PDA

View Full Version : (Rock) Billy Talent - Self Titled


DeathOnBroadway
04-25-2004, 04:41 AM
Band: Billy Talent
Album: Billy Talent (self titled)
Released: 2003

Benjamin Kowalewicz - Vocals
Ian D'Sa - Guitar/Backing Vocals
Jon Gallant - Bass/Backing Vocals
Aaron Solowoniuk - Drums

Track listing:

1. This Is How It Goes - 3:27
2. Living In The Shadows - 3:15
3. Try Honesty - 4:13
4. Line & Sinker - 3:36
5. Lies - 2:59
6. The Ex - 2:40
7. River Below - 3:00
8. Standing In The Rain - 3:20
9. Cut The Curtains - 3:50
10. Prisoners Of Today - 3:53
11. Nothing To Lose - 3:38
12. Voice Of Violence - 3:10

Review:

This Is How It Goes - This starts out the cd with a little, fast-paced riff by Ian, which is played through a few times. Then the third time it's played, after the symbols come in, the bass starts its riff. After that plays a while, it breaks out into some trashing, instense chords that make you want to pick up the nearest breakable items and throw them. It sounds very sloppy, but if you tried to play it all perfect, it would sound horrible. Then it goes back to the intro as the verse and Ben's high pitched, semi-scratchy sounding vocals fuel the verse. Then he does a little bit of screaming (not hardcore-style, just rock-style screaming...if that made any sense) in the chorus...it's just amazing; it's also backed up by Ian and Jon, who fit perfectly. There's some more verses and choruses, but then it gets to the bridge which isn't bad itself, then another chorus. A great song. 10/10

Living In The Shadows - Starts out with a chord and then becomes a little faster, then slows down for the verse and builds back up again for the chorus, in which, Ben does another semi-screaming chorus, with the backing vocals again. Same formula as the first song: Intro-Verse-Chorus-Verse-Chorus-Bridge-Chorus. They do this, or something similar, for many songs, but it works quite well. Not as good as the first song, but still good. 8/10

Try Honesty - You may have seen the video or heard this on the radio. The first single from the cd. The guitar intro is somewhat uplifting and quite wonderful. After that it is power driven, with all instruments, and then there's a break for part of the intro riff, then back into the power, and repeated a few times. It slows down for the verse, in which the drums and vocals are the main focus. Ben's singing is a little bit sadder sounding in the verses of this song than the previous two. The chorus is the driving music again with urgent sounding vocal trade-offs of Ben and the back ups. The bridge is pretty good too. He starts to scream like he's insane, and the video makes it seem even more so. A great song. 9/10

Line & Sinker - This song, on the other hand, starts out with Ben screaming and the chorus, with three overlapping voices, then goes into the verse. It has one of greatest lines that has ever been written in music: Don't think that you're so great, 'cause being great must suck. There's not a single song on this that doesn't have great lyrics, but the little part before the chorus is wonderful. They mention Santa, heh. The breakdown with the palm muted guitar is nice too. Then another chorus, and ends abruptly. Another good song. 8/10

Lies - The opening riff on guitar is different than the past four songs, it's sounds more happyish, you'd have to hear it, the words go along with it really well. Overlapping voices in the verse and then goes into the chorus, which is basicly saying that lies are everywhere. Then a verse, then a chorus, and then a faster chorus and then Ben screams "lies." The bridge is fast with Ian and Ben trading off vocals again, and back into the chorus. Then ends with "lies" but not screamed. 8/10

The Ex - The only blunt song about an ex-girlfriend. The opening riff on this song is comparable to the song before, but lower. Then the verse comes, where Ben sings a few lines and then the back up and Ben sing one, then Ben, then the band and into the chorus. When Ben sings the chorus, the back up is screaming the first word of every line, for about 1 second. You don't really realize it, because it's just put together so well. A good song for when you're angry about your ex. 9/10

River Below - Another great guitar riff, bass and drum intro. Another vocal trade off, but this time is slightly different than the other songs. It lasts throughout the whole verse, and Ian starts, instead of Ben. The chorus is the best part of the song. Ben stretches his voice out on the o-sounds on the words "below" and "inferno." Sounds awesome. It will have you singing along with it, just like most on this cd. Verse and chorus, then the bridge. Which is just lines from the chorus repeated and some screamed. Then a chorus and an abrupt stop. 9/10

