i never said i disliked this album my rating is probably a 4 like yankee's just think it's pretty overrated.

and thanks for including crystal logic, operation mindcrime and rising and sad wings all undisputable classics

Digging: The Wonder Years - The Greatest Generation

Album Rating: 4.0

sea leave NIN, In Flames, Dark Tranquility, Townsend, Priest, Queensryche, Dio, and Manilla Road out of this

Digging: Klaus Nomi - Klaus Nomi

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

album is amazing. who cares if its as good as old swans albums theyre practically different bands

Album Rating: 4.0

Atari if you think this album is a 4 then thats only .1 less than the average so how the friggit does that make it overrated? Do you hear yourself speak?

do you even read my comments.?

all i said was this ISN'T a masterpiece. a masterpiece would imply it's a 5/5 i think a lot of user's overrated it quit getting in pointless arguments man.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

glad yankee's here to stick up for mediocre metal music
and wait then
what would you rate it atari?
edit: /implying ratings are somewhat important lol but still

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

was this my favorite album to come out last year no

do i think it was probably the best yes

@SeaAnemone,

I'd have to give it another spin if i'm gonna rate it. I heard it a few times when Sowing reviewed it and I thought it was good prolly 3.5 to 4 just don't think it's a classic.

not gonna argue about it though

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

the discourse on this album is seriously worse than when michaeljordan started talking about ctts

i don't like this album :'(

Album Rating: 4.0

Not my fault you cant metal sea Im sorry im not a whiny bich who strokes it to empire empire i was a sad lonely diltch

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

it's funny bc I have much better taste in metal than a guy that devotes all his music listening to it

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

atari: "album is painfully overrated on sputnik"
"I'd put it at like a 4"
Album rating on sputnik: 4.1

(lol)

lol when i say it's painfully overrated i'm not even looking at the overall score just all the user's who 5'd it ;)

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

"was this my favorite album to come out last year no

do i think it was probably the best yes"

"the discourse on this album is seriously worse than when michaeljordan started talking about ctts"

well said and well said, but I did enjoy that latter discussion

let's all be nice in swans - the seer thread : )

what what swans say about our quarreling???

Album Rating: 5.0

Definitely best album of last year.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

"lol when i say it's painfully overrated i'm not even looking at the overall score just all the user's who 5'd it ;)"

one time a guy rated Pink Floyd's Animals a 1
God Sputnik underrates that album so much
it's like nobody's ever heard it and nobody likes it

"let's all be nice in swans - the seer thread : )"

This. If i admit i was being ignorant and i'll give the album another spin will you guys leave me alone?! ;(