Members with Neutral Milk Hotel on their favorites list:

antala AnyColour74 Apocalyptic Raids Apollyon Arrakakaka BringHomeTheBacon Bron-Yr-Aur Cacophonaut CaptainPhat Daedelus Dimes Make Dollars Electric City FlawedPerfection francesfarmer GleamInRanks Greilisdead injured234 Iscariot IsItLuck? jacobdixon JAD jamaisvoo John Paul Harrison joshuatree JOutlaw15 JumpTheF**kUp Kyle LordSalohcin21 lunchforthesky maneva masada McP3000 mortimerjstyles Muisee near a mountain nicool nutty_bar Olive Juice pyrox02 Radiodivision85 Regan Farquhar Reillyr something vague Spectrum Time timothyzha TojesDolan ToolBox Two-Headed Boy