Sputnikmusic Top 50: #10-1
by Dave de Sylvia
December 22nd 2008 | 62 Comments
#50-41 // #40-31 // #30-21 // #20-11 // #10-1 Launch Standalone Streaming Playlist
The Top Ten:  10. Butch Walker - Sycamore Meadows Blood On The Tracks. Jagged Little Pill. Sea Change. Iconic break-up records all, but they’re all just a little bit gloomy. Sycamore Meadows isn’t all about a break-up- in fact it’s not so clear there was a full-blown break-up at all- but it’s a record that hits on the full range of emotions that accompany a great loss. Highlight ‘Here Comes The...’ is Walker’s most moving and emotionally vulnerable composition to date, flawlessly evoking the fear and isolation of a relationship going wrong, while ‘Vessels’ takes a more whimsical approach, recalling the exciting “having sex on the hoods of cars” stage of a relationship. The glammy, horn-filled ‘Ponce De Leon Ave’ celebrates the letting loose period after the fact, ‘The Weight Of Her’ channels Elvis Costello in its righteous dismissal of petty post-relationship politics, while tracks like 'Going Back/Going Home' and closer 'ATL' explore the concept of “home” through the eyes of somebody who knows what it’s like to be unexpectedly homeless. / Dave De Sylvia MP3: Butch Walker - 'The Weight Of Her' // Review 9. Protest the Hero – Fortress Ever since A Calculated Use of Sound came out in the summer of 2003, Protest the Hero have been a wildly polarizing outfit. Even as their voices dropped, lyrics advanced and their techniques improved, the complaints and praise have always been more or less the same. Yet these polarizing elements---the vocals, the frenetic leads, the highly literate lyrics and generally over-the-top aesthetic---have remained key components of their sound. Fortress, their most polarizing release yet, has spent the past 12 months garnering reactions primarily on opposite sides of the spectrum. But what really matters is that Fortress consists of wildly contrasting sounds and moods. It walks a fine line between being serious and a joke; it shreds without being gratuitous; it's influenced by Broadway and Dostoevsky and, most significantly, it’s an inspiration to both ugly dudes with beards and gender conflicted teenagers. Arguably, Fortress is the most intriguing metal album of the year. / Tyler Munro Protest The Hero @ MySpace // Review
8. Flying Lotus - Los Angeles Steven Ellison, a.k.a. Flying Lotus, a.k.a. the guy whose music is used on Adult Swim commercials, followed up his 2006 debut LP 1983 with the attention-grabbing release Los Angeles. Los Angeles is a careful, but ultimately substantial, progression from his previous efforts. The cornucopia of samples that defined 1983's varied soundscapes have been mushed together, thrown through a few distortion filters, and yanked even more out of quantization to produce an album that shuffles, sludges, and grooves harder than any other out this year. FlyLo's unique taste in samples for his drum kits yields a rich flavor that, when squeezed into his off-kilter timing and beats, gives a sound that is absolutely throbbing (additional visual evidence of this can be witnessed in his video for "Parisian Goldfish"). This album really is best new music. / Nick Greer MP3: Kanye West - Love Lockdown (Flying Lotus Mix) // Review
7. pg.lost - It's Not Me, It's You! In a genre of music dominated by mainstay artists and their various side projects, pg.lost have risen with seemingly no hype to achieve the highest ranked post-rock album on this list, It's Not Me, It's You!. A mix of deft and beautiful guitar work with dynamic changes in the songs, it may all seem too EitS-esque at first, but as soon as you hear the end of ‘Siren’ you'll forget about who may or may not have influenced pg.lost and focus instead on what they have brought to the table. Their ability to wrangle you into a song and hook you is currently unparalleled in the genre, and hopefully pg.lost can expand their relatively small fan base with It's Not Me, It's You!. / John A. Hanson pg.lost @ MySpace // Review 6. Bon Iver - For Emma, Forever Ago There’s not much that can be said about Bon Iver’s full-length debut that hasn’t already been said. Every critic and his fruit fly has more or less passed some sort of comment, however brief, on just about every conceivable aspect of For Emma, Forever Ago. Yet not a single one could ever even begin to tell you anything about just what the weight of emotion that Justin Vernon’s minimalist acoustic masterpiece carries with it. For Emma is simply too… personal. It’s the sort of intimacy that carves its own meaning in the deepest confines of the heart, skipping with bounds and strides across ears and into the chest with piercing clarity. It’s never hurt more than this but, sometimes, it’s the pain that reminds us that we’re all really alive in the first place. / Alex Silveri MP3: Bon Iver - 