alright I'm getting I Could Live in Hope next (on the third download, fingers crossed this one works). I figured it was between that or Things We Lost in the Fire and I might as well start with their first album (even though I actually started here, their most recent album haha whatever)
I've decided that this is insanely underrated here. I might bump my rating for this; I enjoy it nearly as much as I Could Live in Hope and that's one of my most solid 4.5s