Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
JFK
December 25th 2004


16 Comments


Man, where to begin....The greatest album of all time, or at least top 3.

keep on phishin'
December 25th 2004


71 Comments


This is my second favorite Pink Floyd album, right behind Animals

Syncratic
December 28th 2004


756 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Just got this for Christmas, and I have to say this is one of the greatest albums of all time....I have no favorite tracks, it's all good.

experimental_cheese
January 3rd 2005


1 Comments


Favourite Pink Floyd albums:
1. The Wall (simply for Comfortably Numb)
2. Wish You Were Here
3. Dark Side of the Moon

[QUOTE=jimmydean]the best Pink Floyd album is the greatest hits album. duh. :lol:[/QUOTE]
Although I have never heard the greatest hits album, I thoroughly doubt that it would be any good. Each album has a different feel to it and all the songs blend in so well with each other. Mixing them together just wouldn't have that same feel.

Kingofdudes
January 3rd 2005


294 Comments


Great Review Subtle

This is my second favorite Pink Floyd album(behind Animals). SOYCD pt.2 on "David Gilmour in Concert" is brilliant.

Doop
January 3rd 2005


14 Comments


Love this album.
Awesome review.

newWorld
January 4th 2005


24 Comments


This album rocks ***. I still like The Wall, Animals and Dark Side better.

Orange Fog
January 4th 2005


1 Comments


GREAT review man!

My fav PF albums are:
1) Animals
2) Wish You Were Here
3) Dark Side of The Moon
4) Meddle
5) The Wall
6) Piper at The Gates of Dawn

Kingofdudes
January 25th 2005


294 Comments


I think Pink Floyd older music rocks, but I think their newer material isn't as good


So you really think A Saucer Full of Secrets is better than Wish you Were Here?

Knoxvillelives
February 4th 2005


342 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Best cover ever man

I love it

intheflesh?
February 27th 2005


6 Comments


awsome album.i wonder if they actaully lit a dude on fire for the cover.haha

classicrockielzpfvh
March 14th 2005


7 Comments


this is my girlfriends and my favorite pinkfloyd album next to Dark Side of the Moon and The Wall tour Live

AntiLopa
May 25th 2005


7 Comments


Great review .
;P

But , to be honest , i didn't really like this album . I don't really get what's so amazing about it . Yes it has wonderful songs , especially "Wish You Were Here" ( which is btw IMO one of the best songs ever) , but not amazing . I actually got somewhat frustrated of listeting to "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" , and even bored from "Welcome To The Machine" , which is btw IMO , is the worst song on this album . I liked "Atom Heart Mother" more than that , and even "Division Bell" , the , unfortunately , underrated album of Pink Floyd.



temporary
June 2nd 2005


207 Comments


Ouststanding review of an increadable album. Easily my favorite Pink Floyd album, along with Dark Side of the Moon, Animals, and the Wall (basically all of the ones from the 70s, except Meddle.) Wish You Were Here is one of the greatest songs ever recorded!

robo2448
June 2nd 2005


132 Comments


Great review. Awesome Cd. My favorite PF cds:
Pulse: Live 1994
Wish You Were Here
Animals
The Wall
DSOTM
PATGOD.

I really love them all though and on this list, the last 4 are literally interchangeable and will probably be different tomorrow. However, this and Pulse are always at the top of my list.


br3ad_man
Emeritus
June 2nd 2005


2125 Comments


Great album, Floyd's best imo. Good review also.

My list:

1. Wish You Were Here
2. Animals
3. Dark Side of the Moon
4. Piper At The Gates of Dawn
5. Meddle

Jawaharal
June 8th 2005


1832 Comments


rolling stone has a couple of their albums on the greatest album list and they did realease the best album ever dsotm and still they are not even included in rolling stones 100 greatest artist of all time? eminem got on that list but pink floyd didn't..........

FrddyBrnRgrJhn
June 18th 2005


81 Comments


robo2448, if you like pulse, that's cool. I have a suggestion for you though. If you really want to ruin your favorite pink floyd album of all time, get a copy of the dvd. it's pretty pathetic (in my opinion at least). My favorite floyd albums are:

1. Atom Heart Mother (SOOO underrated)
2. Animals
3. Dark Side of the Moon
4. Wish You Were Here
5. The Wall Live (which i still don't own, i'm waiting for my friend to burn it for me)

i still love the syd barrett stuff (arnold layne, jugband blues, the gnome, interstellar overdrive), but it gets weird and quirky at times. i think a saucerful of secrets is amazing, but it doesnt stand out as an album that really flows well. another highly underrated one is ummagumma. the live disc is incredible, and the studio disc is great if you're into that kinda stuff

DesolationRow
June 18th 2005


833 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

This album changed the way I look at music. The title track is so amazing. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is my favorite PF song along with Dogs. Great Review.

Killtacular
June 18th 2005


1314 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

My favorite album ever. An easy 5/5 for Floyd's magnum opus. SoYcD is my favorite Floyd tune, as well. This Message Edited On 06.18.05



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





FAQ // STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // SITE FORUM // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2014 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Privacy Policy