Standing In The Rain - One of the highest points on the album. A song, in which, Ben takes the place of a drug addicted prostitute. Either herion or cocaine, because he mentions needles. A little more laid back opening this time, that goes into the scene of a man driving by her, standing on the street, wondering if she'll get picked up. His voice fits the slow moving verse perfectly. The chorus has a lot to offer as well. Ben is backed up by the others and then sings a fast line, and repeats the same rhythm with different words, four times through. A truly great song. 9/10

Cut The Curtains - Palm muted guitar intro, with rumbling bass and drums, that slows down when it reaches the start of the verse. I don't find the verse extremely exciting, but the chorus makes up for more than enough of it. Overlapping voices, with a harmony by Ian, which is simple, but cool. It's not so much that most of the things on their songs jump out and choke you to death, but that you listen to it and notice them. It makes you appreciate the music more. I don't believe there's a single person that can match Ian or Ben's voice. Another great part of the song is the bridge. They do something they haven't done the entire cd; they play the same thing over and over until you can't hear it and then it blasts right back at you with intense power. Another great installment to this already great cd. 9/10

Prisoners Of Today - This has to be my favorite opening guitar riff of the entire cd. It's so different from all the others. It's the most mellow sounding one, but it also sounds like it's something caged about to break loose. That's the only way I can think to discribe it. The music builds up and it does get slightly heavier, just not too much. It never really "breaks loose," but the verses are some of the best on the cd. Ben sings the fastest he's sung throughout the whole thing. The bass is extremely audiable for a 10 second part of the song, which is really nice. The chorus is rather nice too. It's quiet, with the intro riff, and the riff that's right after the verse (with the bass part) after the singing is done. The second time through, Ian sings the second part and it sounds cool. The bridge in this song is okay, it's not incredibly awesome, but it's pretty good. It ties you over until it gets to the next part of the song. The building intensity of the song toward the end is good though. 9/10

Nothing To Lose - My favorite track on the whole cd. Most of the other songs are fast-paced and just rip right through them, but this one is slow and it builds up slower than any of the other songs. Very sad sounding vocals and guitar. The drums and bass don't really come in until after the first chorus. Ian and Ben switch off again. The second verse has more power than the first and the same goes for the second verse and then goes into a nice chord progression and gets quiet again with the guitar intro played for the third verse/bridge. The third chorus is the same as the second, but the fourth is just...amazing. It has a lot power in the vocals and the lyrics, backed by the power of the music. This is the first and last time that Ben really screams more hardcore. And when you listen to it, it just feels like an overwhelming feeling (that was built up throughout the first part of the song) has just been suddenly lifted. And it's a topic most people can relate to: teenage years. It's not your typical punk-angst type song though. No, not at all. It must've sucked for him in high school if he ate his lunches in the bathroom alone. 10/10

Voice Of Violence - After that sad song, it bursts right back into the raw, sloppy power that most of the other songs have. The singing's great on the first, but the chorus tops the vocals on every other song on here (including River Below and Cut The Curtains). The back ups start the chorus and hold the note, and Ben screams over it, and while he's screaming they start singing the title twice and Ben comes in at that end with his talented voice and does something like: "(voices of violence, voices of violence) violen-ay-yeah-ay-ence." The parantheses are the back up. It just simply awesome. But you can barely tell when Ian's voice ends and Ben's starts, quite amazing. You'd have to hear it. The bridge is simple but great as well, and it ends with it and a final drum beat. A great song to play on bass or guitar, just as most are. A great song to end a great cd with. 10/10

Other things:

They are Canadian, and they have punk influences, but they are not punk. The influences just make their rock sound faster and sloppier, which makes it sound better than it might. The lyrics on every song are some of the best I've ever heard and you can't help but be amazed by some of the guitar riffs and all the tempo changes. I would recomend this cd to most people. If you love punk, metal or rock, you will most likely love this. Even some pop- listeners might enjoy some of it if they sat down and listened to it, but I doubt most of them would appreciate it. I give the whole cd 4/5.

There's nothing to lose
When no one knows your name
There's nothing to gain
But the days don't seem to change

bruise_pristine
04-25-2004, 10:48 AM
After hearing alot of talk on mx about this band, I went and listened to them at the record store. I was expecting a really good band, everyone was saying good things about them on mx. I heard the album, and I couldn't stand it, they vocals were bad, the music was to generic. The best to my knowledge there was only one song I could stand, and it was one of the last ones, I don't remember the title.

The album is to generic and becomes old very fast, if you can get past the scratching vocals the generic guitar riffs and you like alot of teen angst lyrics then you might like them. I personally can't stand them.

