| | User Rating |
| 1 |  | Defeater Lost Ground Hardcore | 4.33 51 votes |
| 2 |  | Nirvana Live At Reading Grunge | 4.25 46 votes |
| 3 |  | Immolation Majesty and Decay Death Metal | 4.21 26 votes |
| 4 |  | Minus The Bear Into The Mirror EP Alt Rock | 4.14 38 votes |
| 5 |  | Karnivool Sound Awake Progressive | 4.14 206 votes |
| 6 |  | Shpongle Ineffable Mysteries From Shpongleland Electronica | 4.13 77 votes |
| 7 |  | Paul Dempsey Everything Is True Alt & Indie | 4.13 39 votes |
| 8 |  | Eleventh He Reaches London Hollow Be My Name Post Hardcore | 4.12 61 votes |
| 9 |  | Mono Hymn To The Immortal Wind Post Rock | 4.11 344 votes |
| 10 |  | Propagandhi Supporting Caste Punk | 4.1 272 votes |
| 11 |  | Rx Bandits Mandala Rock | 4.1 279 votes |
| 12 |  | John Frusciante The Empyrean Alt Rock | 4.09 158 votes |
| 13 |  | Rodrigo y Gabriela 11:11 Other | 4.09 69 votes |
| 14 |  | The Lawrence Arms Buttsweat and Tears Punk | 4.07 21 votes |
| 15 |  | Trapped Under Ice Secrets of the World Hardcore | 4.07 22 votes |
| 16 |  | Orbs Asleep Next To Science Progressive | 4.06 43 votes |
| 17 |  | Empire! Empire! (I Was A Lonely Estate) What It Takes To Move Forward Indie | 4.06 53 votes |
| 18 |  | Maybeshewill Sing The Word Hope In Four-Part Harmony Post Rock | 4.05 116 votes |
| 19 |  | Manchester Orchestra Mean Everything To Nothing Indie | 4.04 349 votes |
| 20 |  | Do Make Say Think Other Truths Post Rock | 4.04 97 votes |
| 21 |  | Raekwon Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... Pt II Hip-Hop | 4.04 197 votes |
| 22 |  | Hilltop Hoods State of the Art Hip-Hop | 4.04 40 votes |
| 23 |  | fun. Aim and Ignite Indie Pop | 4.03 284 votes |
| 24 |  | HORSE The Band Desperate Living Metalcore | 4.03 227 votes |
| 25 |  | Converge Axe To Fall Metalcore | 4.03 602 votes |
| 26 |  | BATS Red In Tooth & Claw Post Hardcore | 4.03 117 votes |
| 27 |  | Mew No More Stories Alt & Indie | 4.03 197 votes |
| 28 |  | Devin Townsend Project Addicted Progressive | 4.02 159 votes |
| 29 |  | Megadeth Endgame Thrash | 4.02 438 votes |
| 30 |  | Therapy? Crooked Timber Rock | 4.02 25 votes |
| 31 |  | Buckethead A Real Diamond In The Rough Other | 4.02 29 votes |
| 32 |  | Ulcerate Everything is Fire Death Metal | 4.01 111 votes |
| 33 |  | Gavin Castleton Home Alt & Indie | 4.01 76 votes |
| 34 |  | Orphans of Cush White Noize Hip-Hop | 4 34 votes |
| 35 |  | Strike Anywhere Iron Front Punk | 4 26 votes |
| 36 |  | P.O.S. Never Better Hip-Hop | 4 190 votes |
| 37 |  | maudlin of the Well Part the Second Progressive | 3.99 233 votes |
| 38 |  | Strung Out Agents Of The Underground Punk | 3.99 73 votes |
| 39 |  | Animal Collective Merriweather Post Pavilion Indie | 3.99 732 votes |
| 40 |  | Rishloo Feathergun Progressive | 3.99 42 votes |
| 41 |  | Sole and the Skyrider Band Plastique Hip-Hop | 3.99 41 votes |
| 42 |  | Sun of the Blind Skullreader Black Metal | 3.98 30 votes |
| 43 |  | A Wilhelm Scream A Wilhelm Scream Punk | 3.98 57 votes |
| 44 |  | The Antlers Hospice Indie | 3.98 247 votes |
| 45 |  | Alice in Chains Black Gives Way to Blue Grunge | 3.98 308 votes |
| 46 |  | Trophy Scars Bad Luck Post Hardcore | 3.98 130 votes |
| 47 |  | And So I Watch You From Afar And So I Watch You From Afar Post Rock | 3.98 86 votes |
| 48 |  | Animal Collective Fall Be Kind Indie | 3.98 221 votes |
| 49 |  | Epica Design Your Universe Metal | 3.97 38 votes |