'Skinny Love' // Review 5. Have a Nice Life - Deathconsciousness Deathconsciousness is a special album. It was recorded in a home studio over the course of five years by two friends, Tim Macuga and Dan Barrett (ex-In Pieces), who wanted to combine their love of My Blood Valentine, Joy Division, Nine Inch Nails, and Xasthur into one unified sound. After speaking with Richard McFarlan, a Religious Anthropology professor at UMass Amherst, they were inspired to write a concept album surrounding the life and mysteries of Antiochus, an exiled Roman religious leader. In their words, “[w]e're playing songs in a dead genre about believers in a dead religion.” Despite, and maybe thanks to all of this death consciousness, Have a Nice Life have produced an album that is startlingly nuanced, intimate, and emotionally gripping. Amidst fuzzy shoegaze tones and industrial beats, it treads the line between despair and hope; neither too brittle and cold, nor too lush and intricate. The result is esoteric and challenging, yet unexpectedly catchy. / Nick Greer MP3: Have A Nice Life - 'Bloodhail' // Review 4. Blue Sky Black Death - Late Night Cinema Maybe the one thing lacking from modern trip hop and instrumental hip hop is a truly great sense of the moment. Not since DJ Shadow's Endtroducing have listeners been treated to an album that makes good on instrumental hip hop's many strengths by fixing its one glaring weakness. On Late Night Cinema, Blue Sky Black Death effectively combine post-rock song structures and sense of poignancy and escalation, with trip hop's usual strengths (atmosphere, groove, diversity, etc.), to create the first album since Endtroducing that moves the listener as much as it soothes. The expansive, ever-changing arcs feel monumental when coupled with smooth trumpets, fluttering violins, soulful vocal samples, and thick, awe-inspiring beats. / Nick Greer Blue Sky Black Death @ MySpace // Review 3. TV on the Radio - Dear Science With Dear Science, TV on the Radio took in a step in a new direction. Toning down much of their sonic undulations and ramping up the production value, Dear Science adds a poppy, Prince-like quality to the band's already enigmatic sound. Mashing soul, pop, hip-hop and even electronica into a post-punk foundation, Dear Science defies the odds by being both highly coherent and easily digestible. Most importantly, TV on the Radio seem to have recaptured the indefinable “it” factor that made their first two releases so special. As dense as it is fun, Dear Science is one of 2008’s most colorful albums, as well as one of its finest. / Tyler Munro TV On The Radio @ MySpace // Review 2. Off Minor - Some Blood Some Blood is the culmination Off Minor's steady rise to becoming one of the most relevant and original hardcore bands currently playing. Mixing their traditional preference for jazz phrasing with the dynamic nature usually associated with emo, Some Blood exists as a truly 21st century hardcore record, building on the past while clearly looking towards the future. / Jared W. Dillon MP3: Off Minor - 'Everything Explicit' // Review 1. Cynic - Traced in Air Focus' biggest criticism was in the heavily vocoder-laden vocals - some people endured it, others cringed and blindly dismissed the record - but gone (for the most part) are the robotic, mechanized vocals from Paul Masvidal. Opting for cleaner, more melodic vocals in his upper-register (newcomer Tymon Kruidenier handles the harsh death growls on this record - he sounds awesome on "The Unknown Guest"), Masvidal's new delivery is stellar. Tracks like ‘Evolutionary Sleeper,’ ‘Integral Birth,’ and ‘Adam's Murmur’ showcase these higher vocals, while stellar guitarwork from Masvidal and Kruidenier whips around the vocals. The solos are stunning - just listen to ‘Evolutionary Sleeper’ and its concluding solo - and the lead/rhythm parts juxtapose to near-perfection throughout the record. / Jom MP3: Cynic - 'Integral Birth' // Review
Individual Lists:
Share: Facebook
Stumble
Digg
Del.icio.us
Comments
so i assume this is the staff list? predictable, but i think most people should be pleased with the outcome. cynic was always going to top this, wasn't it?
good job on another year, sputnik
|
A bit surprised by how high Off Minor ranked but great job overall.
|
Oh, shittest part of me. This list is a little bit silly.
|
Good list, glad you guys got #1 right.
|
I think everyone saw this list coming a mile away. Predictable, but a good summary of the albums that were enjoyed by the community this year.
|
I don't see how predictability plays any part in such a list. It's not as if the staff should choose different rankings just to be unpredictable.
A couple of ommissions from the Top 10 surprise me, but that will happen when there is quite a number of staff.
And I'm a little surprised Anberlin & Fleet Foxes couldn't squeeze into the Top 50.