Exellent review though, you really went into depth. Which is needed for a music review.

sting-ray
04-25-2004, 11:39 AM
album name please...

DeathOnBroadway
04-25-2004, 02:45 PM
It is self titled. Maybe I should just put self titled up there. But that's why I just put their name again. And, yes, there will a lot of people who can't stand it. I had to listen to it a few times through before I started to like it more and now I love it.

thursdaythrice
04-25-2004, 03:12 PM
wow,your review is really excellent.I might pick this one up

SamParker337
05-15-2004, 03:25 PM
does anyone think that 'try honesty' sounds like ATDI One Arm Scissor?

Curdt_Kobain
06-01-2004, 01:48 PM
SUCKS..... simply put... lol its an opinion

Napes
06-02-2004, 05:36 PM
i've heard a few versions of the same songs. personally the ones that i found on the internet sounded much better (especially "and this is how it goes"). Its still a good cd tho

james_delve
06-04-2004, 07:42 AM
Hmmm, I loved the single Try Honesty, and thought i'd buy the album.
I wasn't impressed, i thought, this is just whingey emo/punk...but i listened, and then listened again, and again. I realised that this really is a good album, i love it now man, the standout track definitely being Nothing To Lose.
I would recommend this album to anyone (especially Blink 182/Brand New fans)
4/5.....Rawk On

Justanothernimrod
06-28-2004, 04:15 PM
Billy Talent-Billy Talent

From the first time I heard the single “Try Honesty�, Billy Talent grabbed my attention like no other band from over the pond, for quite some time. So it just became instinct to buy the album, and what a great album it is. This debut from the self-proclaimed ‘Canadian losers’ is exciting, emotional and above all, fresh which is needed so much in the music industry right now. It all kicks off with opening track “This is how it Goes� which provides, a shout-a-long chorus, catchy guitar riff and overall a brilliant introduction to the band. A couple of tracks later you find yourself at the single track “Try Honesty� which respectively opens with a hypnotic guitar riff and then breaks in to the bands paramount track, taking the listening through the violent mood swings expressed in this song by Benjamin Kowalewicz. And the album progresses, with no real direction as an album, but the single material is distinctive with, the next single, “The Ex� a 2 minute 40 second with a very dark feel to it and musically a general basic punk-pop track with once again, catchy chorus, and a standout track of the album. Afterwards, once again, the album doesn’t really go anywhere, with the 3 minute “River Below� showing the band’s talent musically but overall, an average song. It isn’t till “Cut The Curtains� that things pick up again, another very-dark, single potential, catchy tune with a brilliant break down that will you have you shouting along, and yet being scared of yourself and what you are hearing at the same time. This follows with “Prisoners of Today� another one of the albums best. Unfortunately, these are the only real positive moments of the album, the rest of the tracks are not very compelling and do not really does anything to the listener. However, as a debut album, it is easy to tell that they are still a learning band, and that their future releases, should be brilliant.

7/10

just a phase ix
06-28-2004, 04:40 PM
Billy Talent is a really awesome band. The first time I had ever heard of them was when I saw them live at my local radio station's "Upstart Fest" which shows some of the newest bands in the rock scene. Their performance was full of high energy and was just amazing. Soon after their performance I bought their CD. Most people I know like the song "Nothing to Lose" but I prefer "River Below." Since I saw them live I have gone and seen them live 2 other times and hope to see them at Warped Tour. They rule.

FakeReality
06-28-2004, 06:11 PM
The CD isn't that bad but his voice is so annoying and one way....it's the same tone through the whole album and it kinda gets irritating.

Justanothernimrod
06-29-2004, 11:42 AM
Nothing to lose is the worst song on the album, I cant believe so many people like it...

Jamo88
07-01-2004, 11:50 PM
One of the most promising bands to come out of anywhere, not just Canada. Ian's angular guitar riffs and Aaron's powerful drums carry some songs that would otherwise fall flat. Ben's Johnny Lydon-esque vocals (don't tell me you didn't hear the resemblance between the Pistols and them) brings the songs emotion and conviction and anger.

Jamo88
07-01-2004, 11:53 PM
Oh yeah, I almost forgot. Some of the versions of these songs I heard on the internet were much better than the studio versions. "This Is How It Goes" had better lyrics and better riffs, "The Ex" was faster. But some weren't as good. "Cut The Curtains" had a chunkier riff in the studio version than the one on the internet. The same can be said about "Living In The Shadows".

