this cd is 5/5... I like it as much as dookie, even though they are a hell of alot different.

great review, awsome album...green day rocks

I saw them perform Jesus of Suburbia, Holiday/Boulevard of Broken Dreams, and When September Ends on TV, and I liked it, but I'm not sure if I want to buy the album.

sick review, i like a lot of green days older stuff, but wow, this is good

Yeah. American Idiot has the musical maturity of Warning, the lyrical genius of 39/Smooth, and the fun of Nimrod. Add them together and you get a genre-defining experience like Dookie.

woooooo it went strate in at #1 here.... i don't pay much attashion to the charts but its good to see an album that really desivers to be there, to be there...

I like the new album,alot. I recently picked up kerplunk and it is ALOT different.

ive farted better music

its good but its not better than dookie.

I love this album. Being a huge Green Day fan I didn't expect this to ever top the other albums but I was pleasantly suprised.

I had the exact same feelings.

good review, i dont like green day, so i wont be buying this cd

when i first heard the song american idiot i thought that it was a sign that greenday should split but the rest of the album is so good i dont know why they should stop. great album and great review. cheers mate

tazu now what i said back there was rash
i didnt give this album a good enough chance
but now i have and i must say i like it and about the fouth guy i just wish they would give him credit intead of them hiding him and making the band seem like a trio n such
i must say after listenin to homcomming its my fav. on the cd (funny how i said i didnt like it but its funny when u open your mind and give things chances how much your taste and opion can change)

Same here

[QUOTE=dumb]Great review.

I love Green Day and I would have to say they are the only punk band that I really like.[/QUOTE]

Someone's going to have to break the news to you eventually. Not me!

I'm not a Green Day fan, but I downloaded this album for some reason. It's not too bad actually, nothing mindblowing but definitely much better than all the other pop-punk that's around at the moment.

Extraordinary Girl is just pathetic though. "She's an extraordinary girl, in an ordinary world". Ugh.

[QUOTE=Iai]Depends if he means the band or the footballer.[/QUOTE]

I wasn't aware of a band or football player named Rooney, I was thinking Andy Rooney from 60 Minutes.

[QUOTE=OpaqueNights224]ps. what happened to mike dirnt and his creative basslines???[/QUOTE]

i don't know :upset:

[QUOTE=justinw]I wasn't aware of a band or football player named Rooney, I was thinking Andy Rooney from 60 Minutes.[/QUOTE]

he either meant Wayne Rooney, or that band that was on the OC.

if i had five thumbs i would do this :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: GREEN DAY RULES YOUR LIFE