| 50 |  | Cormorant Metazoa Metal | 3.97 55 votes |
| 51 |  | Touche Amore ...To The Beat Of A Dead Horse Emo | 3.97 35 votes |
| 52 |  | Funebrarum The Sleep of Morbid Dreams Death Metal | 3.97 47 votes |
| 53 |  | Matthew Good Band Vancouver Alt Rock | 3.97 31 votes |
| 54 |  | Consider the Thief Signs and Wonders Post Hardcore | 3.97 31 votes |
| 55 |  | Cobalt Gin Black Metal | 3.96 42 votes |
| 56 |  | Emery ...In Shallow Seas We Sail Post Hardcore | 3.96 333 votes |
| 57 |  | Panopticon Collapse Black Metal | 3.96 66 votes |
| 58 |  | Various Artists (Indie) Dark Was The Night Alt & Indie | 3.96 70 votes |
| 59 |  | Every Time I Die New Junk Aesthetic Metalcore | 3.95 271 votes |
| 60 |  | Bomb the Music Industry! Scrambles Punk | 3.95 69 votes |
| 61 |  | Shining VI - Klagopsalmer Black Metal | 3.95 57 votes |
| 62 |  | Irepress Sol Eye Sea I Post Rock | 3.95 74 votes |
| 63 |  | Florence and the Machine Lungs Alt & Indie | 3.95 92 votes |
| 64 |  | Omar Rodriguez-Lopez Xenophanes Psychedelic | 3.94 45 votes |
| 65 |  | Geist Galeere Black Metal | 3.94 25 votes |
| 66 |  | The Dear Hunter Act III: Life and Death Alt Rock | 3.94 139 votes |
| 67 |  | Between The Buried And Me The Great Misdirect Metal | 3.94 626 votes |
| 68 |  | Scale The Summit Carving Desert Canyons Progressive | 3.93 105 votes |
| 69 |  | Russian Circles Geneva Post Rock | 3.93 94 votes |
| 70 |  | Thy Catafalque Róka Hasa Rádió Metal | 3.93 21 votes |
| 71 |  | Say Anything Say Anything Pop Punk | 3.93 226 votes |
| 72 |  | Kalisia Cybion Metal | 3.93 74 votes |
| 73 |  | Augury Fragmentary Evidence Death Metal | 3.92 72 votes |
| 74 |  | Paradise Lost Faith Divides Us - Death Unites Us Metal | 3.91 77 votes |
| 75 |  | A Fine Frenzy Bomb In A Birdcage Pop | 3.9 21 votes |
| 76 |  | Castevet Summer Fences Indie | 3.9 26 votes |
| 77 |  | Mastodon Crack the Skye Metal | 3.9 994 votes |
| 78 |  | Isis Wavering Radiant Metal | 3.9 450 votes |
| 79 |  | Peste Noire Ballade cuntre lo Anemi francor Black Metal | 3.9 35 votes |
| 80 |  | Thrice Beggars Post Hardcore | 3.9 594 votes |
| 81 |  | Pelican Ephemeral EP Metal | 3.9 48 votes |
| 82 |  | Harvard The Inevitable And I Post Hardcore | 3.89 23 votes |
| 83 |  | Sights And Sounds Monolith Post Hardcore | 3.89 36 votes |
| 84 |  | Foo Fighters Greatest Hits Rock | 3.89 31 votes |
| 85 |  | Katatonia Night Is The New Day Metal | 3.89 216 votes |
| 86 |  | Animals as Leaders Animals as Leaders Metal | 3.88 100 votes |
| 87 |  | Cymbals Eat Guitars Why There Are Mountains Indie | 3.88 130 votes |
| 88 |  | Death [Punk] ...For the Whole World to See Punk | 3.88 26 votes |
| 89 |  | The Red Chord Fed Through the Teeth Machine Death Metal | 3.88 231 votes |
| 90 |  | Weekend Nachos Unforgivable Hardcore | 3.88 47 votes |
| 91 |  | Cave In Planets of Old Metalcore | 3.88 98 votes |
| 92 |  | Phoenix Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix Indie Pop | 3.88 178 votes |
| 93 |  | Dethklok The Dethalbum II Death Metal | 3.88 146 votes |
| 94 |  | Bill Callahan Sometimes I Wish We Were an Eagle Folk | 3.88 25 votes |
| 95 |  | Poison The Well The Tropic Rot Metalcore | 3.88 210 votes |
| 96 |  | Gallows Grey Britain Punk | 3.88 174 votes |
| 97 |  | Shrinebuilder Shrinebuilder Metal | 3.88 24 votes |
| 98 |  | DOOMRIDERS Darkness Come Alive Metal | 3.87 47 votes |
| 99 |  | Coalesce OX EP Hardcore | 3.87 35 votes |
| 100 |  | Brand New Daisy Alt Rock | 3.87 720 votes |