pop-punk. The big deal, i have no idea? Too many people in this forum have an alleergic reaction to being told something they don't like. If he likes GC I DON'T CARE. I do not want them called pop-punk though as i feel it is an insult to the genre and everything it stands for.

And about Ganondorf, the guy is a moron. He does not post constructively and if you read through the thread you will see that all/the majority of his posts are sniping comments with no substance and very little meaning

[Ganondorf]

No but i do see an 'others' forum. I have no idea accepting opinions, i do have a probelm accepting ignorant statements. I do not care if the guy likes good charlotte, but i don't want to see a thread full of sh'it when i log in to talk about pop-punk. I also don't expect to have to explain this to a bunch of morons who ignore what i'm trying to say every time but we'll save that for another day



And about Ganondorf, the guy is a moron. He does not post constructively and if you read through the thread you will see that all/the majority of his posts are sniping comments with no substance and very little meaning

If you don't like this forum, don't come here. Seriously, everyone would be better of without you constantly provoking people into arguments. So yes, you clarify the majority of the forum as a bunch of morons, then wonder why no one gives a **** about your lameass reccomendations or albums uploaded on YSI? And if you don't want to see a thread about a 'non tru pop punx band!!!' don't read them. No one's got a gun to your head forcing you to read threads against your will.

And I wouldn't say I'm a moron, I'm not the one who posts in every other thread telling the threadstarter that he's a retard and that I know better than him when it comes to pop-punk.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

If you don't like this forum, don't come here. Seriously, everyone would be better of without you constantly provoking people into arguments. So yes, you clarify the majority of the forum as a bunch of morons, then wonder why no one gives a **** about your lameass reccomendations or albums uploaded on YSI? And if you don't want to see a thread about a 'on tru pop punx band!!!' don't read them. No one's got a gun to your head forcing you to read threads against your will.

And I wouldn't say I'm a moron, I'm not the one who posts in every other thread telling the threadstarter that he's a retard and that I know better than him when it comes to pop-punk.

i wouldn't hesistate to say i know more about pop-punk than the majority of people in this forum. That's not a major critisicm, it's just that whereas i try to talk pop-punk in here i find it increasingly hard to do so. I enjoy talking about pop-punk hugely, its just getting too hard to do that.

And i think it's worth noting the amoutn of nominations i got in last month's pop-punker of the month compared to you before you make suggestions like that

[Ganondorf]

I think it's worth noticing I've actually won the competetion as opposed to you.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

I think it's worth noticing I've actually won the competetion as opposed to you.

i really don't care, that was ages ago anyway.

i do enjoy the way you escape the whole issue entirely during these arguments

[Ganondorf]

You're the one that bought up the whole PPOTM thing anyway. Too bad you didn't think it through. I've already adressed the main issue anyway, but you persist to be a little bitch.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

You do not adress any issues, you duck the issue and wait for people to help you out, in this case Kif

I brought that up as part of an argument, not the argument. Try again

[Ganondorf]

OK, I failed to show you up. But Kif did, big time.

At the end of the day you still end up looking like a dick.

And if you make a comment about PPOTM, of course I'm going to respond to it. You can't just make a comment and expect everyone to gnore it just because it's not the main focus of discussion.

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

OK, I failed to show you up. But Kif did, big time.

At the end of the day you still end up looking like a dick.

And if you make a comment about PPOTM, of course I'm going to respond to it. You can't just make a comment and expect everyone to gnore it just because it's not the main focus of discussion.

Kif did not show me up in the slightest.

If i make a comment i don't care if you comment on it or ont, but you don't seem to realise that i'm not arguing with you for the sake of that, there is a general point as to why i'm still replying to you

:rolleyes:

[Oz Rembrandt]

Whoa, when did Ganadorf get Banned?

[Ganondorf]

In the Pit gambling thread ;)

[PDWAB]

Twat, Good Charlotte can be discussed in here. It's in the rules thread.

[Ganondorf]

haha, Twat is once again proved to be a retard.

What you gonna do, lair of the mods?

[Twat_Out_Of_Hell]

haha, Twat is once again proved to be a retard.

What you gonna do, lair of the mods?

Lair of the mods? What does that mean?

Fair enough, i didn't go through the rule thread thoroughly enough to realise that good charlotte were allowed to be discussed in a pop-punk and pop-punk forum.

Sorry PDWAB