Album Rating: 4.5

I'd say the water EP specifically is arguably their best work.

"The Alchemy Index Vol. II: Wat" [2]

Water EP is one of the best things these guys have ever done. Night Diving, Open Water, The Whaler, all perfect

Also, you're becoming a really good writer Calc

Album Rating: 5.0

Heck yea!



Love this.

wow this is really good so far

This whole set is phenomenal, but yeah Water and Air were always my favorites. The 9/11 references in Broken Lungs still send chills.

Saw them play Fire & Water opening for Brand New, I actually think at points they stole the show.

Of course, then Brand New opened with Limousine and I practically wept.