Coheed and Cambria In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth: 3
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
biografiend
July 21st 2004


55 Comments


[QUOTE=IsItLuck?] They are getting almost too mainstream and switching from one of my favorite record labels could be a turn for the worst, I really hope they don't go downhill. [/QUOTE] totally agree with you. this was the first coheed cd i got, and i was hooked the first time i heard it. The Light & the Glass and 2113 are my favorite songs. I love this cd, but i think SSTB is more raw, and consistantly good. Awesome review, RollerQueen. :thumb:

RollerQueen
July 21st 2004


209 Comments


Thanks a bunchizzle.

If Claudio knows what's good for him, he'll keep it up. My brother knows his friends and they'll kill if Co&Ca sell out. I wonder what they'll do once the story in album form is complete...

Horace
October 3rd 2004


18 Comments


This was an OK review for one of my favorite albums. Good job, though.

Horace
October 3rd 2004


18 Comments


[QUOTE=StardogChampion]I have come to the conclusion that Coheed and Cambria is just Rush with a more annoying voice, and without the talent.[/QUOTE]

I've come to the conclusion that you're just crap. :thumb:

Amp'd
October 4th 2004


33 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

im trying to download the whole album (dont flame me i live in New Zealand and i cant find it anywhere(and amazon etc dont ship to NZ)). but is the ring in return just a phone ringing and then just some really quiet noises for seven minutes?



My Second Favourite Band Of All Time!!!!!!!!!!!

The_One
October 4th 2004


32 Comments


Just wondering. Do you guys know why they have those 6 -7 tracks that are just like 6 seconds long each before the secret track? I was wondering why they did that. For a second there I thought there were like 6 bonus songs on it or something.

Tapeworm
October 4th 2004


118 Comments


Amp'd - The Ring in Return is juat a phone ringing and then some organs but it doesn;t go for 7 minutes...

PeEpHoLe_10
October 8th 2004


31 Comments


I picked this up yesterday. Good reveiw, really good album.

YDload
October 10th 2004


1207 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Hey, if you read through this whole thread, you'll see my transformation as barely-interested into a converted fan. Anyway, I was listening to this just recently, and the secret track has a riff from "Time Consumer" in it! Like, right after that "I've got a secret to hide" part, it goes into those few little riffs from the intro to SSTB's first proper song. And then of course it ends with part of "Iro-Bot," but that connection is obvious.



One other thing I noticed: the title track is in some different time signature. Maybe 6/8 or just 3/4?

Sep
October 10th 2004


300 Comments


[QUOTE=YDload]Hey, if you read through this whole thread, you'll see my transformation as barely-interested into a converted fan. Anyway, I was listening to this just recently, and the secret track has a riff from "Time Consumer" in it! Like, right after that "I've got a secret to hide" part, it goes into those few little riffs from the intro to SSTB's first proper song. And then of course it ends with part of "Iro-Bot," but that connection is obvious.

One other thing I noticed: the title track is in some different time signature. Maybe 6/8 or just 3/4?[/QUOTE]

Yeah the title track's time signature is very strange. The drum beat sounds easy when you hear it, but for me it's almost impossible to figure out what he's playing.

RollerQueen
October 10th 2004


209 Comments


I'd say 6/4 or 12/8 but I haven't taken a music class in too long. I play the verse riff almost every time I pick up my guitar but I never thought too much about the time signature... Whoops.

SubtleDagger
October 10th 2004


737 Comments


It's in either 6/8 or 12/8, depending on how they take it.

me_want_a_good_guitar
October 11th 2004


2 Comments


Originally Posted by unknownsk8er88
Same here i was just about too review it but then i found this one

argh i was gonna review it too. then i decided to review alkaline trio. it was god****it it think.

Horace
October 13th 2004


18 Comments


Why do y'all hate A Favor House Atlantic? It's one of my favorite tracks on the album. I know it was played all the time on mtv2, but this is one of the rare times that I'm ****ing in love with a popular single. The video is actually my favorite music video of all time.

npstaind
October 14th 2004


1 Comments


i hate these guys, the singer is a fruit and the songs blow too. :lol: :evil:

YDload
October 14th 2004


1207 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

[QUOTE=npstaind]i hate these guys, the singer is a fruit and the songs blow too. :lol: :evil:[/QUOTE]



Antarctica is the driest continent on Earth. PS: Staind fans have no voice when it comes to deciding good or bad music.

Luxor
October 14th 2004


166 Comments


I'm missing them play tonight because my parents won't let me go.

IsItLuck?
Emeritus
October 14th 2004


4957 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

[QUOTE=YDload]Antarctica is the driest continent on Earth. PS: Staind fans have no voice when it comes to deciding good or bad music.[/QUOTE]



That's why the Alter Bridge fan club thread is so long. Because they think they know what they are talking about :thumb:



I have heard many people who said coheed sucks, I guess it is sort of an acquire taste. I for one love coheed, music is brilliantly written, songs never get old. The MTV fan-base should perish, I hate people who live off radio and TV for their musical source. To see them all singing a favor house atlantic at the concerts and knowing all the words to that song and none others song lyrics makes me wonder.



Bad luck @ the mother not letting you go. They are excellent live, I saw them 4 times :x

Cain
October 14th 2004


156 Comments


Welcome, IsItLuck. Nice to see that you can't even show your face in the Alter Bridge thread itself to diss the band; you have to waste space in the Coheed and Cambria forum to do it. What a big tough guy that knows so much more about music than I do. :rolleyes:

Anyway, Coheed and Cambria were probably a bit easier for me to get into than most, me being an enormous Rush fan. It makes me quite used to the high-pitched vocals. The vocal style gets creepy at times, but the band's synthesis of emo, metal guitar riffs, and punk is very effective. "In Keeping Secrets of Silent Earth" is a truly amazing song that probably wins for my favorite one on the album. The Crowing and the Velorium Camper Trilogy are really awesome as well. Titling the secret track "2113" seems to be sacrilige to me, but that's just the Rush fanboyism kicking in again. I like how the band isn't afraid to show that they know a little about music in their playing.

Plus, Claudio wrote the songs on an eight-track studio his parents got him! Is that an omen? (I have a four-track on which I write all my songs, and the guitars have ended up being simarly orchestrated as they do on Coheed's.) Hope so. Another reason I feel a sort of kinship with the band.

JMann
October 14th 2004


12 Comments


I first heard the song IKSSE:3 in Forced Listening and I had the get the album. Definately money well spent. I love every song. I still have yet to get their first album, although I've heard a few songs from it.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy