Album Rating: 4.0

Am I the only one that hears absolutely no similarity to El Cielo? I mean, they both use guitars and drums. Oh, and they both have a singer. Um, that's about it. Either way, I like them both, but this more.

erm el cielo is much better but whatever dude!

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, I know El Cielo is like this site's favorite album. I haven't listened to it enough (I've listened to it 3 times) to give it my rating yet. But I just can't get past the singer's lack of variety. His melodies and vocal delivery seem the same on each song. Inventive music though. I know I'll get bashed for that, but someone could maybe explain to me why that's wrong. Who knows, it could definitely grow on me though.

ya this review's comparisons are retarded

All your comparisons are belong to us

This review comes off as extremely biased. It's way too preoccupied with the comparison between these guys and Saosin.
Basically, it's like this: if you want a great review on how many bands you can compare Circa Survive to and how that automatically means Circa sucks, check out this review. If you want a review about the actual music, ignore this review.

this singer sound a lot like the one in saosinThis Message Edited On 01.16.09

Album Rating: 4.0

i agree, this review and opinion are terrible. i think this album is atmospheric and flows great. and i love anthonys voice. and translating the name is an awesome ep, dumbass.

http://www.petersmeats.com.au/images/beef-recipes.jpg

Album Rating: 2.0

Yawn

Album Rating: 2.0

O snap. Come off it; you haven't done a memorable review since William Control

Album Rating: 2.0

You can hide behind that all you like, but don't bag what I write unless you can do better.

Album Rating: 3.5

who cares about reviews



comments iz where its at

Album Rating: 2.0

whatevs, I know I'm right

Album Rating: 4.0

This review criticizes Green's lack of vocal range because he only has "two types of singing". How many types of singing do we hear on El Cielo? Not hating on Dredg, just making a point; not really a negative aspect of an album.

chan do you think I would like this

gonna branch out

Album Rating: 3.0

which is a part of the concept of the music pretty much

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, but Green supposing to be this amazing singer is nothing that the band or even Green did wrong. That's just other people that created that expectation. Plus, his two types of singing are plenty. Anything more would detract from the music. What else does he need to achieve this diversity that the album sorely needs? Should he have a spoken word section or rap? If he pulled off some Mariah Carey range, it wouldn't sound right with the music. Just saying that's not a good negative point. To each his own though.

this album sounds all the same from what I've heard

Album Rating: 4.0

Act Apalled and In Fear and Faith definitely stand out for me.