-GuitarAddict-
07-09-2004, 10:28 PM
Billy talent is a great new band! I have the album and love every single song on it. It took a little while for me to get to used to their sound though, i find you either love benjamin's voice or you hate it. I find they put alot of emotion into their songs and thats what will grab most peoples attention!
p.s. Great review!

Win A Rabbit
07-10-2004, 02:05 AM
^^^ totally agree. i understand why many people are going to hate his voice, but i think there's just something about it, and i love it. i had to buy it 3 times because my friend and brother bought it off me for $20, when i bought it for $15 each time. made $10 off it, so i think that gets extra points too haha.

its really emotional music, which i fully respect.

i wasn't realy a fan of "nothing to lose", but now that i listen to it, its actually a really good song.

my 2 favorite songs are river below (because it has such a "good" message) (i don't know how to describe it) and prisoners of today (also has a good message, but this time, an actual good message)

Win A Rabbit
07-10-2004, 02:06 AM
i'd recommend anyone to go buy this cd, i saw it today for $8, so you're not gonna lose out if you dont like it.

cheap birthday present gift or something.

Jet Black Stare
07-10-2004, 02:11 AM
My favourite line off the cd

"Rejected since day one, my name is bastard son"

that seems pretty deep to me

GregtheGreat
07-10-2004, 03:07 AM
I love this album, and I think it's an album well put together with great lyrics and great guitar riffs

xtreme chess
08-14-2004, 12:09 AM
amazing band, cut the curtains my favourite song, pick this one up! 5/5

shabutie
08-19-2004, 10:16 PM
BILLY TALENT KICKS A$$, live was amazing, and all there songs are solid

Metallica_1
08-25-2004, 06:30 PM
like a lot of ppl said i...i had to listen to it a couple of times before i started to like it...but i had to listen to it high to really appreciate it

Chop Suey!
08-25-2004, 11:18 PM
GREAT band. Incredibly hard to classify though. I have had this album since it came out and im still listening to it. once again, great band. Any one who has the money should go buy this cd.

IsItLuck?
08-25-2004, 11:38 PM
Maybe not a 10/10 but definitely a 7/10 or 8/10.

Nice review, they rock

Darknessca
08-26-2004, 02:49 PM
They're okay. I really hate ben's voice. Not singing voice...but talking voice. Its very nasal...moreso than chris carraba. Their songs are very boring....they're all formatted perfectly for radio/television. If you listen to their old stuff its much better (including hte older version of Try Honesty)

vernonjr
08-26-2004, 04:27 PM
...i love this cd, and i understand why if anyone doesnt, its a love/hate cd i think

rocknrollgirl
08-28-2004, 09:59 PM
I love Billy Talent. They rock! They're one of the only few punk/screamo bands that i actually like... I've liked almost every single they've released, gonna pick-up album soon. Kick *** band from Canada! Btw I am Canadian so I had to put that....

Rotodizer
08-28-2004, 10:07 PM
Very good review. This album is one if not The best album I ever heard. You just can't stop listening to it after you heard in two or three times. I really recommend it.

as life hangs beside me
08-29-2004, 12:49 AM
the drummer (aaron) went to my high school (meadowvale, mississauga, ontario)
hell, the whole band's from my area, which is awesome
Ian used to teach guitar at a local guitar store, too (the whole band went there for an autograph session a few months ago (got mine signed :D )

wishiwaskurt210
08-29-2004, 12:58 AM
i love billy talent im always blown away by how that guy screams like that for a whole show i went to see them at peabodys in cleveland it was like the best show ive ever seen besides incubus

wishiwaskurt210
08-29-2004, 01:00 AM
as like hangs
thats sweet that he went to your school no one famus has ever came outa my town

Damrod
08-30-2004, 10:28 AM
Hm, some songs are really great, and I like those a lot (River below for instance), but some other songs on the record are not so special. I like one half of the record, the other don't.

