Ludwig van Beethoven
"Appassionata" Piano Sonata No. 23 in F minor, Op. 57


4.5
superb

Review

by ShakerFaker USER (32 Reviews)
December 17th, 2015 | 23 replies


Release Date: 1807 | Tracklist

Review Summary: Appassionata exudes both virtuosity - untouched by most of us, and commonly understood meaning.

1804 - the year Piano Sonata in F Minor was composed found Beethoven amidst dynamic changes occurring in his musical world and in himself. Composing during a transitional period, Beethoven waded through Classical and Romantic sensibilities, battling convention imposed by tonal harmony and proper compositional form. Intensifying compositional dilemmas were his own personal struggles, specifically his ear situation - by 1800, his ears had so far diminished that his 1800s pieces sound distinctly different from his eighteenth century repertory.

Piano Sonata in F Minor voices Beethoven's out-of-control, tumultuous experiences that defined his post-1700s career, and bled into his songwriting. He began expressing man's ability to surmount the earth's powerful, natural forces. Instead of resigning himself to his sad condition, Beethoven pushed forward with new personality, and created possibly his most emotional and challenging composition in Piano Sonata in F Minor.

Clocking in at just over 20 minutes, Piano Sonata in F Minor is rightfully known as Appassionata. Following 3-movement form - Allegro Assai, Andante con moto, and Allegro ma non troppo, Appassionata advances with fast-slow-fast pacing, first emerging with synchronous ominous heaviness and delicacy. Opening with trills and arpeggios in F Minor, sequences of notes then progress with urgent definition, traversing from the keyboard's deep underbelly to the light, flighty upper-register. Accompanying the foreboding, almost harsh first motif, Beethoven built a second, similar lyrical path that soothes built intensity from the prior trajectory with warmth. This warmth conserves sanity, as sudden switches from pianissimo to fortissimo seem unexceptional in Allegro Assai's latter half.

A calm, easy return to tradition, Andante liberates itself from agitation present in the Allegro. Although seeming a smidgen underwhelming at times, this movement provides an essential break to absorb a tempestuous third movement, which succeeds in crushing tonality at one moment, calling upon another motif at another, and at last reasserting tonality with powerful certainty. Allegro ma non troppo's where Beethoven conquered his mounting troubles.

As much a story as a vast display of notes, Piano Sonata in F Minor exudes both virtuosity - untouched by most of us, as well as commonly understood lyrical meaning.

Listen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tdg-DT8rTUQ



Recent reviews by this author
Giuseppe Tartini "Devil's Trill Sonata" Violin Sonata in G minorLubomyr Melnyk Illirion
Richard Strauss Tone Poem: Also sprach ZarathustraEsperanza Spalding Emily's D+Evolution
Kanye West The Life of PabloSofia Gubaidulina Repentance
user ratings (40)
4.5
superb


Comments:Add a Comment 
ShakerFaker
December 17th 2015


215 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Written in honor of Beethoven's birthday, so 4.5, but probably somewhere between 4.0 and 4.5 for me.

LepreCon
December 17th 2015


5481 Comments


Big mistake taking music studies in Secondary (High) School, made me hate some of the otherwise magnificent works I had to study, such as this one, took me almost a decade to regain my appreciation. Solid review brah

Archelirion
December 17th 2015


6594 Comments


Really enjoyed this review, pos'd :] I'm definitely aiming towards increasing my classical listening both at the very end of this year and through 2016, and Beethoven's gonna feature quite a bit I think. This is almost as much a visually awe-inspiring piece as it is musically... almost.

PowerBlitz
December 17th 2015


131 Comments


Never had to much of a taste for classical western music but you know. Nice review man.

Ocean of Noise
December 17th 2015


10970 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

I actually don't like this sonata all that much compared to most of the other Beethoven ones. It sort of meanders, especially in the first movement.

Atari
Staff Reviewer
December 18th 2015


27945 Comments


I like this one, nice to see a review for it. gonna read later!

TheSonomaDude
December 18th 2015


9060 Comments


Who?

Satellite
December 18th 2015


26539 Comments


just some fleeting hipster tripe

Supercoolguy64
December 18th 2015


11786 Comments


the google game they made for his brithday is pretty fun

Insurrection
December 18th 2015


24844 Comments


auto-pos for beethoven

need to hear this one

Atari
Staff Reviewer
December 18th 2015


27945 Comments


surprised you haven't heard this one Ins, I'm sure you'd love it

nice review too

ShakerFaker
December 19th 2015


215 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Hmm yeah this definitely does meander in the first movement, but the second movement is tight and the third movement resolves itself nicely which kind of patches the first movement up too I think. But yeah I can see how that might turn you off

Lelle
December 19th 2015


2766 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I feel the wording is a bit too archaic at times. You don't have to write in a pretentious manner just because it's classical music.

Lasting just over 20 minutes, during which the performing pianist must abandon any previously enjoyed comfort so they can alternatively subject their bodies to spectacular torment, Piano Sonata in F Minor is rightfully known as Appassionata


I'm a classical pianist and I'm not sure what you mean by this

the tempestuous third movement, which manages to completely crush tonality at one moment


It never leaves the tonal harmonic world so you might wanna edit that.

But I love the promoting and reviewing of classical music so keep it up, pos'd

ShakerFaker
December 19th 2015


215 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

thank you for the feedback! fair criticism i can see how this is pretentious although i don't really see any archaic wording?



and, i never meant it completely leaves the tonal harmonic world just that it abruptly switches key, which crushes the tonality?

TheSonomaDude
December 19th 2015


9060 Comments


How hard does this riff?

Lelle
December 20th 2015


2766 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Perhaps "archaic" was the wrong word, I'm just referring to that there is a prevalent use of words and sentences that I perhaps would not use in a review with a more conversational writing tone. "mollify" "smidgen" "as sudden switches from pianissimo to fortissimo are unexceptional in the latter half of the first movement" etc



"and, i never meant it completely leaves the tonal harmonic world just that it abruptly switches key, which crushes the tonality? "



In terms of harmonic progression he is never that controversial. Perhaps you are referring to the transition from the exposition to the development, which contains an unexpected twist where, in the place we expect he will go from the dominant to the tonic (f minor) he replaces the tonic with a diminished chord that functionally acts as a F7 chord, which is the dominant to the b flat minor tonality of the development section. While the switch is unexpected and made even harsher by the loud dynamic, in terms of harmonic progression he is just moving along the circle of fifths.





I'm sorry, I'm a nerd and I know this is kind of nitpicking lol

Lelle
December 20th 2015


2766 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

How hard does this riff?




Very hard.

LaughingSkull
December 20th 2015


860 Comments


autopos for any classical music reviews!

Doctuses
September 7th 2018


1914 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

bump

Zig
November 23rd 2018


2747 Comments


This is good.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy