I really wish this could be as good as mmhmm. It's VERY well produced and catchy, but it lacks the soul. Deathbed and Bite My Tongue are the only things that bring this up to a 4 for me. :/
A 4 is pretty high though. I like "Must Have Done Something Right" despite its weak chorus, but it's more of one of those songs you sing to your girlfriend. It's actually how I asked my ex to prom last year (cliche, indeed.)