So I would say: 3/5

DiGgY
08-30-2004, 11:56 AM
This has to be the best band come out of canada since sum 41. I first caught wind of Billy Talent from 'Try Honestly' which was on the soundtrack do a game i have. I instantly loved the song, and constantly listened to it, with each listen it grew on me. Then i heard 'River Below'. the opening riff is amazing as is the rest of the song, so i decided to get the album. Instant classic in my ever growing collection. The best songs are try honestly, river below, the ex, nothing to lose, and lies. The ex works for me because it connects to a period in my life, so i loved it. the scorching lyrics in all the songs are excellent throughout the entire album and 'nothing to lose' is an amazing song. Im surprised that 'Lies' hasnt been given much credit on this review, the riffs are blasting throughout and the song caught my attention right away, im glad billy talent came along, each cd i bought never lived up to the standard and i was looking for a classic to end the streak of crappy cd's i bought. This is that cd. i rate the whole album 9/10

Chop Suey!
08-30-2004, 12:50 PM
What would you guys classify this baand as? Alot of the songs sound punk but then certain songs like river below and cut the curtains seem hard rock.

DiGgY
08-30-2004, 12:53 PM
Id classify em as........well im not 2 sure either, hard to do. Maybe punk, but a bit heavy for punk, like supercharged punk or sumthin, but i agree that some songs are a little heavy to be classified as punk

Paranoidd
08-30-2004, 01:40 PM
I live about 15 minutes from where these guys are from, so we heard about them first. Personally, I can't stand them. The nasal voice, the power chords, the completely typical muscial structure and content, it just drives me insane. Boring unimaginative melodies and juvenile lyrics. I'm not shytting on anybodys taste, I just don't personally like them.

Great review though.

I_AM_CANADIAN
09-03-2004, 12:14 AM
amazing review personally i hated them when i first heard try honesty on tv but they really grow on you a
great canadian band :D

libertine2020
09-03-2004, 01:13 AM
Just bought it today. 8/10. Very energetic and much deeper than any Good Charlotte crap.

stke22
09-03-2004, 01:29 AM
9/10

Try Honesty - Best track ever and easy to play.
Had this ever since it came out. Great to listen to when you feel down or so.
River Below has been playing for awhile... It gets annoying and on my nerves...

Paranoidd
09-03-2004, 10:38 AM
Just bought it today. 8/10. Very energetic and much deeper than any Good Charlotte crap.

Whats deep about it?

incubliss
09-09-2004, 12:24 PM
it's a good fun album. i listen to it every now and then, and it's a really fun album, with some really good guitar riffs.

i love the riff in How it Goes, and yes, i've noticed the difference in some of the songs. i have two different versions of Try Honesty, the album version being the best in my opinion.

skamakesmehorny
09-21-2004, 01:51 PM
Billy talent is a great new band! I have the album and love every single song on it. It took a little while for me to get to used to their sound though, i find you either love benjamin's voice or you hate it. I find they put alot of emotion into their songs and thats what will grab most peoples attention!
p.s. Great review!
I like it too! and I love office space!

rhcp_r_gods
12-11-2004, 07:22 PM
every song is that same

tallmanevan
12-11-2004, 09:06 PM
After hearing alot of talk on mx about this band, I went and listened to them at the record store. I was expecting a really good band, everyone was saying good things about them on mx. I heard the album, and I couldn't stand it, they vocals were bad, the music was to generic. The best to my knowledge there was only one song I could stand, and it was one of the last ones, I don't remember the title.

The album is to generic and becomes old very fast, if you can get past the scratching vocals the generic guitar riffs and you like alot of teen angst lyrics then you might like them. I personally can't stand them.

Exellent review though, you really went into depth. Which is needed for a music review.


say generic one more time. please.

EdBanger
12-12-2004, 11:05 AM
Definetely 10/10 this band are truely awesome.
I really want them to do a tour over here in England.

Jeuneau
12-12-2004, 12:21 PM
Their good, but not amazing. The first song "This is How It Goes" grabbed me, but the rest of the songs took a few listens to get into. Ben can scream though.

El_Shiznit
12-12-2004, 01:32 PM
What would you guys classify this baand as? Alot of the songs sound punk but then certain songs like river below and cut the curtains seem hard rock.
These guys aren't punk. I don't know why so many people think they are. They are pop-punk but just a bit heavier. Kind of like in the direction Sum41 is. But not completely like them. Just the same type of pop-punk as Sum41. They are very good nonetheless. This band changed my view on music in general with this release. Major props to them. :thumb:

mexicans_arent_gimps
12-12-2004, 02:37 PM
they're like a mix of post-hardcore, and pop-punk. and i think they've done their homework with old-emo, which is nice. i think this is the poppiest band i listen to, and it shows how accessible they are, because they grab attention from both people new to rock music to seasoned rock listeners. i know ben's voice isn't for everyone, but i love ian d'sa's guitar lines mostly, and their drummer is a machine on the record