Overall, this was an excellent read. Fantastic job gents. Well done.
|
pg. lost isn't that good!!!! there, i said it.
|
Bon Iver's release is a 2007 album!
|
the summary of 'Fortress' is so stupid, can nobody write a decent one?
|
silicon you're right except for the bit where you're completely wrong
|
Well, I guess I need to listen to Flying Lotus, Blue Sky Black Death. I don't see protest the hero being in the top 10, let alone the top 50. I'm not a fan of Cynic (though I'm not a metal fan in general) but at least I can respect them, cause they are good. But not PTH.
|
now this is a solid list, though I think 9 shouldn't be near the top 10.
|
good list, if not a little predictable.
|
shut the fuck up about For Emma, Forever Away being 2007. seriously, shut the fuck up. It's official release date is '08 so get over it
|
also people need to stop bitching about protest
|
good to see Butch on the list at 10.
|
Great Top 50, will probably be better than the users, but I still have hope for that one. I'm surprised that Off Minor made it to #2, going to have to listen to it.
|
great job. this seems to very accurately reflect opinions here (tho maybe replacing lotus with deerhunter)
|
The protest album was awesome. Other than in mourning not being on the list, I think its good. The metal section is to crowded, I'm glad the staff stepped back and leveled it out. Great job :)
|
In Mourning is on the list, dummy. It's just not in the top 10.
|
this is really disappointing
but idk what i expected
|
This is the most polarizing part of the list for a reason. A lot of love/hate albums made it here, but I can't complain. This is looks/is great.
|
This website is so disappointing (at the bandwagon musical taste perspective).
|
Please show me another website that has 2, 4, 5, 7, or 10 in it's top 10.
|
We should have compiled a top ten with albums no one has heard of regardless of quality, then we'd be respectable.
|
Bandwagon musical taste perspective meaning once one staffer likes it, every one else is like OMG BEST ALBUM EVER OMG
|
clearly you haven't been privy to the Protest the Hero/TV On the Radio discussion threads
|
such aggression, cocaine. flys with honey and junk
|
ec why you talk so many big words
|
red0 are you like stupid?
|
[quote]Bandwagon musical taste perspective meaning once one staffer likes it, every one else is like OMG BEST ALBUM EVER OMG[/quote]Ha ha ha!!! Holy shit.
|
i see what red0 is saying despite the, um, choice of words
|
Of course, because an album CAN'T be liked by several people. That'd be silly.
|
Don't bother arguing with red0. He is convinced that he is the only person on the site who is not a slave to the bandwagon.
|
he is so not a slave to the bandwagon that he manages to consider a creed album 'excellent'!!
|
I saw a lot of these coming but it's not like that's a big deal/problem. Also glad to have heard (and enjoyed) the #1 album, considering I didn't even know about half the top 50 from last year.
|
This list shows why I like sputnik :D
|
I'm surprised 6 wasn't number 2 tbh.
Im downloading 7, 3 and 2 now because of this list. 7 sounds fantastic so far.
|
I think red0 was trying to say that whatever staff really promoted on here got the most lovin by the end of the year... but i could be wrong and that could just make too much sense
|
aw Fleet Foxes got jipped, oh well. Great work.
|
how shocking that the staff consensus list would feature albums liked by the staff
|
I can't believe those bandwagon jumping idiots would rank albums they like the most higher than the ones they don't like as much. It's ****ing mindblowing bandwagon ****shit.
|
Predictable, utterly utterly predictable.
And of course, because I knew that Cynic would be number one, no matter how awesome it was, and no matter how deserving of that spot it may have been, this list fails. Simply because I knew that Cynic would be #1.
My logic is undeniable.
|
Guys, you need to stop congratulation yourselves for predicting this list. We've spent the entire year discussing our love (and occasionally dislike) for these albums. It's not as if we were going to pick a bunch of albums we hadn't reviewed or rated highly before.
|
*Sigh*
Yeah, I know, I know..."Sarcasm doesn't translate well online" and all that...
|
Overall, a pretty decent list. I kept looking for Fleet Foxes and Vampire Weekend, and was quite surprised, but glad when I didn't find them. The Mars Volta was a bit high on the list, I think, and I can't believe that album came out in 08 because it seems like its been out forever.
Theres a lot of albums on here I realized I missed over the year, and I'm gonna have to check them out. Some I did listen to and didn't like (Bon Iver, Deerhunter), some I know I just know I won't like (Butch Walker, Girl Talk), and some that I would never have checked out if I didn't browse this sight (Cynic, pg.lost). Overall, this year was not as good as years past, and while I did discover a lot of good music, most of it was not released this year.
Here's to a better 2009, and looking forward to new Glassjaw and Brand New albums.
|
I do not love everything here, but all in all this is way better than any other staff list by any other musicsite I've seen this year.
|
#1 wasn't predictable at all I swear.
|
^ Agreed
but this is still pretty boss
|
i was looking for vampire weekend and fleet foxes too, only i was very disappointed to not find them. them be good records.
|
Actually I was very glad that neither Fleet Foxes nor Vampire Weekend ended up in the list.
|
Eh, Fleet Foxes was pretty good...Vampire Weekend not so much.
|
Only thing I missed was Elbow their album, there was not much talk about them. Sadly ...
|
That banner is easily the best part of this list!
|
banner is obv a rip off of the silent circus (btbam) cover
|
TV on the Radio was probably my favourite discovery this year.
|
|